![]() |
Sailing for the aged
Does anyone have sail boat recommendations for a couple in their 80s?
Frankly, my dad has a lot of trouble moving quickly and so much less strength that he makes me appear to be Atlas. He has tried powerboats twice but frankly he loves to go out and sail on Long Island Sound. I am interested in sail boats with equipment or specifically earmarked for the older sailor which are designed to allow those with less strength to succeed. He could keep it at a dock to charge up electrical stuff... TIA, harlan -- To respond, obviously drop the "nospan"? |
Sailing for the aged
In article ,
Harlan Lachman wrote: Does anyone have sail boat recommendations for a couple in their 80s? Frankly, my dad has a lot of trouble moving quickly and so much less strength that he makes me appear to be Atlas. He has tried powerboats twice but frankly he loves to go out and sail on Long Island Sound. I am interested in sail boats with equipment or specifically earmarked for the older sailor which are designed to allow those with less strength to succeed. He could keep it at a dock to charge up electrical stuff... My first thought is cat-boat: A single sail, stable and the newer designs are pretty good sailing vessels. -- Jere Lull Xan-a-Deux ('73 Tanzer 28 #4 out of Tolchester, MD) Xan's Pages: http://members.dca.net/jerelull/X-Main.html Our BVI FAQs (290+ pics) http://homepage.mac.com/jerelull/BVI/ |
Sailing for the aged
Harlan Lachman wrote:
Does anyone have sail boat recommendations for a couple in their 80s? Frankly, my dad has a lot of trouble moving quickly and so much less strength that he makes me appear to be Atlas. He has tried powerboats twice but frankly he loves to go out and sail on Long Island Sound. I am interested in sail boats with equipment or specifically earmarked for the older sailor which are designed to allow those with less strength to succeed. He could keep it at a dock to charge up electrical stuff... TIA, harlan I wonder if a modified version of the 'Sail Able' boats used by handicapped people would help? http://www.pspmembers.com/syclub/sailableNS.htm |
Sailing for the aged
Harlan Lachman wrote:
Does anyone have sail boat recommendations for a couple in their 80s? Frankly, my dad has a lot of trouble moving quickly and so much less strength that he makes me appear to be Atlas. He has tried powerboats twice but frankly he loves to go out and sail on Long Island Sound. I am interested in sail boats with equipment or specifically earmarked for the older sailor which are designed to allow those with less strength to succeed. He could keep it at a dock to charge up electrical stuff... http://www.santanasailboats.com/boat...0/harbor20.htm Have not sailed one of these myself, but there are a few around and they look like fun... easy to handle from what I've seen. Fresh Breezes- Doug King |
Sailing for the aged
Harlan Lachman wrote:
Does anyone have sail boat recommendations for a couple in their 80s? snip SFWIW, I'm on another list with a guy in Rhode Island that has sailed a Marshal cat boat for years. He loves it and while not 80, is no spring chicken either. If you want something smaller, how about a 9 ft Fatty Knees, a dinghy designed by Lyle Hess and now being built by Eddy & Duff. Lew |
Sailing for the aged
Lew Hodgett wrote:
Harlan Lachman wrote: Does anyone have sail boat recommendations for a couple in their 80s? snip SFWIW, I'm on another list with a guy in Rhode Island that has sailed a Marshal cat boat for years. He loves it and while not 80, is no spring chicken either. If you want something smaller, how about a 9 ft Fatty Knees, a dinghy designed by Lyle Hess and now being built by Eddy & Duff. Lew I certainly wouldn't recommend a Fatty Knees to anyone with mobility problems. It would be a death trap - they wouldn't last one tack! I have one - I only capsized once, but that was stepping into it from my boat. A Marshall 15 might be better, but the larger ones have a lot of sail to handle. I was thinking of a Rhodes 19, or the Mariner (same hull, with a cuddy). With a keel its going to be stable, nothing happens too quickly, and the sails aren't to large to handle. Its even reasonably functional under main alone. Of course, a lot depends on where they are and what type of sailing they want to do. |
Sailing for the aged
Harlan Lachman wrote:
