View Single Post
  #37   Report Post  
Chuck
 
Posts: n/a
Default

It's hard to believe the marine version of the Outbacker was very
efficient, but it probably was better than nothing at all.

Yeah, other than traps, the only other reliable technique I can think of
for a multiband (as opposed to simply a "wideband") antenna is to use
switched, tuned feeders (open wire line stubs actually, cut to tune a
dipole to each band). I have a difficult time imagining that on a
sailboat! Anyway, that stretches the idea of "no tuner", but at least
there are no moving parts other than the band switch.

Well, now that I think of it, there are some common antennas that work
on more than one band without a tuner or traps. A simple 40 meter dipole
(or quarter-wave vertical) ought to work on 15 meters, for example. And
the G5RV, and some sky loop antennas are multiband. A vertical (cut the
horizontal one in half) G5RV would be interesting to consider. I don't
think I've encountered that before and matching might be interesting,
but it may have potential for backstay antennas. These antennas usually
benefit from a rig with a built-in tuner, so maybe they should be
"disqualified" as not tuner-less.

Chuck, NT3G
s/v Sans Serif

Doug Dotson wrote:
I supose that one could make a trap-vertical to avoid a tuner, but
I've never seen one for marine bands. I do recall a version of the
OutBacker that was for marine use but have never known anyone
that had one.

Doug, k3qt
s/v Callista