![]() |
|
A question about boat weight and displacement
writes:
You have not answered: What state do you live in? This is relevant to the weight of a boat how? How anonymous do you intend to remain? As much as possible. I have several concerns, all of which are not relevant to the questions being asked. If I lived in North Carolina, the vessel would weigh the same as if I lived in North Dakota. Also, what states will you be in when you are towing on your trips? Please forgive my ignorance, but this is relevant to the weight of the boat how? I raised the matter of your boat's 10' 6" beam because in ALL of the states in the USA, you will be towing an Oversize Load. This to me is a more pertinent question than the weight of the vessel. It is an excellent question, and I thank you for asking it. How high is the top of your boat above the waterline? I have no idea how high it is above the waterline. After your boat is on a trailer what will the height of the boat be above the pavement? I have no idea what the height of the boat above the pavement will be, when on a trailer. Note that states have a height limit for towed loads because of overpasses and powerlines. In most states the limit is 13' 6". In at least one state it is 13'. This is another excellent piece of information. There's a Chart of the Trailer Towing Laws of the various states at http://www.loadrite.com/ . There are a couple of mistakes, but I think the chart gives you an idea of what I and others are saying. You or anyone looking at the chart should confirm the requirements and limits with the Department of Motor Vehicles for the states in which you will be towing. This is indeed a factor in the decision to acquire this vessel. Towing an Oversize Load can requi a Permit for each trip; only towing during daylight hours; and/or an escort vehicle or escort vehicles. You may have seen this when a large piece of equipment, a large house trailer or "half" of a prefabricated/manufactured house is being moved on a public highway. This I have seen many times. This can get expensive each time you move the boat. You may decide that it is not practical or "feasible" (your word) for you to have such a large boat as your "trailerable boat" and so your other questions may become moot. Based solely on your post, and the excellent questions you have raised, I am no longer considering this or any other large boat. It simply is not worth what effort it will take to move it between places to put it on water. If I were to buy a boat this long, or longer, it would have to be for use in one location only. Another factor is that you will be launching a 28' long boat with a draft of 2' 2". I do not know and so ask others, can such a boat be launched at all boat launching ramps? Or, can it only be launched at ramps which are steep? Again, my ignorance of this is telling, but are not boat ramps made so that boats can be launched? I understand you to tell me that they are not made for boats bigger than the little open fishing type boats that I see which are as small as the cars pulling them. I should go and read more on this, and ask around as to how these large boats I see get put in the water in the first place. Sorry if this does answer your displacement questions, but you have other considerations, as well, before you buy this boat. I have no other considerations any longer, thanks to your excellent questions raised. I appreciate this group for having good answers and raising more good questions. It is a place to learn! I know that this may be frustrating to all of you who know so much about this and other things, but I have to start somewhere, and learn from the beginning. It is good to see people who remember what it is like to not know a lot, and who take the time to be nice enough to make good responses to what they think are easy or silly questions. We have to learn somehow. And I apologize for all those other multiple posts. My software does not work perfectly all the time. --- - Topic-Mimara Unique in the World! --- -=- This message was posted via two or more anonymous remailing services. |
A question about boat weight and displacement
As much as possible. I have several concerns, all of which are not relevant to the questions being asked. If I lived in North Carolina, the vessel would weigh the same as if I lived in North Dakota. No it wouldnt !!!! The MASS would be the same but not necessarily the weight. Wgt .= mass X gravitational acceleration. Weight is not a constant value and varies due to local (and varying) gravity values. The 'local' acceleration to do gravity anomalies for each location and altitude will be different and you need to ascertain what the local gravity acceleration is. Mass is constant but weight never is. ...... just like displacement values vary with the density of the water. Thought I'd add to this never ending 'moebius loop' thread. ;-) |
A question about boat weight and displacement
As much as possible. I have several concerns, all of which are not relevant to the questions being asked. If I lived in North Carolina, the vessel would weigh the same as if I lived in North Dakota. No it wouldnt !!!! The MASS would be the same but not necessarily the weight. Wgt .= mass X gravitational acceleration. Weight is not a constant value and varies due to local (and varying) gravity values. The 'local' acceleration to do gravity anomalies for each location and altitude will be different and you need to ascertain what the local gravity acceleration is. Mass is constant but weight never is. ...... just like displacement values vary with the density of the water. Thought I'd add to this never ending 'moebius loop' thread. ;-) |
A question about boat weight and displacement
Rich Hampel writes:
Ante Topic Mimara wrote: As much as possible. I have several concerns, all of which are not relevant to the questions being asked. If I lived in North Carolina, the vessel would weigh the same as if I lived in North Dakota. No it wouldnt !!!! For all practical purposes, yes it would. The MASS would be the same but not necessarily the weight. For all practical purposes, yes it would. Wgt .= mass X gravitational acceleration. Thank you for the math lesson. You tell me off the top of your head what the exact "gravitational acceleration" at Wrightsville Beach, North Carolina is, and also that of Williston, North Dakota, and figure up the equation you posed above to tell me the exact difference between the two. This is as significant as wheels on a platypus. The variation of weight between any two given locations within 500 miles, would not matter in the least to what kind of vehicle would be required to tow this vessel, nor would it matter in the least to the real-world weight of this vessel, as it is measured in a realistic manner. There may be up to a fraction of a pound of weight, but in the grand scheme of things, that is statistically insignificant. Perhaps if I were towing this vessel on the moon, it might matter, but I am not concerned with theory, I am concerned with real world practice. And in any case, it is now totally irrelevant, because I cannot use this, or any other boat large enough for me to utilize in the manner I wish to. I would have to cruise it over 200 miles to get to the nearest coast, to be able to go anywhere with it, other than up and down a short amount of the local river front. I cannot take it to any of the local lakes, and this is something I had wanted to do. Weight is not a constant value and varies due to local (and varying) gravity values. The 'local' acceleration to do gravity anomalies for each location and altitude will be different and you need to ascertain what the local gravity acceleration is. Mass is constant but weight never is...... just like displacement values vary with the density of the water. You are choking on a flea, and swallowing a camel. I do not know about you, but I cannot look at any item this large, and determine it's weight at a glance, down to the fraction of an ounce. For all practical purposes, and in the real world, not that of theoretical mathematics, the boat might weigh 7000 pounds in North Dakota, and 7000.00002 pounds in North Carolina. Of course this is just as much of a stretch of the theory of gravity as your comment that it would not weight the same, and just as helpful. Thought I'd add to this never ending 'moebius loop' thread. Perhaps your efforts would have been better exerted, had you just addressed the questions I wished to have answered, than in dwelling over miniscule details that matter not a whit to the issues at hand. I thank you for your reply, but it served no practical purpose. Except possibly to discourage me from wanting to participate. --- - Topic-Mimara Unique in the World! --- -=- This message was posted via two or more anonymous remailing services. |
A question about boat weight and displacement
Rich Hampel writes:
Ante Topic Mimara wrote: As much as possible. I have several concerns, all of which are not relevant to the questions being asked. If I lived in North Carolina, the vessel would weigh the same as if I lived in North Dakota. No it wouldnt !!!! For all practical purposes, yes it would. The MASS would be the same but not necessarily the weight. For all practical purposes, yes it would. Wgt .= mass X gravitational acceleration. Thank you for the math lesson. You tell me off the top of your head what the exact "gravitational acceleration" at Wrightsville Beach, North Carolina is, and also that of Williston, North Dakota, and figure up the equation you posed above to tell me the exact difference between the two. This is as significant as wheels on a platypus. The variation of weight between any two given locations within 500 miles, would not matter in the least to what kind of vehicle would be required to tow this vessel, nor would it matter in the least to the real-world weight of this vessel, as it is measured in a realistic manner. There may be up to a fraction of a pound of weight, but in the grand scheme of things, that is statistically insignificant. Perhaps if I were towing this vessel on the moon, it might matter, but I am not concerned with theory, I am concerned with real world practice. And in any case, it is now totally irrelevant, because I cannot use this, or any other boat large enough for me to utilize in the manner I wish to. I would have to cruise it over 200 miles to get to the nearest coast, to be able to go anywhere with it, other than up and down a short amount of the local river front. I cannot take it to any of the local lakes, and this is something I had wanted to do. Weight is not a constant value and varies due to local (and varying) gravity values. The 'local' acceleration to do gravity anomalies for each location and altitude will be different and you need to ascertain what the local gravity acceleration is. Mass is constant but weight never is...... just like displacement values vary with the density of the water. You are choking on a flea, and swallowing a camel. I do not know about you, but I cannot look at any item this large, and determine it's weight at a glance, down to the fraction of an ounce. For all practical purposes, and in the real world, not that of theoretical mathematics, the boat might weigh 7000 pounds in North Dakota, and 7000.00002 pounds in North Carolina. Of course this is just as much of a stretch of the theory of gravity as your comment that it would not weight the same, and just as helpful. Thought I'd add to this never ending 'moebius loop' thread. Perhaps your efforts would have been better exerted, had you just addressed the questions I wished to have answered, than in dwelling over miniscule details that matter not a whit to the issues at hand. I thank you for your reply, but it served no practical purpose. Except possibly to discourage me from wanting to participate. --- - Topic-Mimara Unique in the World! --- -=- This message was posted via two or more anonymous remailing services. |
A question about boat weight and displacement
You were asked what state re; permits and such because of the 10'+ beam.