Does anyone have sail boat recommendations for a couple in their 80s? snip Lew Hodgett wrote: SFWIW, I'm on another list with a guy in Rhode Island that has sailed a Marshal cat boat for years. He loves it and while not 80, is no spring chicken either. If you want something smaller, how about a 9 ft Fatty Knees, a dinghy designed by Lyle Hess and now being built by Eddy & Duff. If you want to go with something small, why not a Tech dinghy? Jeff wrote: I certainly wouldn't recommend a Fatty Knees to anyone with mobility problems. It would be a death trap - they wouldn't last one tack! I have one - I only capsized once, but that was stepping into it from my boat. And they're not as tippy as some other hard dinks. A Tech or one of the other frostbiting classes might be a good mix of stability & performance. A Marshall 15 might be better, but the larger ones have a lot of sail to handle. A Beetle Cat! .... I was thinking of a Rhodes 19, or the Mariner (same hull, with a cuddy). With a keel its going to be stable, nothing happens too quickly, and the sails aren't to large to handle. Its even reasonably functional under main alone. Good idea. Of course, a lot depends on where they are and what type of sailing they want to do. A boat with a cuddy cabin need not make it too large or heavy or expensive, and can add functionality. DSK |
Sailing for the aged
Before doing any boat recommendations I need to know about the couple.
Eighty year of age does not means much. How physically flexible is the couple. Are they quick enough to react if the boom swims toward them. Can they swim ashore if their boat capsizes or can they get back in their boat. I know people sailing dinghies is their late eighty and doing extremely well. Mr. X is over eighty five. He build his own 11'2" Shellback Dinghy. During the summer he takes his grandson sailing with him or his girlfriend of the same age. Conversely, today you can buy 30 (and up) foot sloop sailboat with walk though transom, furling for the main and jib. If a couple has been physically active and know what they are doing on the water age is not a problem. "DSK" wrote in message ... Harlan Lachman wrote: Does anyone have sail boat recommendations for a couple in their 80s? snip Lew Hodgett wrote: SFWIW, I'm on another list with a guy in Rhode Island that has sailed a Marshal cat boat for years. He loves it and while not 80, is no spring chicken either. If you want something smaller, how about a 9 ft Fatty Knees, a dinghy designed by Lyle Hess and now being built by Eddy & Duff. If you want to go with something small, why not a Tech dinghy? Jeff wrote: I certainly wouldn't recommend a Fatty Knees to anyone with mobility problems. It would be a death trap - they wouldn't last one tack! I have one - I only capsized once, but that was stepping into it from my boat. And they're not as tippy as some other hard dinks. A Tech or one of the other frostbiting classes might be a good mix of stability & performance. A Marshall 15 might be better, but the larger ones have a lot of sail to handle. A Beetle Cat! .... I was thinking of a Rhodes 19, or the Mariner (same hull, with a cuddy). With a keel its going to be stable, nothing happens too quickly, and the sails aren't to large to handle. Its even reasonably functional under main alone. Good idea. Of course, a lot depends on where they are and what type of sailing they want to do. A boat with a cuddy cabin need not make it too large or heavy or expensive, and can add functionality. DSK |
Sailing for the aged
DSK wrote:
If you want something smaller, how about a 9 ft Fatty Knees, a dinghy designed by Lyle Hess and now being built by Eddy & Duff. If you want to go with something small, why not a Tech dinghy? A Tech is a great student dinghy, but its still tippy in puffy weather. The older version were not self rescuing, they would come up filled with water. The latest version ("the fifth fleet") are said to be better in this regard. Jeff wrote: I certainly wouldn't recommend a Fatty Knees to anyone with mobility problems. It would be a death trap - they wouldn't last one tack! I have one - I only capsized once, but that was stepping into it from my boat. And they're not as tippy as some other hard dinks. A Tech or one of the other frostbiting classes might be a good mix of stability & performance. Oddly, the common frostbiter in Marblehead is the Interclub Dinghy, one of the tippiest dinks ever built. A Marshall 15 might be better, but the larger ones have a lot of sail to handle. A Beetle Cat! Good choice. How about one of the variations of an H12? .... I was thinking of a Rhodes 19, or the Mariner (same hull, with a cuddy). With a keel its going to be stable, nothing happens too quickly, and the sails aren't to large to handle. Its even reasonably functional under main alone. Good idea. Of course, a lot depends on where they are and what type of sailing they want to do. A boat with a cuddy cabin need not make it too large or heavy or expensive, and can add functionality. DSK |
