On Sun, 25 Mar 2007 15:25:03 -0400, Charlie Morgan wrote:

The quality of what they publish in their magazine
would not pass muster in first year journalism classes.

Are you criticizing their writing style, integrity or testing methods?

I've seen one or two cases where they've given the nod to a product
based on subjective perceived quality where all other factors seemed
about equal. That seems fair to me, and probably jibes with how most
of us would make the final decision.