"Steven Rowe" wrote in message
...
In article , "arachedeux"
writes:

Well they're quite young

why do you say this?
isnt it the oldest still running canoe magazine out there?

It existed in '88 or earlier & changed it's name from Canoe to Canoe & Kayak
while I had a subscription.

I occasionally find a good review in a magazine. The most thorough review
of canoes I've read was in Backpacker in '90. The reviewer, formerly of
Canoe magazine, had several tandem tripping canoes to compare. He had a
bunch of testers ranging in experience from novice to tripping, whitewater &
fla****er competition. Each tester assigned scores to each boat in a bunch
of categories. One boat stood out. It was only second fastest. It sure
wasn't the most maneuverable. But it did everything well enough that it
came out on top when the scores were totalled. It was also the first or
second favourite of every tester, which probably upset makers of the other
canoes, especially if they advertised in Backpacker. I bought that boat
sight unseen & never regretted it. I wouldn't make a decision like that
based on current reviews.

Lloyd