Sailing for the aged
In article ,
Jeff wrote: Lew Hodgett wrote: Harlan Lachman wrote: Does anyone have sail boat recommendations for a couple in their 80s? snip SFWIW, I'm on another list with a guy in Rhode Island that has sailed a Marshal cat boat for years. He loves it and while not 80, is no spring chicken either. If you want something smaller, how about a 9 ft Fatty Knees, a dinghy designed by Lyle Hess and now being built by Eddy & Duff. Lew I certainly wouldn't recommend a Fatty Knees to anyone with mobility problems. It would be a death trap - they wouldn't last one tack! I have one - I only capsized once, but that was stepping into it from my boat. A Marshall 15 might be better, but the larger ones have a lot of sail to handle. I was thinking of a Rhodes 19, or the Mariner (same hull, with a cuddy). With a keel its going to be stable, nothing happens too quickly, and the sails aren't to large to handle. Its even reasonably functional under main alone. Of course, a lot depends on where they are and what type of sailing they want to do. Thanks guys. But I am pretty sure with his experience and money (not to mention bladder), he would want a bigger boat. I am just not sure anyone makes anything to compensate for someone unable to reliably hoist and lower sails manually. harlan -- To respond, obviously drop the "nospan"? |
Sailing for the aged
Good questions, I will try to address them as you asked them:
In article , wrote: Before doing any boat recommendations I need to know about the couple. Eighty year of age does not means much. How physically flexible is the couple. Are they quick enough to react if the boom swims toward them. Absolutely, especially since after 60 - 70 years of sailing they can anticipate the danger based on wind conditions. Can they swim ashore if their boat capsizes or can they get back in their boat. At their age and given the water temperatures and distances of LI Sound out of Mamaroneck, I think not. I know people sailing dinghies is their late eighty and doing extremely well. Mr. X is over eighty five. He build his own 11'2" Shellback Dinghy. During the summer he takes his grandson sailing with him or his girlfriend of the same age. Conversely, today you can buy 30 (and up) foot sloop sailboat with walk though transom, furling for the main and jib. Any suggestions? I think this is the size boat and solutions they would want to consider. How reliable has mainsail furling become? Do some boats offer more mechanical advantage on the winches than others (or electric assist). TIA, harlan If a couple has been physically active and know what they are doing on the water age is not a problem. "DSK" wrote in message ... Harlan Lachman wrote: Does anyone have sail boat recommendations for a couple in their 80s? snip Lew Hodgett wrote: SFWIW, I'm on another list with a guy in Rhode Island that has sailed a Marshal cat boat for years. He loves it and while not 80, is no spring chicken either. If you want something smaller, how about a 9 ft Fatty Knees, a dinghy designed by Lyle Hess and now being built by Eddy & Duff. If you want to go with something small, why not a Tech dinghy? Jeff wrote: I certainly wouldn't recommend a Fatty Knees to anyone with mobility problems. It would be a death trap - they wouldn't last one tack! I have one - I only capsized once, but that was stepping into it from my boat. And they're not as tippy as some other hard dinks. A Tech or one of the other frostbiting classes might be a good mix of stability & performance. A Marshall 15 might be better, but the larger ones have a lot of sail to handle. A Beetle Cat! .... I was thinking of a Rhodes 19, or the Mariner (same hull, with a cuddy). With a keel its going to be stable, nothing happens too quickly, and the sails aren't to large to handle. Its even reasonably functional under main alone. Good idea. Of course, a lot depends on where they are and what type of sailing they want to do. A boat with a cuddy cabin need not make it too large or heavy or expensive, and can add functionality. DSK -- To respond, obviously drop the "nospan"? |
Sailing for the aged
In article ,
