BoatBanter.com

BoatBanter.com (https://www.boatbanter.com/)
-   General (https://www.boatbanter.com/general/)
-   -   Alligator Gar (https://www.boatbanter.com/general/104331-alligator-gar.html)

Eisboch[_4_] April 23rd 09 04:17 PM

Alligator Gar
 

Did anyone else see the History Channel spot on these fish?
I had never heard of them before. Creepy looking and big.
Although not normally aggressive against humans, apparently
there have been some documented cases of attacks.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alligator_gar

Eisboch

[email protected] April 23rd 09 04:42 PM

Alligator Gar
 
On Apr 23, 11:17*am, "Eisboch" wrote:
Did anyone else see the History Channel spot on these fish?
I had never heard of them before. * Creepy looking and big.
Although not normally aggressive against humans, apparently
there have been some documented cases of attacks.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alligator_gar

Eisboch


I was bass fishing in a local florida swamp and caught a decent size
one by accident. I got that thing to my canoe, and really, really
wanted my lure back. I'm sitting there looking at this thing that's
all teeth and wondering what to do!

Tim April 23rd 09 05:10 PM

Alligator Gar
 
On Apr 23, 10:42*am, wrote:
On Apr 23, 11:17*am, "Eisboch" wrote:

Did anyone else see the History Channel spot on these fish?
I had never heard of them before. * Creepy looking and big.
Although not normally aggressive against humans, apparently
there have been some documented cases of attacks.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alligator_gar


Eisboch


I was bass fishing in a local florida swamp and caught a decent size
one by accident. I got that thing to my canoe, and really, really
wanted my lure back. I'm sitting there looking at this thing that's
all teeth and wondering what to do!


Yes, i watched it too. Very fascinating. At the end though, the marine
people said the Gar gets a bad rap and was considered more harmless
than agressive. and said the attacks were more to be blamed on
alligators. but when the guy caught a three footer it wasn't very
happy and bloodied his arm fairly well.

I was feeeshing with a friend of min in a small Lake in Central
Illinois, and he caught one. narley looking dude and maybe a food
long. He wanted his lure back too so he put on some leather gloves and
cut it's head off and dug the lure out.

I didn't know they got so big though. 7-10 asnd ev3en reported to be
up to 14-15 feet in length!

they said it will hold onto a fish then determine if it can swallow it
whole. The bad part is, I wonder how long it would take to hold onto
an arm or leg untill it figured it was to big to gulp down.

I don't wanna mess with one that size.

Butt ugly but beautiful in a wierd way.

[email protected] April 23rd 09 05:56 PM

Alligator Gar
 
On Apr 23, 12:10*pm, Tim wrote:
On Apr 23, 10:42*am, wrote:

On Apr 23, 11:17*am, "Eisboch" wrote:


Did anyone else see the History Channel spot on these fish?
I had never heard of them before. * Creepy looking and big.
Although not normally aggressive against humans, apparently
there have been some documented cases of attacks.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alligator_gar


Eisboch


I was bass fishing in a local florida swamp and caught a decent size
one by accident. I got that thing to my canoe, and really, really
wanted my lure back. I'm sitting there looking at this thing that's
all teeth and wondering what to do!


Yes, i watched it too. Very fascinating. At the end though, the marine
people said the Gar gets a bad rap and was considered more harmless
than agressive. and said the attacks were more to be blamed on
alligators. but when the guy caught a three footer it wasn't very
happy and bloodied his arm fairly well.

I was feeeshing with a friend of min in a small Lake in Central
Illinois, and he caught one. narley looking dude and maybe a food
long. He wanted his lure back too so he put on some leather gloves and
cut it's head off and dug the lure out.

I didn't know they got so big though. 7-10 asnd ev3en reported to be
up to 14-15 feet in length!

they said it will hold onto a fish then determine if it can swallow it
whole. The bad part is, I wonder how long it would take to hold onto
an arm or leg untill it figured it was to big to gulp down.

I don't wanna mess with one that size.

Butt ugly but beautiful in a wierd way.


The really big ones in Florida hardly will hit a lure at all. Think
they like live bait!!! I know of a spot, you go into the swamp on the
Hillsboro River, and get to a decent sized lake, nothing but swamp all
around it. When you are canoeing through it, the gar will be right at
the surface, BIG gar. It's a little nerve racking in a canoe, by
yourself, in the middle of a swamp with these all-teeth things
surfacing around you!

