BoatBanter.com

BoatBanter.com (https://www.boatbanter.com/)
-   Cruising (https://www.boatbanter.com/cruising/)
-   -   Burglar alarms (https://www.boatbanter.com/cruising/8432-burglar-alarms.html)

John Smith December 11th 03 08:59 AM

Burglar alarms
 
Looking for some advice on the most appropriate sensors for a moored
cruiser. I have switches on the door, the hatch and some windows, I have
two infra red motion detectors and a pressure mat.

Are the IR detectors any good on a boat that sways a lot in the wind etc?
Any other options?

Thanks in advance



Jean Dufour December 11th 03 03:07 PM

Burglar alarms
 
IR sensors will detect the heat generated by someone in your boat. It's
ultrasound sensors that would be trigered by the motion of something moving
in your boat. But what if the boat's interior is heated to higher than the
body's temperature on a sunny day? I dunno enough about this to risk a
categoric answer. But I GUESS it would generate a false alarm.

Jean Dufour
Montreal, Qc

John Smith wrote:

Looking for some advice on the most appropriate sensors for a moored
cruiser. I have switches on the door, the hatch and some windows, I have
two infra red motion detectors and a pressure mat.

Are the IR detectors any good on a boat that sways a lot in the wind etc?
Any other options?

Thanks in advance



Jean Dufour December 11th 03 03:07 PM

Burglar alarms
 
IR sensors will detect the heat generated by someone in your boat. It's
ultrasound sensors that would be trigered by the motion of something moving
in your boat. But what if the boat's interior is heated to higher than the
body's temperature on a sunny day? I dunno enough about this to risk a
categoric answer. But I GUESS it would generate a false alarm.

Jean Dufour
Montreal, Qc

John Smith wrote:

Looking for some advice on the most appropriate sensors for a moored
cruiser. I have switches on the door, the hatch and some windows, I have
two infra red motion detectors and a pressure mat.

Are the IR detectors any good on a boat that sways a lot in the wind etc?
Any other options?

Thanks in advance



Haakon Dybdahl December 11th 03 03:45 PM

Burglar alarms
 
I think IR sensors set off an alarm when the "picture" of IR changes. I have
done some testing with home security alarams, and if you really move slowly,
the alarm will not go off.

Haakon

"Jean Dufour" wrote in message
...
IR sensors will detect the heat generated by someone in your boat. It's
ultrasound sensors that would be trigered by the motion of something

moving
in your boat. But what if the boat's interior is heated to higher than the
body's temperature on a sunny day? I dunno enough about this to risk a
categoric answer. But I GUESS it would generate a false alarm.

Jean Dufour
Montreal, Qc

John Smith wrote:

Looking for some advice on the most appropriate sensors for a moored
cruiser. I have switches on the door, the hatch and some windows, I

have
two infra red motion detectors and a pressure mat.

Are the IR detectors any good on a boat that sways a lot in the wind

etc?
Any other options?

Thanks in advance





Haakon Dybdahl December 11th 03 03:45 PM

Burglar alarms
 
I think IR sensors set off an alarm when the "picture" of IR changes. I have
done some testing with home security alarams, and if you really move slowly,
the alarm will not go off.

Haakon

"Jean Dufour" wrote in message
...
IR sensors will detect the heat generated by someone in your boat. It's
ultrasound sensors that would be trigered by the motion of something

moving
in your boat. But what if the boat's interior is heated to higher than the
body's temperature on a sunny day? I dunno enough about this to risk a
categoric answer. But I GUESS it would generate a false alarm.

Jean Dufour
Montreal, Qc

John Smith wrote:

Looking for some advice on the most appropriate sensors for a moored
cruiser. I have switches on the door, the hatch and some windows, I

have
two infra red motion detectors and a pressure mat.

Are the IR detectors any good on a boat that sways a lot in the wind

etc?
Any other options?

Thanks in advance





Meindert Sprang December 11th 03 06:14 PM

Burglar alarms
 
"Jean Dufour" wrote in message
...
IR sensors will detect the heat generated by someone in your boat. It's
ultrasound sensors that would be trigered by the motion of something

moving
in your boat. But what if the boat's interior is heated to higher than the
body's temperature on a sunny day? I dunno enough about this to risk a
categoric answer. But I GUESS it would generate a false alarm.