"Ante Topic Mimara" ] wrote in message news:GCJCWQGI38079.4399189815@anonymous... Rich Hampel writes: Ante Topic Mimara wrote: As much as possible. I have several concerns, all of which are not relevant to the questions being asked. If I lived in North Carolina, the vessel would weigh the same as if I lived in North Dakota. No it wouldnt !!!! For all practical purposes, yes it would. The MASS would be the same but not necessarily the weight. For all practical purposes, yes it would. Wgt .= mass X gravitational acceleration. Thank you for the math lesson. You tell me off the top of your head what the exact "gravitational acceleration" at Wrightsville Beach, North Carolina is, and also that of Williston, North Dakota, and figure up the equation you posed above to tell me the exact difference between the two. This is as significant as wheels on a platypus. The variation of weight between any two given locations within 500 miles, would not matter in the least to what kind of vehicle would be required to tow this vessel, nor would it matter in the least to the real-world weight of this vessel, as it is measured in a realistic manner. There may be up to a fraction of a pound of weight, but in the grand scheme of things, that is statistically insignificant. Perhaps if I were towing this vessel on the moon, it might matter, but I am not concerned with theory, I am concerned with real world practice. And in any case, it is now totally irrelevant, because I cannot use this, or any other boat large enough for me to utilize in the manner I wish to. I would have to cruise it over 200 miles to get to the nearest coast, to be able to go anywhere with it, other than up and down a short amount of the local river front. I cannot take it to any of the local lakes, and this is something I had wanted to do. Weight is not a constant value and varies due to local (and varying) gravity values. The 'local' acceleration to do gravity anomalies for each location and altitude will be different and you need to ascertain what the local gravity acceleration is. Mass is constant but weight never is...... just like displacement values vary with the density of the water. You are choking on a flea, and swallowing a camel. I do not know about you, but I cannot look at any item this large, and determine it's weight at a glance, down to the fraction of an ounce. For all practical purposes, and in the real world, not that of theoretical mathematics, the boat might weigh 7000 pounds in North Dakota, and 7000.00002 pounds in North Carolina. Of course this is just as much of a stretch of the theory of gravity as your comment that it would not weight the same, and just as helpful. Thought I'd add to this never ending 'moebius loop' thread. Perhaps your efforts would have been better exerted, had you just addressed the questions I wished to have answered, than in dwelling over miniscule details that matter not a whit to the issues at hand. I thank you for your reply, but it served no practical purpose. Except possibly to discourage me from wanting to participate. --- - Topic-Mimara Unique in the World! --- -=- This message was posted via two or more anonymous remailing services. |
A question about boat weight and displacement
You were asked what state re; permits and such because of the 10'+ beam.
"Ante Topic Mimara" ] wrote in message news:GCJCWQGI38079.4399189815@anonymous... Rich Hampel writes: Ante Topic Mimara wrote: As much as possible. I have several concerns, all of which are not relevant to the questions being asked. If I lived in North Carolina, the vessel would weigh the same as if I lived in North Dakota. No it wouldnt !!!! For all practical purposes, yes it would. The MASS would be the same but not necessarily the weight. For all practical purposes, yes it would. Wgt .= mass X gravitational acceleration. Thank you for the math lesson. You tell me off the top of your head what the exact "gravitational acceleration" at Wrightsville Beach, North Carolina is, and also that of Williston, North Dakota, and figure up the equation you posed above to tell me the exact difference between the two. This is as significant as wheels on a platypus. The variation of weight between any two given locations within 500 miles, would not matter in the least to what kind of vehicle would be required to tow this vessel, nor would it matter in the least to the real-world weight of this vessel, as it is measured in a realistic manner. There may be up to a fraction of a pound of weight, but in the grand scheme of things, that is statistically insignificant. Perhaps if I were towing this vessel on the moon, it might matter, but I am not concerned with theory, I am concerned with real world practice. And in any case, it is now totally irrelevant, because I cannot use this, or any other boat large enough for me to utilize in the manner I wish to. I would have to cruise it over 200 miles to get to the nearest coast, to be able to go anywhere with it, other than up and down a short amount of the local river front. I cannot take it to any of the local lakes, and this is something I had wanted to do. Weight is not a constant value and varies due to local (and varying) gravity values. The 'local' acceleration to do gravity anomalies for each location and altitude will be different and you need to ascertain what the local gravity acceleration is. Mass