Richard Casady April 23rd 09 06:33 PM

Alligator Gar
 
On Thu, 23 Apr 2009 08:42:13 -0700 (PDT), wrote:

On Apr 23, 11:17*am, "Eisboch" wrote:
Did anyone else see the History Channel spot on these fish?
I had never heard of them before. * Creepy looking and big.
Although not normally aggressive against humans, apparently
there have been some documented cases of attacks.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alligator_gar

Eisboch


I was bass fishing in a local florida swamp and caught a decent size
one by accident. I got that thing to my canoe, and really, really
wanted my lure back. I'm sitting there looking at this thing that's
all teeth and wondering what to do!


The commercial fishermen, the ones subject to a shark in the net,
carry a shotgun. If you catch one on a line, you cut the line.
For smaller fish, there are clubs designed for finishing them off. You
smash their skull. You can make a nice club from a broken paddle.
Go to your local ball club and ask for a couple of suitable broken
bats. Repair and shorten. Those bats cost a hundred bucks, by the way.

Casady

Tim April 23rd 09 06:51 PM

Alligator Gar
 
On Apr 23, 11:56*am, wrote:
On Apr 23, 12:10*pm, Tim wrote:





On Apr 23, 10:42*am, wrote:


On Apr 23, 11:17*am, "Eisboch" wrote:


Did anyone else see the History Channel spot on these fish?
I had never heard of them before. * Creepy looking and big.
Although not normally aggressive against humans, apparently
there have been some documented cases of attacks.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alligator_gar


Eisboch


I was bass fishing in a local florida swamp and caught a decent size
one by accident. I got that thing to my canoe, and really, really
wanted my lure back. I'm sitting there looking at this thing that's
all teeth and wondering what to do!


Yes, i watched it too. Very fascinating. At the end though, the marine
people said the Gar gets a bad rap and was considered more harmless
than agressive. and said the attacks were more to be blamed on
alligators. but when the guy caught a three footer it wasn't very
happy and bloodied his arm fairly well.


I was feeeshing with a friend of min in a small Lake in Central
Illinois, and he caught one. narley looking dude and maybe a food
long. He wanted his lure back too so he put on some leather gloves and
cut it's head off and dug the lure out.


I didn't know they got so big though. 7-10 asnd ev3en reported to be
up to 14-15 feet in length!


they said it will hold onto a fish then determine if it can swallow it
whole. The bad part is, I wonder how long it would take to hold onto
an arm or leg untill it figured it was to big to gulp down.


I don't wanna mess with one that size.


Butt ugly but beautiful in a wierd way.


The really big ones in Florida hardly will hit a lure at all. Think
they like live bait!!! I know of a spot, you go into the swamp on the
Hillsboro River, and get to a decent sized lake, nothing but swamp all
around it. When you are canoeing through it, the gar will be right at
the surface, BIG gar. It's a little nerve racking in a canoe, by
yourself, in the middle of a swamp with these all-teeth things
surfacing around you!- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -



I can understand that. In fact, the guy in the opening of the program
showd he had a 7 ft.r mounted on the wall and said he was trolling in
a 14 ft. jon boat, when one was swimming right next to him and it was
the full length of the boat. He then gave the impression that it was
time to get the heck out of there....


I can't blame him.

Frogwatch[_2_] April 23rd 09 07:30 PM

Alligator Gar
 
On Apr 23, 12:56 pm, wrote:
On Apr 23, 12:10 pm, Tim wrote:



On Apr 23, 10:42 am, wrote:


On Apr 23, 11:17 am, "Eisboch" wrote:


Did anyone else see the History Channel spot on these fish?
I had never heard of them before. Creepy looking and big.
Although not normally aggressive against humans, apparently
there have been some documented cases of attacks.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alligator_gar


Eisboch


I was bass fishing in a local florida swamp and caught a decent size
one by accident. I got that thing to my canoe, and really, really
wanted my lure back. I'm sitting there looking at this thing that's
all teeth and wondering what to do!


Yes, i watched it too. Very fascinating. At the end though, the marine
people said the Gar gets a bad rap and was considered more harmless
than agressive. and said the attacks were more to be blamed on
alligators. but when the guy caught a three footer it wasn't very
happy and bloodied his arm fairly well.