They don't. IR sensors 'look' into the area in sectors, like A-B-A-B-A-B and
reacts on the difference between A and B. If the environment temperature
changes, both the A and B sectors change, hence no alarm. If someone walks
through the area, A changes, then B, then A again. The alarm trigger is set
to the amount of change and the number of changes. It can be set so
accurately that it wouldn't alarm on a cat or a small dog, but only on a
large enough body, like a human. Because is reacts on changes, it also does
not alarm on a sudden sunshine through a porthole.

Meindert



Meindert Sprang December 11th 03 06:14 PM

Burglar alarms
 
"Jean Dufour" wrote in message
...
IR sensors will detect the heat generated by someone in your boat. It's
ultrasound sensors that would be trigered by the motion of something

moving
in your boat. But what if the boat's interior is heated to higher than the
body's temperature on a sunny day? I dunno enough about this to risk a
categoric answer. But I GUESS it would generate a false alarm.


They don't. IR sensors 'look' into the area in sectors, like A-B-A-B-A-B and
reacts on the difference between A and B. If the environment temperature
changes, both the A and B sectors change, hence no alarm. If someone walks
through the area, A changes, then B, then A again. The alarm trigger is set
to the amount of change and the number of changes. It can be set so
accurately that it wouldn't alarm on a cat or a small dog, but only on a
large enough body, like a human. Because is reacts on changes, it also does
not alarm on a sudden sunshine through a porthole.

Meindert



padeen December 11th 03 07:29 PM

12V IR Detectors?
 
Anyone found a source for 12 volt IR detectors?


"John Smith" wrote in message
...
Looking for some advice on the most appropriate sensors for a moored
cruiser. I have switches on the door, the hatch and some windows, I have
two infra red motion detectors and a pressure mat.

Are the IR detectors any good on a boat that sways a lot in the wind etc?
Any other options?

Thanks in advance





padeen December 11th 03 07:29 PM

12V IR Detectors?
 
Anyone found a source for 12 volt IR detectors?


"John Smith" wrote in message
...
Looking for some advice on the most appropriate sensors for a moored
cruiser. I have switches on the door, the hatch and some windows, I have
two infra red motion detectors and a pressure mat.

Are the IR detectors any good on a boat that sways a lot in the wind etc?
Any other options?

Thanks in advance





Marcus AAkesson December 12th 03 12:06 AM

12V IR Detectors?
 
On Thu, 11 Dec 2003 19:29:21 GMT, "padeen"
wrote:

Anyone found a source for 12 volt IR detectors?


I hope You are joking, as they are all 12V for normal alarm use.
/Marcus

--
Marcus AAkesson
Gothenburg Callsigns: SM6XFN & SB4779
Sweden
Keep the world clean - no HTML in news or mail !


Marcus AAkesson December 12th 03 12:06 AM

12V IR Detectors?
 
On Thu, 11 Dec 2003 19:29:21 GMT, "padeen"
wrote:

Anyone found a source for 12 volt IR detectors?


I hope You are joking, as they are all 12V for normal alarm use.
/Marcus

--
Marcus AAkesson
Gothenburg Callsigns: SM6XFN & SB4779
Sweden
Keep the world clean - no HTML in news or mail !


padeen December 12th 03 10:31 AM

12V IR Detectors?
 
Marcus, are you capable of understanding that your post reveals our combined
ignorance? I'm an electrician who's been installing 120V IR sensors for
many years, but haven't had any alarm experience. You, on the other hand,
see the world from the 12V side. Shall we both broaden our knowledge?

Padeen


"Marcus AAkesson" wrote in message
...
On Thu, 11 Dec 2003 19:29:21 GMT, "padeen"
wrote:

Anyone found a source for 12 volt IR detectors?


I hope You are joking, as they are all 12V for normal alarm use.
/Marcus

--
Marcus AAkesson
Gothenburg Callsigns: SM6XFN & SB4779
Sweden
Keep the world clean - no HTML in news or mail !




padeen December 12th 03 10:31 AM

12V IR Detectors?
 