DSK wrote: Harlan Lachman wrote: Does anyone have sail boat recommendations for a couple in their 80s? Frankly, my dad has a lot of trouble moving quickly and so much less strength that he makes me appear to be Atlas. He has tried powerboats twice but frankly he loves to go out and sail on Long Island Sound. I am interested in sail boats with equipment or specifically earmarked for the older sailor which are designed to allow those with less strength to succeed. He could keep it at a dock to charge up electrical stuff... http://www.santanasailboats.com/boat...0/harbor20.htm Have not sailed one of these myself, but there are a few around and they look like fun... easy to handle from what I've seen. Fresh Breezes- Doug King I owned a Harbor 20. My folks owned the Alerion 28. I got a letter from the factory re the H 20 warning me that one of their boats sunk, killing its skipper. I had had floation added to my boat. They would not guarantee me the boat would not sink if taking in water so I sold it. Also, as per responses to other posts, I think they would prefer to be in a larger, more comfortable boat. Harlan -- To respond, obviously drop the "nospan"? |
Sailing for the aged
In article ,
Don White wrote: Harlan Lachman wrote: Does anyone have sail boat recommendations for a couple in their 80s? Frankly, my dad has a lot of trouble moving quickly and so much less strength that he makes me appear to be Atlas. He has tried powerboats twice but frankly he loves to go out and sail on Long Island Sound. I am interested in sail boats with equipment or specifically earmarked for the older sailor which are designed to allow those with less strength to succeed. He could keep it at a dock to charge up electrical stuff... TIA, harlan I wonder if a modified version of the 'Sail Able' boats used by handicapped people would help? http://www.pspmembers.com/syclub/sailableNS.htm Don, very cool sailboat. They are not wheel chair restricted or even close. But I like some of the design features. I will share the boat with them but think they will think it too small and designed for folks with different issues. harlan -- To respond, obviously drop the "nospan"? |
Sailing for the aged
In article ,
Jere Lull wrote: In article , Harlan Lachman wrote: Does anyone have sail boat recommendations for a couple in their 80s? Frankly, my dad has a lot of trouble moving quickly and so much less strength that he makes me appear to be Atlas. He has tried powerboats twice but frankly he loves to go out and sail on Long Island Sound. I am interested in sail boats with equipment or specifically earmarked for the older sailor which are designed to allow those with less strength to succeed. He could keep it at a dock to charge up electrical stuff... My first thought is cat-boat: A single sail, stable and the newer designs are pretty good sailing vessels. Jere, any made with a highly reliable furling sail with either a electric assist or great mechanical advantage. I think they would like something of this ilk if it was large enough? Any specific recommendation? harlan -- To respond, obviously drop the "nospan"? |
Sailing for the aged
On Fri, 27 Oct 2006 09:38:30 -0400, Harlan Lachman
wrote: In article , Jeff wrote: Lew Hodgett wrote: Harlan Lachman wrote: Does anyone have sail boat recommendations for a couple in their 80s? snip SFWIW, I'm on another list with a guy in Rhode Island that has sailed a Marshal cat boat for years. He loves it and while not 80, is no spring chicken either. If you want something smaller, how about a 9 ft Fatty Knees, a dinghy designed by Lyle Hess and now being built by Eddy & Duff. Lew I certainly wouldn't recommend a Fatty Knees to anyone with mobility problems. It would be a death trap - they wouldn't last one tack! I have one - I only capsized once, but that was stepping into it from my boat. A Marshall 15 might be better, but the larger ones have a lot of sail to handle. I was thinking of a Rhodes 19, or the Mariner (same hull, with a cuddy). With a keel its going to be stable, nothing happens too quickly, and the sails aren't to large to handle. Its even reasonably functional under main alone. Of course, a lot depends on where they are and what type of sailing they want to do. Thanks guys. But I am pretty sure with his experience and money (not to mention bladder), he would want a bigger boat. I am just not sure anyone makes anything to compensate for someone unable to reliably hoist and lower sails manually. harlan I wouldn't look for an off-the-shelf boat. It will almost certainly need electric winches and windlass, and those are add-on accessories. Implied in this is significant battery power and hence a reasonably large boat. To answer an earlier question, boom furling mains are reliable. I did encounter a few "learning curve" issues with mine but it failed in a forgiving manner unlike in-mast furlers that fail with an unreducible sail. |
