Around 2/22/2006 12:58 PM, Martin Schöön wrote:

On Tue, 21 Feb 2006 21:33:34 -0800, Garth Almgren wrote:

The characters may have come across as one-dimensional, but that's
almost exactly how they're portrayed in the later books, when both
Aubrey and Maturin are older and more set in their ways. If you've only
read M&C, you've only read about the younger, more vibrant versions of
those characters.

To me it sounds like I should *not* read the entire series. It sounds
like O'Brian went from inspired author to someone stomping out books
as a routine.

I didn't mean to give that impression; I think the books are all
inspired page-turners, and even after 20-some volumes O'Brian left me
wanting more.

I really hope this is not the case but if the film
is true to how the series develops...

Eh, bad choice of words; "One-dimensional" has such a negative
connotation, and it's not that Aubrey is that in the later books. Let me
put it this way: while maintaining his complexity and signature
boldness, Jack is far less /rash/ in his decisions. He's older and wiser
(a bit), but still the same Jack.


In "Master and Commander" Aubry is a complex guy: A womaniser, vain, great
leader who does want to win but keep the number of dead and wounded down
(so did Cochrane), he finds life as a commander lonely (did you see any of
that in the film??)

They *barely* touched on it, but it was there, most notably the two or
three scenes where Jack's sense of duty came before his friendship with
Stephen.

he is distinctly non-musical (that's how the book starts)...

He's certainly not as good as he thinks he is, in either the movie or
the books. Also true of his punning, for that matter.

In short he has good and bad sides as most of us but in the
film he is just another standardised action hero.

I still say you're watching a different movie.

May I suggest this is a rather futile exchange since seems to
come down to differences in taste?

Nah, that has /never/ happened, in all the history of USENET! How could
you even suggest such a thing?!


Seriously, I still wholeheartedly recommend reading the rest of the
series. Once I got to book three, I couldn't put the series down until I
had read through the everything including the unfinished novel about a
week and a half later.


--
~/Garth - 1966 Glastron V-142 Skiflite: "Blue-Boat"
"There is nothing - absolutely nothing - half so much worth doing
as simply messing about in boats." -- Kenneth Grahame
~~ Ventis secundis, tene cursum ~~