Rope as lifeline replacement [was Lifelines without PVC coating]
I bought my boat two years ago and it has all dacron life lines. I did
not do the installation and am not sure when it was done but I think
about a year before I bought. However, they seem to be holding up
fine. I can only vouch for two years.
One thing, sure is no stretch in it.
Howard
AMPowers wrote:
As a multihull owner interested in saving weight wherever possible I'd
appreciate hearing any insight, opinion, ideas or experience anyone has
with this.
The one concern I've heard from someone who had Kevlar shrouds and stays
on his racing boat's mast was that it was far easier to cut those lines,
resulting in catastrophic loss. I'm not sure how easily Kevlar cuts,
but I would think it is somewhat easier than steel wire.
The concern I'd have for using them as lifelines (as voiced by Gary) is
more about the possibility that the lines might UV degrade, making the
unnoticibly weaker. Given that I intend to couple my life lines with
netting, and also use jack lines and harness when out of the cockpit, I
think this minimizes the issue, but it is worth consideration.
Robb
Roger Long wrote:
I've heard or seen something somewhere about using some of the new super
low stretch rope for lifelines. Has anyone heard about that idea?
Gary wrote:
I have seen many different parts of a boats rigging being replaced with
new high modulus ropes. The multihull world is embracing rope because
of the weight savings. They are certainly strong enough and look good
but the are a couple issues that warrant thought. First of all is the
UV degredation. It is much greater in any rope than in wire and
requires more frequent replacement. The second thing is nicks. Wire
will stand some abuse but a nicked rope will be much weaker. I have
seen a couple boat lose their rigs because of nicks in rope backstays.
Finally the splices in the new ropes are much more challenging and many
require special splices to ensure the strength isn't lost.
It is doable but think about pros and cons first.
Gary
|