What's your favorite revolver...and why?
 

I've always liked revolvers. A few years ago, I bought a new Ruger
GP100, a stainless steel six shooter in .357/.38 Special, with a six
inch barrel. Great shooter, very nicely made, but for reasons I could
never discern, I never could balance it properly when shooting off-hand
without working at it.

The reason *may* have been the barrel was just too long for me to shoot
the way I wanted. In any event, I sold that revolver to a federal law
enforcement guy, and got a S&W 686 with a 4" barrel. That revolver
weighs about the same as the Ruger, but for me it balances better.

I don't see any qualitative differences between the two revolvers.
They're both well-made. The single action pull on the S&W is the best
I've encountered on a full-size, "heavy" ammo revolver, a tad better
than the pull on the Ruger. Double action isn't bad, either.

What's your favorite revolver...and why?
 

On Thu, 14 Jan 2016 14:04:21 -0500, Keyser Söze wrote:

I've always liked revolvers. A few years ago, I bought a new Ruger
GP100, a stainless steel six shooter in .357/.38 Special, with a six
inch barrel. Great shooter, very nicely made, but for reasons I could
never discern, I never could balance it properly when shooting off-hand
without working at it.

The reason *may* have been the barrel was just too long for me to shoot
the way I wanted. In any event, I sold that revolver to a federal law
enforcement guy, and got a S&W 686 with a 4" barrel. That revolver
weighs about the same as the Ruger, but for me it balances better.

I don't see any qualitative differences between the two revolvers.
They're both well-made. The single action pull on the S&W is the best
I've encountered on a full-size, "heavy" ammo revolver, a tad better
than the pull on the Ruger. Double action isn't bad, either.

S&W Model 28.

I'd tell you why, but you'd probably call me names.
--

Ban idiots, not guns!

What's your favorite revolver...and why?
 

On Thu, 14 Jan 2016 14:04:21 -0500, Keyser Söze
wrote:

I've always liked revolvers. A few years ago, I bought a new Ruger
GP100, a stainless steel six shooter in .357/.38 Special, with a six
inch barrel. Great shooter, very nicely made, but for reasons I could
never discern, I never could balance it properly when shooting off-hand
without working at it.

The reason *may* have been the barrel was just too long for me to shoot
the way I wanted. In any event, I sold that revolver to a federal law
enforcement guy, and got a S&W 686 with a 4" barrel. That revolver
weighs about the same as the Ruger, but for me it balances better.

I don't see any qualitative differences between the two revolvers.
They're both well-made. The single action pull on the S&W is the best
I've encountered on a full-size, "heavy" ammo revolver, a tad better
than the pull on the Ruger. Double action isn't bad, either.

I don't really have that much experience with revolvers but I do like
my old Colt OM Match. It is basically like the "trooper" 357 I have
but it has the bull barrel. I assume you would not like the balance.
It is 40oz or so empty and a lot of it is out front. That does make
muzzle flip pretty much non existent with wad cutters over 2.5 gr of
Bullseye.
My other 3 revolvers are 2 antique Saturday night specials and a Colt
Frontier scout (.22 rf version of the SA Army)

What's your favorite revolver...and why?
 

On 1/14/16 3:59 PM, wrote:
On Thu, 14 Jan 2016 14:04:21 -0500, Keyser Söze
wrote:

I've always liked revolvers. A few years ago, I bought a new Ruger
GP100, a stainless steel six shooter in .357/.38 Special, with a six
inch barrel. Great shooter, very nicely made, but for reasons I could
never discern, I never could balance it properly when shooting off-hand
without working at it.

The reason *may* have been the barrel was just too long for me to shoot
the way I wanted. In any event, I sold that revolver to a federal law
enforcement guy, and got a S&W 686 with a 4" barrel. That revolver
weighs about the same as the Ruger, but for me it balances better.

I don't see any qualitative differences between the two revolvers.
They're both well-made. The single action pull on the S&W is the best
I've encountered on a full-size, "heavy" ammo revolver, a tad better
than the pull on the Ruger. Double action isn't bad, either.

I don't really have that much experience with revolvers but I do like
my old Colt OM Match. It is basically like the "trooper" 357 I have
but it has the bull barrel. I assume you would not like the balance.
It is 40oz or so empty and a lot of it is out front. That does make
muzzle flip pretty much non existent with wad cutters over 2.5 gr of
Bullseye.
My other 3 revolvers are 2 antique Saturday night specials and a Colt
Frontier scout (.22 rf version of the SA Army)


The S&W I now have has a bull barrel and full underlug, but as it is 2"
shorter than the Ruger, the balance is more to my liking.

I had a nice Ruger six shooter in .22 LR/.22MAG for a while, and it shot
nicely but I didn't much like emptying out the "empties" one at a time
with the plunger. If I were in the market for a .22 revolver, I'd get a
double action model with the hinged cylinder.

What's your favorite revolver...and why?
 

On 1/14/2016 2:04 PM, Keyser Söze wrote:

I've always liked revolvers. A few years ago, I bought a new Ruger
GP100, a stainless steel six shooter in .357/.38 Special, with a six
inch barrel. Great shooter, very nicely made, but for reasons I could
never discern, I never could balance it properly when shooting off-hand
without working at it.

The reason *may* have been the barrel was just too long for me to shoot
the way I wanted. In any event, I sold that revolver to a federal law
enforcement guy, and got a S&W 686 with a 4" barrel. That revolver
weighs about the same as the Ruger, but for me it balances better.

I don't see any qualitative differences between the two revolvers.
They're both well-made. The single action pull on the S&W is the best
I've encountered on a full-size, "heavy" ammo revolver, a tad better
than the pull on the Ruger. Double action isn't bad, either.


I've only owned three revolvers, a Ruger Single 10, a S&W Performance
Center 627 and a .38 "Chief's Special". I only have the .38 now.

The Ruger was a nice gun but loading and unloading it was a pain.
Accurate though. .22 cal. Ended up trading it in towards something
else.

The S&W 627 was awesome right out of the box. 357 magnum and .38 cal.
Nice gun but I found I rarely used it after taking it to the range a few
times plus ammo was scarce and expensive at the time. I am not a
collector or a gun nut so I sold it.

The .38 will stay. Good home protection gun. Point and shoot.

Favorite? Probably the S&W 627.

What's your favorite revolver...and why?
 

On Thursday, January 14, 2016 at 2:04:24 PM UTC-5, Keyser Söze wrote:
I've always liked revolvers.


Too bad THIS ISN'T A GUN GROUP, YOU ****.