BoatBanter.com

BoatBanter.com (https://www.boatbanter.com/)
-   Cruising (https://www.boatbanter.com/cruising/)
-   -   Through-hull question (https://www.boatbanter.com/cruising/8463-through-hull-question.html)

Trent D. Sanders December 15th 03 12:57 AM

Through-hull question
 
We replaced all the through-hulls on my Islander 29 with new bronze
through-hulls and bronze/stainless ball valves. The threads on the
through-hulls were straight threads, while the threads on the ball
valves were tapered [pipe] threads. As a consequence the ball valves
only tightened down on the through-hulls by about 2 "turns". The
yardman that did the job said that was the "accepted practice" and not
to worry about it.

But,,,, in this month's issue of Good Old Boat's newsletter supplement
there's this,,, "You must use straight threads on both the valve and
through-hull, or tapered on both. Mixing tapered and straight threads
is the worst thing you can do, and sadly it is [or was] common".

So, my question is,,,, does anyone know where to obtain
bronze/stainless ball valves with straight threads? Easier to replace
the ball valves rather than the through-hulls.

I'd use proper seacocks but they require bolting to the hull which
would be difficult with a fiberglass hull.

Thanking you in advance,

Trent Sanders
S/V Cimba
Marina Del Rey
Southern California

doug dotson December 15th 03 02:55 AM

Through-hull question
 
I think you have answered your own question. To the best of
my knowledge ball valves are not acceptable for seacocks.
Not sure why. That may be why thru-hulls and seacocks use
straight threads. So ball valves won't fit. I've never had a seacock
bolted to the hull. Normally the thru-hull is bedded and secured with
the retaining ring and the seacock is just threaded on. Even
though the seacock has a flange that will accept bolts, the flange
has always just floated.

Doug
s/v Callista

"Trent D. Sanders" wrote in message
om...
We replaced all the through-hulls on my Islander 29 with new bronze
through-hulls and bronze/stainless ball valves. The threads on the
through-hulls were straight threads, while the threads on the ball
valves were tapered [pipe] threads. As a consequence the ball valves
only tightened down on the through-hulls by about 2 "turns". The
yardman that did the job said that was the "accepted practice" and not
to worry about it.

But,,,, in this month's issue of Good Old Boat's newsletter supplement
there's this,,, "You must use straight threads on both the valve and
through-hull, or tapered on both. Mixing tapered and straight threads
is the worst thing you can do, and sadly it is [or was] common".

So, my question is,,,, does anyone know where to obtain
bronze/stainless ball valves with straight threads? Easier to replace
the ball valves rather than the through-hulls.

I'd use proper seacocks but they require bolting to the hull which
would be difficult with a fiberglass hull.

Thanking you in advance,

Trent Sanders
S/V Cimba
Marina Del Rey
Southern California




doug dotson December 15th 03 02:55 AM

Through-hull question
 
I think you have answered your own question. To the best of
my knowledge ball valves are not acceptable for seacocks.
Not sure why. That may be why thru-hulls and seacocks use
straight threads. So ball valves won't fit. I've never had a seacock
bolted to the hull. Normally the thru-hull is bedded and secured with
the retaining ring and the seacock is just threaded on. Even
though the seacock has a flange that will accept bolts, the flange
has always just floated.

Doug
s/v Callista

"Trent D. Sanders" wrote in message
om...
We replaced all the through-hulls on my Islander 29 with new bronze
through-hulls and bronze/stainless ball valves. The threads on the
through-hulls were straight threads, while the threads on the ball
valves were tapered [pipe] threads. As a consequence the ball valves
only tightened down on the through-hulls by about 2 "turns". The
yardman that did the job said that was the "accepted practice" and not
to worry about it.

But,,,, in this month's issue of Good Old Boat's newsletter supplement
there's this,,, "You must use straight threads on both the valve and
through-hull, or tapered on both. Mixing tapered and straight threads
is the worst thing you can do, and sadly it is [or was] common".

So, my question is,,,, does anyone know where to obtain
bronze/stainless ball valves with straight threads? Easier to replace
the ball valves rather than the through-hulls.

I'd use proper seacocks but they require bolting to the hull which
would be difficult with a fiberglass hull.

Thanking you in advance,

Trent Sanders
S/V Cimba
Marina Del Rey
Southern California




Everett December 15th 03 04:01 AM

Through-hull question
 
"Trent D. Sanders" wrote in message
om...
We replaced all the through-hulls on my Islander 29 with new bronze
through-hulls and bronze/stainless ball valves. The threads on the
through-hulls were straight threads, while the threads on the ball
valves were tapered [pipe] threads. As a consequence the ball valves
only tightened down on the through-hulls by about 2 "turns". The
yardman that did the job said that was the "accepted practice" and not
to worry about it.