I was feeeshing with a friend of min in a small Lake in Central
Illinois, and he caught one. narley looking dude and maybe a food
long. He wanted his lure back too so he put on some leather gloves and
cut it's head off and dug the lure out.


I didn't know they got so big though. 7-10 asnd ev3en reported to be
up to 14-15 feet in length!


they said it will hold onto a fish then determine if it can swallow it
whole. The bad part is, I wonder how long it would take to hold onto
an arm or leg untill it figured it was to big to gulp down.


I don't wanna mess with one that size.


Butt ugly but beautiful in a wierd way.


The really big ones in Florida hardly will hit a lure at all. Think
they like live bait!!! I know of a spot, you go into the swamp on the
Hillsboro River, and get to a decent sized lake, nothing but swamp all
around it. When you are canoeing through it, the gar will be right at
the surface, BIG gar. It's a little nerve racking in a canoe, by
yourself, in the middle of a swamp with these all-teeth things
surfacing around you!


Here in N. FL, you can go to Wakulla Springs and look out from the
swim tower toward the springs and see alligator gar hanging nearly
motionless over the clear spring and they range from 3-6'. When I was
a kid, my parents would give all 9 of us kids a mask and drag us
behind the canoe down the Wakulla river. There were gar all over the
place and at first they scared us but they never bothered us.

SteveB[_2_] April 24th 09 03:55 AM

Alligator Gar
 

"Eisboch" wrote in message
...

Did anyone else see the History Channel spot on these fish?
I had never heard of them before. Creepy looking and big.
Although not normally aggressive against humans, apparently there have
been some documented cases of attacks.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alligator_gar

Eisboch


These fish were familiar to me when I lived in Texas and Louisiana. Bigger
around than a bowling ball, and six feet long. The biggest ones I saw were
in Galveston bay around Seabrook, in brackish water. They did get big in
the Louisiana marshes, too. Fishing for them was with snares, or frayed
nylon lines that got tangled in their teeth. Bowfishing was fun, too. Very
good to eat as a roast, or scraping the meat and making a local delicacy
called "gar fish balls" meaning balls made of shredded meat, and not the
testicles. Some pretty big damn awesome powerful fish that look like they
came from the age of the dinosaurs.

Steve



thunder April 24th 09 12:44 PM

Alligator Gar
 
On Thu, 23 Apr 2009 11:30:57 -0700, Frogwatch wrote:


Here in N. FL, you can go to Wakulla Springs and look out from the swim
tower toward the springs and see alligator gar hanging nearly motionless
over the clear spring and they range from 3-6'. When I was a kid, my
parents would give all 9 of us kids a mask and drag us behind the canoe
down the Wakulla river.


Trolling for gar, were they? ;-) Personally, I've never seen them in
the 6' range. I have seen them 2-3' and they seemed rather sluggish to
me. Of course, I was on land and safe.

thunder April 24th 09 12:47 PM

Alligator Gar
 
On Thu, 23 Apr 2009 20:55:29 -0600, SteveB wrote:


Some pretty big damn
awesome powerful fish that look like they came from the age of the
dinosaurs.


Are they powerful? The few I've seen seemed rather sluggish and slow.

Eisboch[_4_] April 24th 09 12:57 PM

Alligator Gar
 

"thunder" wrote in message
t...
On Thu, 23 Apr 2009 20:55:29 -0600, SteveB wrote:


Some pretty big damn
awesome powerful fish that look like they came from the age of the
dinosaurs.


Are they powerful? The few I've seen seemed rather sluggish and slow.



To the contrary, they are capable of being very fast and efficient hunters.
Here's a pic I found of one a guy caught in 1991.

http://www.texasfishingguides.org/ki...atula_42_x.jpg

Eisboch


[email protected] April 24th 09 01:29 PM

Alligator Gar
 
On Apr 24, 7:47*am, thunder wrote:
On Thu, 23 Apr 2009 20:55:29 -0600, SteveB wrote:
*Some pretty big damn
awesome powerful fish that look like they came from the age of the
dinosaurs.


Are they powerful? *The few I've seen seemed rather sluggish and slow.


Oh, no. They kind of act like 'gators, they can be fast and powerful
as all hell! Just hook one sometime!

[email protected] April 24th 09 01:30 PM

Alligator Gar
 
On Apr 23, 10:55*pm, "SteveB" wrote:
"Eisboch" wrote in message

...



