BoatBanter.com

BoatBanter.com (https://www.boatbanter.com/)
-   General (https://www.boatbanter.com/general/)
-   -   B&S 5-HP (https://www.boatbanter.com/general/78829-b-s-5-hp.html)

Danny D. March 6th 07 08:28 AM

B&S 5-HP
 
Does anyone have
exp............................................... .................................................. ......


mystro March 6th 07 08:57 PM

B&S 5-HP
 
On Mar 6, 12:28 am, "Danny D." wrote:
Does anyone have
exp............................................... ..........................*....................... ........


If 5hp would work for me I wouldn't hesitate to purchase the American
Built B&S that's so easy
on fuel and by far the most economical to operate of *any* outboard
engine. I recall all the skepticism
when B&S first intro'd their outboard by so-called *experienced people
in this newsgroup back in 2002 ..they
lambasted it as just an updated lawnmower version which it is
certainly NOT..ignorance was bliss back then. :)

From everything I've read..you'll be hard pressed to find a single

owner who isn't very pleased and if and when it's needs a part..B&S
will not
do what all other marine engine manufacturers do..hit you extremely
hard in the pocketbook and that
includes the original retail price. No, B&S has proven to not only be
an exceptional (half the price) value but
also backs their engines as good or better then anyone. I wish they
made a 15hp.

06 Review from an old fisherman :) http://www.duckworksmagazine.com/03/...p/06/index.htm


mystro March 6th 07 09:00 PM

B&S 5-HP
 
I should have mentioned B&S has 30,000 dealers so you can shop for
prices very easy.


dt March 6th 07 09:26 PM

B&S 5-HP
 
mystro wrote:

On Mar 6, 12:28 am, "Danny D." wrote:

Does anyone have
exp............................................. ...........................*...................... .........



If 5hp would work for me I wouldn't hesitate to purchase the American
Built B&S that's so easy
on fuel and by far the most economical to operate of *any* outboard
engine. I recall all the skepticism
when B&S first intro'd their outboard by so-called *experienced people
in this newsgroup back in 2002 ..they
lambasted it as just an updated lawnmower version which it is
certainly NOT..ignorance was bliss back then. :)

From everything I've read..you'll be hard pressed to find a single

owner who isn't very pleased and if and when it's needs a part..B&S
will not
do what all other marine engine manufacturers do..hit you extremely
hard in the pocketbook and that
includes the original retail price. No, B&S has proven to not only be
an exceptional (half the price) value but
also backs their engines as good or better then anyone. I wish they
made a 15hp.

06 Review from an old fisherman :) http://www.duckworksmagazine.com/03/...p/06/index.htm


Holy moly! They're now makin' a 3HP electic outboard, too:
http://www.briggsandstratton.com/dis...sp?DocID=76404

Although the weight of four 12v batteries is gonna be a minus...

DT

Short Wave Sportfishing March 6th 07 09:51 PM

B&S 5-HP
 
On 6 Mar 2007 00:28:39 -0800, "Danny D."
wrote:

Does anyone have exp................


Not personally, but I have a relative who bought one and the neighbor
across the street had one on his little tin boat for the lake.

Never do it again. Loud, noisy - basically a lawnmower engine on a
drive shaft.

They both went through two of them under warranty before they gave up
and called it a lesson learned.

The fuel efficiency is about what you would get with a lawnmower and
they are noisy as hell to boot - I can tell you that from personal
experience that ear plugs or shooting muffs are required equipment.

While it's true that parts for the engine are easy to purchase, don't
think that the drive shaft and gear box are worth anything - they are
cheaply built and under any kind of prolonged use, wear out or break.
Do'nt expect to hit anything under water and have the drive system
survive either.

In addition, while the engine parts may be readily available, it's not
true for the drive system. You also need to remember that you are
working with lawn tractor dealers who already have warranty
reimbursement problems with B&S. There is no margin built in for the
dealer - they make at most $30 an engine so don't count on rapid
service - it will most likely be when they can get to it kind of
thing.

You can find a decent small two stroke used for about the same money.