But,,,, in this month's issue of Good Old Boat's newsletter supplement
there's this,,, "You must use straight threads on both the valve and
through-hull, or tapered on both. Mixing tapered and straight threads
is the worst thing you can do, and sadly it is [or was] common".

So, my question is,,,, does anyone know where to obtain
bronze/stainless ball valves with straight threads? Easier to replace
the ball valves rather than the through-hulls.

I'd use proper seacocks but they require bolting to the hull which
would be difficult with a fiberglass hull.

Thanking you in advance,

Trent Sanders
S/V Cimba
Marina Del Rey
Southern California


If you can find a tap of the right size, you could "untaper" the ball valve
so it fits correctly.



Everett December 15th 03 04:01 AM

Through-hull question
 
"Trent D. Sanders" wrote in message
om...
We replaced all the through-hulls on my Islander 29 with new bronze
through-hulls and bronze/stainless ball valves. The threads on the
through-hulls were straight threads, while the threads on the ball
valves were tapered [pipe] threads. As a consequence the ball valves
only tightened down on the through-hulls by about 2 "turns". The
yardman that did the job said that was the "accepted practice" and not
to worry about it.

But,,,, in this month's issue of Good Old Boat's newsletter supplement
there's this,,, "You must use straight threads on both the valve and
through-hull, or tapered on both. Mixing tapered and straight threads
is the worst thing you can do, and sadly it is [or was] common".

So, my question is,,,, does anyone know where to obtain
bronze/stainless ball valves with straight threads? Easier to replace
the ball valves rather than the through-hulls.

I'd use proper seacocks but they require bolting to the hull which
would be difficult with a fiberglass hull.

Thanking you in advance,

Trent Sanders
S/V Cimba
Marina Del Rey
Southern California


If you can find a tap of the right size, you could "untaper" the ball valve
so it fits correctly.



98stratus December 15th 03 04:07 AM

Through-hull question
 
Wrong...
if you use a proper seacock, throw the nut from the through hull away. The
seacock should be through bolted, but mose people seem to screw it to the
backing plate. Which is better than nothing. Also throw away those ball
vales, they are not designed for this task and. Yes you are correct you
only have 2 or 3 threads seperating you from a sinking!

Pierre

"doug dotson" wrote in message
...
I think you have answered your own question. To the best of
my knowledge ball valves are not acceptable for seacocks.
Not sure why. That may be why thru-hulls and seacocks use
straight threads. So ball valves won't fit. I've never had a seacock
bolted to the hull. Normally the thru-hull is bedded and secured with
the retaining ring and the seacock is just threaded on. Even
though the seacock has a flange that will accept bolts, the flange
has always just floated.

Doug
s/v Callista

"Trent D. Sanders" wrote in message
om...
We replaced all the through-hulls on my Islander 29 with new bronze
through-hulls and bronze/stainless ball valves. The threads on the
through-hulls were straight threads, while the threads on the ball
valves were tapered [pipe] threads. As a consequence the ball valves
only tightened down on the through-hulls by about 2 "turns". The
yardman that did the job said that was the "accepted practice" and not
to worry about it.

But,,,, in this month's issue of Good Old Boat's newsletter supplement
there's this,,, "You must use straight threads on both the valve and
through-hull, or tapered on both. Mixing tapered and straight threads
is the worst thing you can do, and sadly it is [or was] common".

So, my question is,,,, does anyone know where to obtain
bronze/stainless ball valves with straight threads? Easier to replace
the ball valves rather than the through-hulls.

I'd use proper seacocks but they require bolting to the hull which
would be difficult with a fiberglass hull.

Thanking you in advance,

Trent Sanders
S/V Cimba
Marina Del Rey
Southern California






98stratus December 15th 03 04:07 AM

Through-hull question
 
Wrong...
if you use a proper seacock, throw the nut from the through hull away. The
seacock should be through bolted, but mose people seem to screw it to the
backing plate. Which is better than nothing. Also throw away those ball
vales, they are not designed for this task and. Yes you are correct you
only have 2 or 3 threads seperating you from a sinking!

Pierre

"doug dotson" wrote in message
...
I think you have answered your own question. To the best of
my knowledge ball valves are not acceptable for seacocks.
Not sure why. That may be why thru-hulls and seacocks use
straight threads. So ball valves won't fit. I've never had a seacock
bolted to the hull. Normally the thru-hull is bedded and secured with
the retaining ring and the seacock is just threaded on. Even
though the seacock has a flange that will accept bolts, the flange
has always just floated.

