View Single Post
  #89   Report Post  
posted to alt.sailing.asa
Scotty Scotty is offline
external usenet poster
 
First recorded activity by BoatBanter: Jul 2006
Posts: 2,070
Default Google proves MacGregor 26 is flimsy

Hey everybody, Jimbo has discovered what ballast is!

Did you use Google?

SV


"JimC" wrote in message
. com...



The point is that ships have been using ballast in the

lower portions of
their hulls (as does the Mac) for hundreds of years.

Whether it's a tall
ship or short ship, a sailboat or power boat, water or

permanent
ballast, the principle is the same. And most ocean-going

vessels still
use ballast tanks for holding water in the lower portions

of such
vessels. (That's what keeps those container vessels from

tipping over.)

You say that the tall ships are deeper than a Mac. Still,

both used or
use ballast positioned within the hull and below the

waterline.

You say that tall ships didn't use water for ballast.

Right you are. -
That came later (after marine design became more

sophisticated). But
they did use ballast positioned in the lower portion of

the hull, as
does the Mac.

You say that tall ships used stones, brick, etc., rather

than water.
Nevertheless, the same principles apply.

You imply that water ballast is the least desirable. - In

that case,
you should complement MacGregor for adding solid,

permanent ballast to
the 26M in addition to water ballast. Of course, if they

used only
permanent ballast, they would loose the advantages gained

by using
water ballast that can be removed to lighten the boat

during trailoring,
or for high-speed motoring, etc. And if they used only

permanent
ballast, the boat would quickly sink to the bottom in the

event the hull
was seriously compromised, as do most weighted-hull

sailboats.

You say that tall ships are so different from the Mac that

the
comparison is laughable. Nevertheless, the same principles

apply. -
sails acting to power the vessel, keel acting to limit

lateral movement,
and ballast, positioned below the waterline, to lower the

center of mass
and prevent capsizing of the vessel and limit heeling.

Jim