Marcus, are you capable of understanding that your post reveals our combined
ignorance? I'm an electrician who's been installing 120V IR sensors for
many years, but haven't had any alarm experience. You, on the other hand,
see the world from the 12V side. Shall we both broaden our knowledge?

Padeen


"Marcus AAkesson" wrote in message
...
On Thu, 11 Dec 2003 19:29:21 GMT, "padeen"
wrote:

Anyone found a source for 12 volt IR detectors?


I hope You are joking, as they are all 12V for normal alarm use.
/Marcus

--
Marcus AAkesson
Gothenburg Callsigns: SM6XFN & SB4779
Sweden
Keep the world clean - no HTML in news or mail !




Meindert Sprang December 12th 03 11:23 AM

12V IR Detectors?
 
"padeen" wrote in message
...
Marcus, are you capable of understanding that your post reveals our

combined
ignorance? I'm an electrician who's been installing 120V IR sensors for
many years, but haven't had any alarm experience. You, on the other hand,
see the world from the 12V side. Shall we both broaden our knowledge?


Well, I think Marcus is right. I think it would be fair to say that ALL IR
sensors for alarm applications are 12V, since it doesn't make sense to run
an alarm sensor at 120V when it will be connected to an alarm system that
works on low voltage. I think the 120V or 240V types you refer to are the
ones used to control a light. And you don't want to use these for an alarm
system because they react on anything. The alarm types are better in
discriminating between events that are important (moving people) and not
important (moving small animals for instance).

Meindert



Meindert Sprang December 12th 03 11:23 AM

12V IR Detectors?
 
"padeen" wrote in message
...
Marcus, are you capable of understanding that your post reveals our

combined
ignorance? I'm an electrician who's been installing 120V IR sensors for
many years, but haven't had any alarm experience. You, on the other hand,
see the world from the 12V side. Shall we both broaden our knowledge?


Well, I think Marcus is right. I think it would be fair to say that ALL IR
sensors for alarm applications are 12V, since it doesn't make sense to run
an alarm sensor at 120V when it will be connected to an alarm system that
works on low voltage. I think the 120V or 240V types you refer to are the
ones used to control a light. And you don't want to use these for an alarm
system because they react on anything. The alarm types are better in
discriminating between events that are important (moving people) and not
important (moving small animals for instance).

Meindert



padeen December 12th 03 09:01 PM

12V IR Detectors?
 
The 120V sensors will control anything you want them to control, and have
considerable adjustment capabilities so as not to "react on anything",
including small animals, wind-propelled trees, or street traffic. But of
course all 12V alarm systems would have 12V sensors! However, I would
expect that the internal sensor electronics for both 12 and 120V is
essentially similar, with the difference being only in the PS & switch.

Padeen



"Meindert Sprang" wrote in message
...
"padeen" wrote in message
...
Marcus, are you capable of understanding that your post reveals our

combined
ignorance? I'm an electrician who's been installing 120V IR sensors for
many years, but haven't had any alarm experience. You, on the other

hand,
see the world from the 12V side. Shall we both broaden our knowledge?


Well, I think Marcus is right. I think it would be fair to say that ALL IR
sensors for alarm applications are 12V, since it doesn't make sense to run
an alarm sensor at 120V when it will be connected to an alarm system that
works on low voltage. I think the 120V or 240V types you refer to are the
ones used to control a light. And you don't want to use these for an alarm
system because they react on anything. The alarm types are better in
discriminating between events that are important (moving people) and not
important (moving small animals for instance).

Meindert





padeen December 12th 03 09:01 PM

12V IR Detectors?
 
The 120V sensors will control anything you want them to control, and have
considerable adjustment capabilities so as not to "react on anything",
including small animals, wind-propelled trees, or street traffic. But of
course all 12V alarm systems would have 12V sensors! However, I would
expect that the internal sensor electronics for both 12 and 120V is
essentially similar, with the difference being only in the PS & switch.

