On Sunday, January 31, 2016 at 8:01:38 AM UTC-5, John H. wrote:
On Sat, 30 Jan 2016 22:03:19 -0500, Alex wrote:

wrote:
On Thu, 28 Jan 2016 19:21:19 -0500, Alex wrote:


Apple or cherry are nice and mild. Oak will be stronger. Forget
hickory for any fish.
I do mahi over hickory chips on the gas grill. It is pretty good that
way.
I cook it hot and right on the edge of burning. You cook it fast so
the juices are sealed in. Get it off the heat before it is really done
inside and let the carry over heat to the rest. I prefer it fresh but
frozen will work if that is all I can get. Be sure it is thawed and
room temperature before you start cooking so it cooks fast.


I was referring to a smoker at lower temperatures. 250º tops.

Yes, I knew. That's what I meant also. I tried it on the gas grill last night with
the cedar planks underneath. Didn't taste nearly as good as on the smoker.. Might use
the cedar planks as firewood.
--

Ban idiots, not guns!

Did you do it correctly?

Soak the planks in water for an hour.
Toast the planks on the cooking side for a couple of minutes.
Flip over, place the fish, then move to an unheated part of the grill (use indirect heat to cook).

You can use them many times. It's not the same as the smoker, but it's good in a different way.