is constant but weight never is...... just like displacement values vary with the density of the water. You are choking on a flea, and swallowing a camel. I do not know about you, but I cannot look at any item this large, and determine it's weight at a glance, down to the fraction of an ounce. For all practical purposes, and in the real world, not that of theoretical mathematics, the boat might weigh 7000 pounds in North Dakota, and 7000.00002 pounds in North Carolina. Of course this is just as much of a stretch of the theory of gravity as your comment that it would not weight the same, and just as helpful. Thought I'd add to this never ending 'moebius loop' thread. Perhaps your efforts would have been better exerted, had you just addressed the questions I wished to have answered, than in dwelling over miniscule details that matter not a whit to the issues at hand. I thank you for your reply, but it served no practical purpose. Except possibly to discourage me from wanting to participate. --- - Topic-Mimara Unique in the World! --- -=- This message was posted via two or more anonymous remailing services. |
A question about boat weight and displacement
wrote in message
... I raised the matter of your boat's 10' 6" beam because in ALL of the states in the USA, you will be towing an Oversize Load. True! Note that states have a height limit for towed loads because of overpasses and powerlines. In most states the limit is 13' 6". In at least one state it is 13'. Which state is 13' ? Towing an Oversize Load can requi a Permit for each trip; only towing during daylight hours; and/or an escort vehicle or escort vehicles. Not to mention some cities have curfew laws. (no movement 0600~0900 and 1600~1900) This can get expensive each time you move the boat. Depending on the state (which for some suspicious reason he is hiding ) permit can be as little as $10. But that is each trip. Some states require special insurance. -- Scott Vernon Plowville PA __/)__/)__ |
A question about boat weight and displacement
wrote in message
... I raised the matter of your boat's 10' 6" beam because in ALL of the states in the USA, you will be towing an Oversize Load. True! Note that states have a height limit for towed loads because of overpasses and powerlines. In most states the limit is 13' 6". In at least one state it is 13'. Which state is 13' ? Towing an Oversize Load can requi a Permit for each trip; only towing during daylight hours; and/or an escort vehicle or escort vehicles. Not to mention some cities have curfew laws. (no movement 0600~0900 and 1600~1900) This can get expensive each time you move the boat. Depending on the state (which for some suspicious reason he is hiding ) permit can be as little as $10. But that is each trip. Some states require special insurance. -- Scott Vernon Plowville PA __/)__/)__ |
A question about boat weight and displacement
writes:
You have not answered: What state do you live in? This is relevant to the weight of a boat how? How anonymous do you intend to remain? As much as possible. I have several concerns, all of which are not relevant to the questions being asked. If I lived in North Carolina, the vessel would weigh the same as if I lived in North Dakota. Go down to the local county fair. There's a guy there who for $2 will guess your weight. Bet he does boats, too. That's what you're expecting the people on this group to do.....guess the weight. I'd ask "where's the boat now", but probably get a smart ass reply about how I still hadn't told you what the boat weighed. That's too bad, because if the boat is in a yard with a Travelift, many of those lifts are equipped with a way to measure the actual weight of a load. Anything else, whether based on dimensions, listed displacement, or whatever is a SWAG, and not even all that S in the end. |
A question about boat weight and displacement
writes:
You have not answered: What state do you live in? This is relevant to the weight of a boat how? How anonymous do you intend to remain? As much as possible. I have several concerns, all of which are not relevant to the questions being asked. If I lived in North Carolina, the vessel would weigh the same as if I lived in North Dakota. Go down to the local county fair. There's a guy there who for $2 will guess your weight. Bet he does boats, too. That's what you're expecting the people on this group to do.....guess the weight. I'd ask "where's the boat now", but probably get a smart ass reply about how I still hadn't told you what the boat weighed. That's too bad, because if the boat is in a yard with a Travelift, many of those lifts are equipped with a way to measure the actual weight of a load. Anything else, whether based on dimensions, listed displacement, or whatever is a SWAG, and not even all that S in the end. |
A question about boat weight and displacement
"WaIIy" wrote in message ... This mimara guy is a known troll. Remember a while back when he was pretending to be some foreign guy? No, I'm new here. -- Scott Vernon Plowville PA __/)__/)__ |
A question about boat weight and displacement
"WaIIy" wrote in message ... This mimara guy is a known troll. Remember a while back when he was pretending to be some foreign guy? No, I'm new here. -- Scott Vernon Plowville PA __/)__/)__ |
A question about boat weight and displacement
$99,000 !!!! For that much you could buy a REAL truck.