Sailing for the aged
On Thu, 26 Oct 2006 17:50:32 -0400, Harlan Lachman
wrote: Does anyone have sail boat recommendations for a couple in their 80s? Frankly, my dad has a lot of trouble moving quickly and so much less strength that he makes me appear to be Atlas. He has tried powerboats twice but frankly he loves to go out and sail on Long Island Sound. A small keel boat like a Rhodes 19 or a Pearson Ensign might be just the ticket. Rigged with a roller furling jib, and lazy jacks on the main, it would be stable and very easy to handle. For a cabin boat, something like a Nonsuch 22 or 26 might make a good choice. |
Sailing for the aged
On Thu, 26 Oct 2006 17:50:32 -0400, Harlan Lachman wrote:
Does anyone have sail boat recommendations for a couple in their 80s? Frankly, my dad has a lot of trouble moving quickly and so much less strength that he makes me appear to be Atlas. He has tried powerboats twice but frankly he loves to go out and sail on Long Island Sound. I am interested in sail boats with equipment or specifically earmarked for the older sailor which are designed to allow those with less strength to succeed. He could keep it at a dock to charge up electrical stuff... Harbor 20! If there's power at the dock, the electric auxiliary is perfect. Matt O. |
Sailing for the aged
On Fri, 27 Oct 2006 09:51:49 -0400, Harlan Lachman wrote:
In article , Jere Lull wrote: In article , Harlan Lachman wrote: Does anyone have sail boat recommendations for a couple in their 80s? Frankly, my dad has a lot of trouble moving quickly and so much less strength that he makes me appear to be Atlas. He has tried powerboats twice but frankly he loves to go out and sail on Long Island Sound. I am interested in sail boats with equipment or specifically earmarked for the older sailor which are designed to allow those with less strength to succeed. He could keep it at a dock to charge up electrical stuff... My first thought is cat-boat: A single sail, stable and the newer designs are pretty good sailing vessels. Jere, any made with a highly reliable furling sail with either a electric assist or great mechanical advantage. I think they would like something of this ilk if it was large enough? Any specific recommendation? If you want a slightly bigger boat with a cabin and a head compartment, look at a Nonsuch 26 or 30. These are very simply rigged, with a wishbone boom and few strings to pull. I've seen a few of the 30s with electric winches. I think it was a standard factory option. I don't know about electric winches on the 26 but I'm sure it's doable. Both these boats are exceptionally roomy for their size. Even the 26 has standing headroom and a decent head compartment, as well as 4 berths. They're very well made too, some of the nicest yachts around. Otherwise, be careful with cat boats because that single sail is a large one. Matt O. |
Sailing for the aged
Harlan Lachman wrote:
Thanks guys. But I am pretty sure with his experience and money (not to mention bladder), he would want a bigger boat. I am just not sure anyone makes anything to compensate for someone unable to reliably hoist and lower sails manually. If he gets a sloop, dropping the main is probably the biggest challenge. You can drop the jib without leaving the cockpit if the halyards are brought aft. Get a Milwaukee, right angle, 24 VDC cordless drill fitted with a square shank adapter to fit the manual winch which will provide power assist to raise the sails. They come with a spare battery that can be kept charged. Lew |
Sailing for the aged
Wayne.B wrote:
On Thu, 26 Oct 2006 17:50:32 -0400, Harlan Lachman wrote: Does anyone have sail boat recommendations for a couple in their 80s? Frankly, my dad has a lot of trouble moving quickly and so much less strength that he makes me appear to be Atlas. He has tried powerboats twice but frankly he loves to go out and sail on Long Island Sound. A small keel boat like a Rhodes 19 or a Pearson Ensign might be just the ticket. Rigged with a roller furling jib, and lazy jacks on the main, it would be stable and very easy to handle. For a cabin boat, something like a Nonsuch 22 or 26 might make a good choice. I was just going to say a smaller Nonsuch. You can add a single large winch to handle both the halyard and mainsheet, and once rigged up, you can sail it all day with "fingertip control." The main comes down into lazyjacks, the only problem being gathering up all the sail. However, if that's an issuer, there might be a way to add a Dutchman system. I lived with a Nonsuch 30 for 8 years, and when the time comes to downsize, a 22 or 26 will be on my short list. |
