Came on suddenly, probably building up for a while actually, got the
bareboating bug. Have been to the BVI twice, was thinking it might be fun to
charter in the windward/leeward chain. Any suggestions?

In increasing order of difficulty: Belize (try a catamaran from TMM); St.
Vincent and Grenadines (try Barefoot - see
http://www.usual-suspects-sailing.com/index.html); St.Martin/Anquilla/St. Bart
- try Sunsail or Moorings). All are fantastic and all provide better sailing
than BVI.