SV wrote in message Since you are not sure about the F150 or F250, then you should get a F650. Click here for more info: http://www.f650pickups.com |
A question about boat weight and displacement
$99,000 !!!! For that much you could buy a REAL truck.
SV wrote in message Since you are not sure about the F150 or F250, then you should get a F650. Click here for more info: http://www.f650pickups.com |
A question about boat weight and displacement
Comments below:
"Ante Topic Mimara" ] wrote in message news:XLTQSVUD38078.3849652778@anonymous... DUINK writes: As far as I know displacement = weight. Somehow, this doesn't sound right to me. Certainly the weight of the boat will displace the amount of water with that same weight (hence the term displacement). If something displaces X pounds of water, it must weigh X - n to be able to float. It must weigh less than the amount of water it displaces, else it will have neutral (or worse, negative) buoyancy. You aren't thinking this through completely. A boat's weight is equal to its displacement. In other words, the weight of the amount of water it displaces (or moves out of the hole in the water it makes when floating) is equal to the weight of the boat displacing that water. If a boat displaces X pounds of water it weighs X, if it weighed X-n it would only displace X-n. If it weighs more it will displace more water until you get to the point it can no longer displace more water as it has sank/submerged. In a sense, any boat floating is at neutral boyancy (it is neither rising out of the water, nor is it sinking) but has lots of reserve boyancy (the part of the hull above the water line which would displace more water if it was forced down into the water) to accomodate additional weight that may be added. Or to provide freeboard to keep waves from coming abord, wahtever. There are a number of different way displacement is listed. Others get into that in later posts. I though I'd try to clear up this aspect here. -- Ken Heaton & Anne Tobin Cape Breton Island, Canada kenheaton AT ess wye dee DOT eastlink DOT ca Having said this, how do I determine how much it weighs, from limited information, without being there to weigh it? That said, for documentation purposes the Coast Guard refers to a tonnage (don't recall if they call it displacement) that relates only to boat volume, not the weight. This is very interesting. It also has nothing to do with what I asked originally. I cannot see inquiring of the Coast Guard about the tonnage or volume of a 28 foot motor boat. What can they tell me about how much this vessel weighs, by me inquiring about the volume of the boat? I do not understand where you were going with this. Do you have anything to add that will address the original question? --- - Topic-Mimara Unique in the World! --- -=- This message was posted via two or more anonymous remailing services. |
A question about boat weight and displacement
Comments below:
"Ante Topic Mimara" ] wrote in message news:XLTQSVUD38078.3849652778@anonymous... DUINK writes: As far as I know displacement = weight. Somehow, this doesn't sound right to me. Certainly the weight of the boat will displace the amount of water with that same weight (hence the term displacement). If something displaces X pounds of water, it must weigh X - n to be able to float. It must weigh less than the amount of water it displaces, else it will have neutral (or worse, negative) buoyancy. You aren't thinking this through completely. A boat's weight is equal to its displacement. In other words, the weight of the amount of water it displaces (or moves out of the hole in the water it makes when floating) is equal to the weight of the boat displacing that water. If a boat displaces X pounds of water it weighs X, if it weighed X-n it would only displace X-n. If it weighs more it will displace more water until you get to the point it can no longer displace more water as it has sank/submerged. In a sense, any boat floating is at neutral boyancy (it is neither rising out of the water, nor is it sinking) but has lots of reserve boyancy (the part of the hull above the water line which would displace more water if it was forced down into the water) to accomodate additional weight that may be added. Or to provide freeboard to keep waves from coming abord, wahtever. There are a number of different way displacement is listed. Others get into that in later posts. I though I'd try to clear up this aspect here. -- Ken Heaton & Anne Tobin Cape Breton Island, Canada kenheaton AT ess wye dee DOT eastlink DOT ca Having said this, how do I determine how much it weighs, from limited information, without being there to weigh it? That said, for documentation purposes the Coast Guard refers to a tonnage (don't recall if they call it displacement) that relates only to boat volume, not the weight. This is very interesting. It also has nothing to do with what I asked originally. I cannot see inquiring of the Coast Guard about the tonnage or volume of a 28 foot motor boat. What can they tell me about how much this vessel weighs, by me inquiring about the volume of the boat? I do not understand where you were going with this. Do you have anything to add that will address the original question? --- - Topic-Mimara Unique in the World! --- -=- This message was posted via two or more anonymous remailing services. |
All times are GMT +1. The time now is 08:13 AM. |
|
Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com