Sailing for the aged
|
Sailing for the aged
Nobody's mentioned multihulls. Most octogenarians won't feel comfortable on
a boat which is likely to heel at least 20 degrees in any middling wind. Multihulls are likely to be a lot flatter. Some trimarans have decent cockpits. The other problem which has been noted is sail handling and, between the Nonsuch wishbone catboats and the Hoyt boats (Alerion xx) with self-tending jibs, that's a help. I'm building a 28' daysailing tri, Dick Newick's 'Spark', which has a Ljungstrom cat-yawl rig. There's a lot that's experimental in the rig, but it's hoped that it'll be easy for an old fart to operate. Ask me in a year. |
Sailing for the aged
In article ,
Harlan Lachman wrote: My first thought is cat-boat: A single sail, stable and the newer designs are pretty good sailing vessels. Jere, any made with a highly reliable furling sail with either a electric assist or great mechanical advantage. I think they would like something of this ilk if it was large enough? Any specific recommendation? You've gotten the major makers from people that have used them. There's also the AC cat (I believe Atlantic City) that I've seen around. Foot for foot, catboats have enormous accommodations and they're designed for easy use. Taking the conversation in a different direction: How about a small catamaran? Wouldn't take much to give power-assist and they're pretty comfortable. Drawback might be the up-and-down to the various levels that the catboats don't have, and they're more complex, more things to fiddle with and keep track of. -- Jere Lull Xan-a-Deux ('73 Tanzer 28 #4 out of Tolchester, MD) Xan's Pages: http://members.dca.net/jerelull/X-Main.html Our BVI FAQs (290+ pics) http://homepage.mac.com/jerelull/BVI/ |
Sailing for the aged
There are certainly advantages to multihulls for older folk: a stable
platform, more room to get around, much easier to work at the bow, greatly reduced sail area for the size. However, there are downsides: the cruising cat design does not scale down very well - there are very few modern designs under 32 feet. Since that's the equivalent of a 40 foot monohull, the price will be fairly high - $80K or more. Various maintenance issue are multiplied - I have 144 feet of waterline to tape when I paint, double the oil changes, etc. If you have twin engines you gain a lot of maneuverability, but still it can be difficult to dock singlehanded. And its very hard to find slips in many areas, you end up on face docks which give less protection, and while easier to get out, can be hard to land at with an offshore breeze. But the biggest issue for the OP is that I presume they are interested in shorter daysails rather than longer distance cruising. Cats can be very tedious to sail in constrained waters. On my Nonsuch I almost always raised sail within 100 yards of the slip, even if it meant a beat out of the inner harbor. We did numerous short sails, sometimes just tacking around the inner harbor. With the cat, we're far more likely to power until we clear the middle harbor and start heading for distant vacations. I did know of one Gemini that was setup for someone in a wheelchair, and a PDQ 32 for someone in crutches, in both case they were strong active men, who felt it was easier to get around the cat. I also knew of a Nonsuch 36 that was cruised by wheelchair bound man - he had a special StackPak designed that could be operated entirely from the cockpit. One more thing - as it turned out, for the first year we had our cat, every overnight guest was 78 years old. My FiL crewed for half the delivery, and my parents joined us for 5 days on the Vineyard. All enjoyed the boat a lot, of course. Jim Conlin wrote: Nobody's mentioned multihulls. Most octogenarians won't feel comfortable on a boat which is likely to heel at least 20 degrees in any middling wind. Multihulls are likely to be a lot flatter. Some trimarans have decent cockpits. The other problem which has been noted is sail handling and, between the Nonsuch wishbone catboats and the Hoyt boats (Alerion xx) with self-tending jibs, that's a help. I'm building a 28' daysailing tri, Dick Newick's 'Spark', which has a Ljungstrom cat-yawl rig. There's a lot that's experimental in the rig, but it's hoped that it'll be easy for an old fart to operate. Ask me in a year. |
All times are GMT +1. The time now is 06:53 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com