Well Peter, I have to disagree there. The gravitational force acts only
toward the center of mass of the system. This cannot by itself produce
two bulges. To clarify this, try imagining the forces of gravity in 2D
on a piece of paper. In all cases, water would be pulled toward the
center of the Earth-Moon pair. This would lead to less water on the far
side and more water as you move toward the moon... -two bulges would not
be present.
Cheers
Peter S/Y Anicula wrote:
You make it sound as if the gravitational forces explains the bulge
under the moon and the centrifugal forces explains the bulge on the
side of the earth that turns away from the moon.
That is not right.
The gravitational difference alone can explain that there are bulges
on both side of the earth. That's why it is sometimes the only factor
mentioned when trying to keep the explanation simple.
The centrifugal element can only explain that there is a bulge on the
part of the earth that turns away from the moon.
That is why it is one of the elements (and there are others), that is
sometimes left out of the explanation.
While I think that in some cases it is a good idea to include the
centrifugal element in the explanation, I don't know exactly how many
elements one should include to make it a good explanation - but I
haven't yet seen a complete explanation in a popular publication.
Peter S/Y Anicula
Sailor
The seven seas
|