View Single Post
  #15   Report Post  
posted to alt.sailing.asa
Joe Joe is offline
external usenet poster
 
First recorded activity by BoatBanter: Jul 2006
Posts: 3,698
Default Ghost and the Sea Wolf

On Jun 7, 7:36 pm, "Capt. Rob" wrote:
Who's we're all? Are you speaking for your puppets or what?

Joe, you believe that I have puppets here??? Okay.

What I was looking for is a well told story with background and
common
sence to match.

Curtiz work often reflected a stylistic approach that required some
imagination and cinematic education from the viewer.

What you call artistic view is about the same thing they did with
the
Perfect Storm. In trying to create an artistic mood they made the
crew
and Skipper of the Andrea Dora look like a boat load of
retards....but
the lubbers ate it up.

Who ate it up? The Perfect Storm was a dissapointment both
economically and critically. The Sea Wolf was popular on both fronts.

I guess if you are watching an artist versions of mariners it
would
be better if you are an baffon lubber and not have a clue so you can
enjoy it and not be bothered by the glaring stupity...huh?

Like I said, you never read the book, You have no idea how stupid you
sound. The Ghost is depicted in the movie much as it was in the book.
Curtiz pushed it further, but even in the book, "Unlike other ships,
the decks of the Ghost lay barren and lonely; her crew hidden away in
fear."
So now we all know that you're not only too stupid to understand a
good movie, but also ignorant of it's famous source.
Well done, Joe!

RB
35s5
NY


Good bubbles...name one 100+ft 3 masted clipper ship that can sail
with just one man at the wheel.. If I need my imigination to streach
that far then I might as well be watching a movie about a Captain
sailing a ship through the desert with sawsquach at the wheel.

The point you seem to miss is that Curtiz screwed the pooch with the
prop and all aspects of seamanship. Again I understand just how easy
it is for you to overlook such glaring errors.

Joe