Padeen



"Meindert Sprang" wrote in message
...
"padeen" wrote in message
...
Marcus, are you capable of understanding that your post reveals our

combined
ignorance? I'm an electrician who's been installing 120V IR sensors for
many years, but haven't had any alarm experience. You, on the other

hand,
see the world from the 12V side. Shall we both broaden our knowledge?


Well, I think Marcus is right. I think it would be fair to say that ALL IR
sensors for alarm applications are 12V, since it doesn't make sense to run
an alarm sensor at 120V when it will be connected to an alarm system that
works on low voltage. I think the 120V or 240V types you refer to are the
ones used to control a light. And you don't want to use these for an alarm
system because they react on anything. The alarm types are better in
discriminating between events that are important (moving people) and not
important (moving small animals for instance).

Meindert





Larry December 12th 03 09:13 PM

12V IR Detectors?
 
On Thu, 11 Dec 2003 19:29:21 GMT, padeen wrote:

Anyone found a source for 12 volt IR detectors?


Pretty sure you can buy them from Eastern Distributors since you're an
electrician. They're available from all the alarm wholesalers - Ademco,
Tri-State, etc. - but they might not be willing to sell to you without a
bunch of rigamarole.
--

Larry
email is rapp at lmr dot com

Larry December 12th 03 09:13 PM

12V IR Detectors?
 
On Thu, 11 Dec 2003 19:29:21 GMT, padeen wrote:

Anyone found a source for 12 volt IR detectors?


Pretty sure you can buy them from Eastern Distributors since you're an
electrician. They're available from all the alarm wholesalers - Ademco,
Tri-State, etc. - but they might not be willing to sell to you without a
bunch of rigamarole.
--

Larry
email is rapp at lmr dot com

Marcus AAkesson December 12th 03 11:21 PM

12V IR Detectors?
 
On Fri, 12 Dec 2003 10:31:03 GMT, "padeen"
wrote:

Marcus, are you capable of understanding that your post reveals our combined
ignorance? I'm an electrician who's been installing 120V IR sensors for
many years, but haven't had any alarm experience. You, on the other hand,
see the world from the 12V side. Shall we both broaden our knowledge?


No offense meant!

I'm very well aware of all the AC (here 230V) IR sensors around, but
as the subject of the main thread was "Burglar alarms", the field of
application was pretty much given.

Since a fundamental requirement of alarm systems is to run on backup
power, everything is DC (usually 12V), just like in a boat (how
convenient) !

I have a boat alarm based on switches and an IR sensor and haven't had
any problems with false alarms. There are many nice products in the
market, and the latest offer positioning, alarm and remote control by
GSM/SMS. You can check the wind conditions from work, and then decide
to go out or not. Nice.

http://www.seakey.com/indexe.htm

http://www.boatgard.com/en/index.htm


/Marcus

--
Marcus AAkesson
Gothenburg Callsigns: SM6XFN & SB4779
Sweden
Keep the world clean - no HTML in news or mail !


Marcus AAkesson December 12th 03 11:21 PM

12V IR Detectors?
 
On Fri, 12 Dec 2003 10:31:03 GMT, "padeen"
wrote:

Marcus, are you capable of understanding that your post reveals our combined
ignorance? I'm an electrician who's been installing 120V IR sensors for
many years, but haven't had any alarm experience. You, on the other hand,
see the world from the 12V side. Shall we both broaden our knowledge?


No offense meant!

I'm very well aware of all the AC (here 230V) IR sensors around, but
as the subject of the main thread was "Burglar alarms", the field of
application was pretty much given.

Since a fundamental requirement of alarm systems is to run on backup
power, everything is DC (usually 12V), just like in a boat (how
convenient) !

I have a boat alarm based on switches and an IR sensor and haven't had
any problems with false alarms. There are many nice products in the
market, and the latest offer positioning, alarm and remote control by
GSM/SMS. You can check the wind conditions from work, and then decide
to go out or not. Nice.

http://www.seakey.com/indexe.htm

http://www.boatgard.com/en/index.htm


/Marcus

--
Marcus AAkesson
Gothenburg Callsigns: SM6XFN & SB4779
Sweden
Keep the world clean - no HTML in news or mail !



All times are GMT +1. The time now is 03:19 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com