Did anyone else see the History Channel spot on these fish?
I had never heard of them before. * Creepy looking and big.
Although not normally aggressive against humans, apparently there have
been some documented cases of attacks.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alligator_gar


Eisboch


These fish were familiar to me when I lived in Texas and Louisiana. *Bigger
around than a bowling ball, and six feet long. *The biggest ones I saw were
in Galveston bay around Seabrook, in brackish water. *They did get big in
the Louisiana marshes, too. *Fishing for them was with snares, or frayed
nylon lines that got tangled in their teeth. *Bowfishing was fun, too. *Very
good to eat as a roast, or scraping the meat and making a local delicacy
called "gar fish balls" meaning balls made of shredded meat, and not the
testicles. *Some pretty big damn awesome powerful fish that look like they
came from the age of the dinosaurs.

Steve


Interesting, I never knew (or thought about it) that they would live
in brackish water.

thunder April 24th 09 01:53 PM

Alligator Gar
 
On Fri, 24 Apr 2009 07:57:44 -0400, Eisboch wrote:



http://www.texasfishingguides.org/kirkland/images/

atractosteus_spatula_42_x.jpg


They sure do have some size to them. That's a nice fish. I was reading
somewhere that their eggs are toxic.

SteveB[_2_] April 24th 09 02:41 PM

Alligator Gar
 

"thunder" wrote in message
t...
On Thu, 23 Apr 2009 20:55:29 -0600, SteveB wrote:


Some pretty big damn
awesome powerful fish that look like they came from the age of the
dinosaurs.


Are they powerful? The few I've seen seemed rather sluggish and slow.


As with an alligator, they clamp and roll. YES, YES, they are powerful.
They hunt by stealth, slowly.



Calif Bill April 24th 09 09:31 PM

Alligator Gar
 

"Eisboch" wrote in message
...

"thunder" wrote in message
t...
On Thu, 23 Apr 2009 20:55:29 -0600, SteveB wrote:


Some pretty big damn
awesome powerful fish that look like they came from the age of the
dinosaurs.


Are they powerful? The few I've seen seemed rather sluggish and slow.



To the contrary, they are capable of being very fast and efficient
hunters.
Here's a pic I found of one a guy caught in 1991.

http://www.texasfishingguides.org/ki...atula_42_x.jpg

Eisboch


Was over at the San Francisco Academy of Science. Used to be the Steinhart
Aquarium. Lots of gars in the tank, and they looked like they could swim
very fast from just watching them glide along nomally.



Richard Casady May 3rd 09 03:31 PM

Alligator Gar
 
On Fri, 24 Apr 2009 07:57:44 -0400, "Eisboch"
wrote:

To the contrary, they are capable of being very fast and efficient hunters.


That is a real no brainer. What else would a zillion needle sharp
teeth be for? Eating weeds? And any fish shaped like that is built for
speed. Barracuda for example.

Casady

No Name May 28th 09 09:22 PM

Alligator Gar
 
Eisboch wrote:

Did anyone else see the History Channel spot on these
fish?


We used to catch them on our YoYos on Caddo Lake.
Blechy, mean fish that got to be thrown back as there
isn't a thing edible on em.


sam

Tim May 29th 09 03:32 AM

Alligator Gar
 
On Apr 24, 7:53*am, thunder wrote:
On Fri, 24 Apr 2009 07:57:44 -0400, Eisboch wrote:
http://www.texasfishingguides.org/kirkland/images/


atractosteus_spatula_42_x.jpg

They sure do have some size to them. *That's a nice fish. *I was reading
somewhere that their eggs are toxic. *


The whole blasted thing looks toxic to me...

Tim May 29th 09 03:40 AM

Alligator Gar
 
On May 28, 3:22*pm, wrote:
Eisboch wrote:
Did anyone else see the History Channel spot on these
fish?


We used to catch them on our YoYos on Caddo Lake.
Blechy, mean fish that got to be thrown back as there
isn't a thing edible on em.

sam


Actually they are edible. But look at this recipe:

http://www.greatcajuncooking.com/recipes/recipe.php?65

5 pounds deboned Garfish
2 medium onions
2 cloves garlic
I rib celery
5 sprigs parsley
1/2 teaspoon red pepper
1 teaspoon black pepper
1 tablespoon salt
1 cup fine bread crumbs
Sauce:
2 cups flour
1¼ cups vegetable oil
I large bell pepper
1 can tomato sauce
1 large onion, chopped
8 to 10 cups boiling water
¼ teaspoon red pepper
1 cup chopped green onion tops
1 cup chopped green pepper
2 cloves garlic, chopped
Salt and pepper to taste

Procedu Grind together the fish, onions, bell pepper, garlic,
celery, and parsley. Add red pepper, black pepper, salt and bread
crumbs. Shape into balls the size desired. Fry in deep hot vegetable
oil until brown.


