Marty S. wrote:


Note that it is a vehicle for continuing education and professional
development. Thus it is hardly a place to censor material to ensure
only one side of a story is told.

John H




That's a pretty naive thing to say. If the publisher of a journal disagrees
with a particular position, whether academic, scientific, or political, then
it won't publish the article.

I'm not defending or condeming the article in question -- I haven't read it.
I don't have a dog in this fight. But, what you said, John, is just not the
way the world works.

--
Marty S.
Baltimore, MD USA


My wife has two papers under consideration for publication by two
separate professional journals in her field. Both articles and
everything related to them are being carefully vetted and, AFTER that,
they are submitted to the editorial boards for commentary and a vote on
whether they should be published. John's concept of the world is
slightly colored by his years in the military and his inexperience with
the real world.


--
Email sent to is never read.