Doug
s/v Callista

"Trent D. Sanders" wrote in message
om...
We replaced all the through-hulls on my Islander 29 with new bronze
through-hulls and bronze/stainless ball valves. The threads on the
through-hulls were straight threads, while the threads on the ball
valves were tapered [pipe] threads. As a consequence the ball valves
only tightened down on the through-hulls by about 2 "turns". The
yardman that did the job said that was the "accepted practice" and not
to worry about it.

But,,,, in this month's issue of Good Old Boat's newsletter supplement
there's this,,, "You must use straight threads on both the valve and
through-hull, or tapered on both. Mixing tapered and straight threads
is the worst thing you can do, and sadly it is [or was] common".

So, my question is,,,, does anyone know where to obtain
bronze/stainless ball valves with straight threads? Easier to replace
the ball valves rather than the through-hulls.

I'd use proper seacocks but they require bolting to the hull which
would be difficult with a fiberglass hull.

Thanking you in advance,

Trent Sanders
S/V Cimba
Marina Del Rey
Southern California






JJ December 15th 03 06:09 AM

Through-hull question
 
So who's the stupid yard - all those in LA should know about it.


On 14 Dec 2003 16:57:45 -0800, (Trent D. Sanders)
wrote:

We replaced all the through-hulls on my Islander 29 with new bronze
through-hulls and bronze/stainless ball valves. The threads on the
through-hulls were straight threads, while the threads on the ball
valves were tapered [pipe] threads. As a consequence the ball valves
only tightened down on the through-hulls by about 2 "turns". The
yardman that did the job said that was the "accepted practice" and not
to worry about it.

But,,,, in this month's issue of Good Old Boat's newsletter supplement
there's this,,, "You must use straight threads on both the valve and
through-hull, or tapered on both. Mixing tapered and straight threads
is the worst thing you can do, and sadly it is [or was] common".

So, my question is,,,, does anyone know where to obtain
bronze/stainless ball valves with straight threads? Easier to replace
the ball valves rather than the through-hulls.

I'd use proper seacocks but they require bolting to the hull which
would be difficult with a fiberglass hull.

Thanking you in advance,

Trent Sanders
S/V Cimba
Marina Del Rey
Southern California



JJ December 15th 03 06:09 AM

Through-hull question
 
So who's the stupid yard - all those in LA should know about it.


On 14 Dec 2003 16:57:45 -0800, (Trent D. Sanders)
wrote:

We replaced all the through-hulls on my Islander 29 with new bronze
through-hulls and bronze/stainless ball valves. The threads on the
through-hulls were straight threads, while the threads on the ball
valves were tapered [pipe] threads. As a consequence the ball valves
only tightened down on the through-hulls by about 2 "turns". The
yardman that did the job said that was the "accepted practice" and not
to worry about it.

But,,,, in this month's issue of Good Old Boat's newsletter supplement
there's this,,, "You must use straight threads on both the valve and
through-hull, or tapered on both. Mixing tapered and straight threads
is the worst thing you can do, and sadly it is [or was] common".

So, my question is,,,, does anyone know where to obtain
bronze/stainless ball valves with straight threads? Easier to replace
the ball valves rather than the through-hulls.

I'd use proper seacocks but they require bolting to the hull which
would be difficult with a fiberglass hull.

Thanking you in advance,

Trent Sanders
S/V Cimba
Marina Del Rey
Southern California



Dennis Gibbons December 15th 03 12:47 PM

Through-hull question
 
It is accepted practice to through-bolt seacocks even with a fiberglass
hull. there should be a backing plate wide enough to spread the load.

--
Dennis Gibbons
S/V Dark Lady
CN35-207
email: dennis dash gibbons at worldnet dot att dot net
"Trent D. Sanders" wrote in message
om...
We replaced all the through-hulls on my Islander 29 with new bronze
through-hulls and bronze/stainless ball valves. The threads on the
through-hulls were straight threads, while the threads on the ball
valves were tapered [pipe] threads. As a consequence the ball valves
only tightened down on the through-hulls by about 2 "turns". The
yardman that did the job said that was the "accepted practice" and not
to worry about it.

But,,,, in this month's issue of Good Old Boat's newsletter supplement
there's this,,, "You must use straight threads on both the valve and
through-hull, or tapered on both. Mixing tapered and straight threads
is the worst thing you can do, and sadly it is [or was] common".

So, my question is,,,, does anyone know where to obtain
bronze/stainless ball valves with straight threads? Easier to replace
the ball valves rather than the through-hulls.

I'd use proper seacocks but they require bolting to the hull which
would be difficult with a fiberglass hull.

Thanking you in advance,

Trent Sanders
S/V Cimba
Marina Del Rey
Southern California





All times are GMT +1. The time now is 05:12 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com