On Wed, 29 Sep 2004 13:18:41 +0000, Butch Davis wrote:

As a guy who soldiered for 35+ years I'll wade in on this issue.

COL Hackworth was a great combat soldier and a real example to all of us.
I was disappointed by the Ranger Tab issue but it takes nothing from his
proven bravery in battle.

That the "most decorated living soldier" did not rise above the rank of
COL indicates that the Army felt he did not rank above his peers when it
came to important attributes required of senior leaders.

But he did rise to that rank rather quickly, especially considering his
start as an enlisted man (at 15 years old). The Army must have felt
he had some important attributes.

I deeply respect COL Hackworth for his military accomplishments. However
his ability as a journalist leaves me unimpressed.

I wouldn't dispute that, but I will stop and listen to anyone with his
experience and accomplishments.