On Feb 16, 8:40 pm, "steve_hayes_maine" wrote:
I guided Boy Scouts down the Allagash in Maine for over a dozen
years. First, canvassed canoes are by far the preferred form of
transportation -- they are flexible and easily repaired (glued on
patch or, in a pinch, super sticky duct tape). Aluminum canoes are
rock magnets. I have seen many, many such canoes hit a rock the other
canoes slid over and tip, with gear, occupants, etc. and then resist
efforts to free them. And there is no repair in the wilderness.

And then you get to the other issue -- noise. Every foot fall
resounds throughout the canoe and the surrounding water. It's
wonderful notice to the trout that you are there. Almost every other
form of canoe is far more silent.

I am amazed at a 45 year old aluminum canoe, which is near miracle.
100 year old wood and canvas canoes, by contrast, are relatively
common. I have a 20' Guide from 1923 that is in fine shape, mainly
because it is so easy to maintain them (and to replace the canvas when
needed).

Steve Hayes

The 45 yr old Grumman survived me and my 8 siblings and has been on
just about every body of water in Florida. Admittedly, it is noisy if
you dont know how to paddle but it is tough. One great characteristic
is that you can feel the temp change of the water through it to tell
when you are near a spring. As far as maintenance goes, it just sits
outside upside down on eh ground with no care at all. Here in Fl, a
wood canoe would be termite food in a week or so.
As kids, we'd take the Grumman to the center of a lake and turn her
over and swim inside it, we'd fill her with water and sit in that if
the outside water was too snakey or alligatorish. This 18' canoe is
huge and light. I dont like kayaks so will probably have the Grumman
for another 30 yrs and pass it on to my kids.