Here's another:

http://www.realcajunrecipes.com/reci...eaning/705.rcr

HK May 29th 09 03:50 AM

Alligator Gar
 
Tim wrote:
On May 28, 3:22 pm, wrote:
Eisboch wrote:
Did anyone else see the History Channel spot on these
fish?

We used to catch them on our YoYos on Caddo Lake.
Blechy, mean fish that got to be thrown back as there
isn't a thing edible on em.

sam


Actually they are edible. But look at this recipe:

http://www.greatcajuncooking.com/recipes/recipe.php?65

5 pounds deboned Garfish
2 medium onions
2 cloves garlic
I rib celery
5 sprigs parsley
1/2 teaspoon red pepper
1 teaspoon black pepper
1 tablespoon salt
1 cup fine bread crumbs
Sauce:
2 cups flour
1¼ cups vegetable oil
I large bell pepper
1 can tomato sauce
1 large onion, chopped
8 to 10 cups boiling water
¼ teaspoon red pepper
1 cup chopped green onion tops
1 cup chopped green pepper
2 cloves garlic, chopped
Salt and pepper to taste

Procedu Grind together the fish, onions, bell pepper, garlic,
celery, and parsley. Add red pepper, black pepper, salt and bread
crumbs. Shape into balls the size desired. Fry in deep hot vegetable
oil until brown.


Here's another:

http://www.realcajunrecipes.com/reci...eaning/705.rcr



Sorta like eating prairie dog; when you have nothing else to eat, eat
what's huntable-fishable-growable.

As in:

Prairie Dog Stew

Ingredients:
1 prairie dog, quartered
1 cup diced onion
2 large tomatoes (from your garden) or 1 can of tomatoes
Assorted fresh ,or canned veggies

Preparation:
Sprinkle seasoned salt, pepper, and cayenne pepper (optional) liberally
on the meat. Pour some cooking oil into a large pot (dutch oven). Sauté
the meat with the onions until well browned. Drain the excess oil, add
about 2 cups water, and bring to a boil. Cut up the tomatoes and add. If
you use canned tomatoes add them now. Turn down the heat, and let slow
cook for at least an hour. Important: older prairie dogs may require
cooking longer than an hour. Check periodically for tenderness. If you
don't you will have a hard time chewing the meat. After the meat is
tender, add the veggies, carrots, potatoes, banana pepper, what ever you
like. Cook until the veggies are done. An option you can use is, cook up
your favorite pasta and serve over the pasta. (eliminate the potatoes).
That's it, nice and simple


From:

http://www.lovelandnet.com/toms-plac...df/recipes.htm

Tim May 29th 09 10:47 AM

Alligator Gar
 
On May 28, 9:50*pm, HK wrote:


Sorta like eating prairie dog; when you have nothing else to eat, eat
what's huntable-fishable-growable.

Unless your Cajun, then everything is edible , and in season.

John H[_2_] May 29th 09 11:43 AM

Alligator Gar
 
On Thu, 28 May 2009 19:40:45 -0700 (PDT), Tim
wrote:

On May 28, 3:22*pm, wrote:
Eisboch wrote:
Did anyone else see the History Channel spot on these
fish?


We used to catch them on our YoYos on Caddo Lake.
Blechy, mean fish that got to be thrown back as there
isn't a thing edible on em.

sam


Actually they are edible. But look at this recipe:

http://www.greatcajuncooking.com/recipes/recipe.php?65

5 pounds deboned Garfish
2 medium onions
2 cloves garlic
I rib celery



It's that 'deboned' part that's worrisome. That could turn into a
likelong occupation from what I've heard about them.
--

John H

Richard Casady May 29th 09 02:08 PM

Alligator Gar
 
On Fri, 29 May 2009 06:43:29 -0400, John H
wrote:

It's that 'deboned' part that's worrisome. That could turn into a
likelong occupation from what I've heard about them.


They are shaped like a Northern Pike, and those are famous for bones.

Casady


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 07:47 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com