Save yourself the time and effort.

trainfan1 March 7th 07 12:01 AM

B&S 5-HP
 
mystro wrote:
On Mar 6, 12:28 am, "Danny D." wrote:

Does anyone have
exp............................................. ...........................*...................... .........



If 5hp would work for me I wouldn't hesitate to purchase the American
Built B&S that's so easy
on fuel and by far the most economical to operate of *any* outboard
engine.


No way! The wear & tear, & noise will kill you, and a Johnson/Evinrude
5.5/6 hp will use less gas & last decades longer.

Don't even think about carrying a B&S OVER brackish or salt water much
less use it in there. There is ZERO salt water operation protection...
so much inferior corrosion protection for/in any environ.

Rob

I recall all the skepticism
when B&S first intro'd their outboard by so-called *experienced people
in this newsgroup back in 2002 ..they
lambasted it as just an updated lawnmower version which it is
certainly NOT..ignorance was bliss back then. :)

From everything I've read..you'll be hard pressed to find a single

owner who isn't very pleased and if and when it's needs a part..B&S
will not
do what all other marine engine manufacturers do..hit you extremely
hard in the pocketbook and that
includes the original retail price. No, B&S has proven to not only be
an exceptional (half the price) value but
also backs their engines as good or better then anyone. I wish they
made a 15hp.

06 Review from an old fisherman :) http://www.duckworksmagazine.com/03/...p/06/index.htm


mystro March 7th 07 04:00 AM

B&S 5-HP
 
Interesting comments but contradicts some very positive reviews from
people who have actually owned of this little motor:

http://reviews.basspro.com/2010/50120/reviews.htm



rbstern March 7th 07 05:19 AM

B&S 5-HP
 
On Mar 6, 3:28 am, "Danny D." wrote:
Does anyone have
exp............................................... ..........................*....................... ........


My neighbor at the lake has one. Too noisy and unrefined sounding for
my taste. There are several small outboards in our cove, and the B&S
is the only one that I notice and find annoying.


Short Wave Sportfishing March 7th 07 11:07 AM

B&S 5-HP
 
On 6 Mar 2007 20:00:23 -0800, "mystro" wrote:

Interesting comments but contradicts some very positive reviews from
people who have actually owned of this little motor:

http://reviews.basspro.com/2010/50120/reviews.htm


"As for the motor itself, it ran great. Starts easy, has lots of pep.
It sounds a bit like a tractor motor rather than an outboard. At low
rpm it does have quite a bit of vibration - you can feel the cylinder
firing every other stroke (4-stroke). And I think it killed my Timex,
it stopped ticking. But the price is right, considering that a
comparable new outboard would cost...."

Some people are too cheap for their own good.

Vic Smith March 7th 07 02:02 PM

B&S 5-HP
 
On Wed, 07 Mar 2007 11:07:54 GMT, Short Wave Sportfishing
wrote:

On 6 Mar 2007 20:00:23 -0800, "mystro" wrote:

Interesting comments but contradicts some very positive reviews from
people who have actually owned of this little motor:

http://reviews.basspro.com/2010/50120/reviews.htm


"As for the motor itself, it ran great. Starts easy, has lots of pep.
It sounds a bit like a tractor motor rather than an outboard. At low
rpm it does have quite a bit of vibration - you can feel the cylinder
firing every other stroke (4-stroke). And I think it killed my Timex,
it stopped ticking. But the price is right, considering that a
comparable new outboard would cost...."

Some people are too cheap for their own good.


I don't about the B&S, but I bought a Sears air-cooled 5hp
back about 1970. Used it for many years on fishing boats
I rented in IL and WI.
It cost about $150 instead of the $3-400 for a smooth Johnson or
Evinrude.
It was loud, shaky, and lousy for trolling, but it always started
after only 10-15 pulls. I swore if it ever took me to twenty pulls I
would sink it and get something decent. Sadly it always started.
Sadly, I never felt good about clamping it on a transom, knowing
the putt-put hell I was going to suffer when it started.
You're right.

--Vic


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 06:18 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com