BoatBanter.com

BoatBanter.com (https://www.boatbanter.com/)
-   Cruising (https://www.boatbanter.com/cruising/)
-   -   internet on board (https://www.boatbanter.com/cruising/71414-internet-board.html)

Edoardo July 6th 06 09:56 AM

internet on board
 
Hi,

I am searching for some good source of information about installing a
satellite internet connection on sailing boats.
What's the best solution?
Is there a website/forum/group that is specifically talking about this?

Thanks a lot for your help
Eddy


You July 6th 06 08:20 PM

internet on board
 
In article . com,
"Edoardo" wrote:

Hi,

I am searching for some good source of information about installing a
satellite internet connection on sailing boats.
What's the best solution?
Is there a website/forum/group that is specifically talking about this?

Thanks a lot for your help
Eddy


All it takes is MONEY, and lots of it, for either expensive hardware, or
expensive SAT Time, or BOTH......

Edoardo July 6th 06 10:41 PM

internet on board
 
You wrote:
In article . com,
"Edoardo" wrote:

Hi,

I am searching for some good source of information about installing a
satellite internet connection on sailing boats.
What's the best solution?
Is there a website/forum/group that is specifically talking about this?

Thanks a lot for your help
Eddy


All it takes is MONEY, and lots of it, for either expensive hardware, or
expensive SAT Time, or BOTH......


This was the same kind of answer one would get 10 years ago asking for
a flat panel 19" display or for a car navigation system.
things that you can buy now for less than 500euro (maybe because
somebody started talking about?)
I am sorry for being polemic but I can't get an answer other than the
"wow, what you want to do it's really expensive!" one.
The reason I am asking this is because I really like sailing and at the
same time I would like to help a friend of mine that asked this - maybe
just as curiosity - or maybe just to know how it works.
Internet satellite systems are getting widely used for cars, caravans
and TV vans for example; I guess the most complicated thing to make
them work on a boat would be for the boat movements (tilting, etc) but
I can't find any good source of information about.
thanks anyway..


Skip Gundlach July 6th 06 11:48 PM

internet on board
 
Hi, Eduardo,

Edoardo wrote:
Hi,

I am searching for some good source of information about installing a
satellite internet connection on sailing boats.
What's the best solution?
Is there a website/forum/group that is specifically talking about this?

Thanks a lot for your help
Eddy


I don't want to rain on your parade. However, you asked about
satellite, as compared to other means of internet.

If you want full browsing and other like-at-home capabiliities, it's
certainly within the range of today's technology. Just ask the major
merchant marine folks, who have that aboard.

But it comes at a cost. *Lots* of whatever coinage you choose will
accomplish the job.

Just like the (American - don't know where you are) saying: Fast,
Cheap, Good. Choose two. In the case of marine internet, it's pretty
much the same. Want it good, and fast (not the equivalent of 20 years
ago's dial-up), it's not cheap. Want it fast and cheap? Go ashore to
internet cafés (no hardware investment). Good and cheap? Still
working on it, but in relative terms, SSB "modems" can get you email
and if you're a Ham, somewhat larger files, but still not browsing.

I'm currently working on, and am whittling away at problems
encountered, being able to access wifi from out in the harbor, without
having to be tied to an antenna - but there will still have to be some
gear up the mast, if I'm successful. However, that's only going to
work in range of some AP, most likely some household with an open
router, or a commercial pay site.

And then there's the satellite phones connected like a modem/dialer.
Now you're up to perhaps 15 years ago's speeds, but you can do whatever
you want with your minutes, and endure the time it takes to load a
page.

About a grand to get in for the SSB/Ham, minimum, plus the radio (many
flavors and costs) but minimal costs (free HAM and 250/year SSB), and
about the same for the satphone (but with minute costs plus whatever
plan you're on - and flaky coverage depending on where you are an whose
service/phone you have).

So, the other responses aren't being flip. If you want good solid
satellite internet coverage, it's major dinero, euro, bux, or your
favorite. The others are less costly and less effective.

L8R

Skip, working on the boat, one of which projects includes harborage and
anchorage wifi


Capt.Mooron July 7th 06 12:19 AM

internet on board
 
Don't listen to the ignorance and nay saying regarding internet service
while at sea. Several providers have sail mail. Many marinas offer high
speed internet on a global basis.
Research what you need. Keep in mind the baud rate drop is substantial when
at sea. VHF sail mail will keep you in touch with a laptop. stick to text
messages and it will allow downloads of weather data.

CM

I don't usually condone x-posting... but this is a sailing related thread
"Edoardo" wrote in message
oups.com...
You wrote:
In article . com,
"Edoardo" wrote:

Hi,

I am searching for some good source of information about installing a
satellite internet connection on sailing boats.
What's the best solution?
Is there a website/forum/group that is specifically talking about this?

Thanks a lot for your help
Eddy


All it takes is MONEY, and lots of it, for either expensive hardware, or
expensive SAT Time, or BOTH......


This was the same kind of answer one would get 10 years ago asking for
a flat panel 19" display or for a car navigation system.
things that you can buy now for less than 500euro (maybe because
somebody started talking about?)
I am sorry for being polemic but I can't get an answer other than the
"wow, what you want to do it's really expensive!" one.
The reason I am asking this is because I really like sailing and at the
same time I would like to help a friend of mine that asked this - maybe
just as curiosity - or maybe just to know how it works.
Internet satellite systems are getting widely used for cars, caravans
and TV vans for example; I guess the most complicated thing to make
them work on a boat would be for the boat movements (tilting, etc) but
I can't find any good source of information about.
thanks anyway..




Goofball_star_dot_etal July 7th 06 12:26 AM

internet on board
 

I'm currently working on, and am whittling away at problems
encountered, being able to access wifi from out in the harbor, without
having to be tied to an antenna - but there will still have to be some
gear up the mast, if I'm successful. However, that's only going to
work in range of some AP, most likely some household with an open
router, or a commercial pay site.


I have had success with a wl-330 as a repeater
http://uk.asus.com/products2.aspx?l1=12&l2=41
The wl-330 does not seem to be available here now in the UK ( I think
I had the last three!) The wl-330g is availble but it is not clear to
me that this model does wds. You probably need to use the ethernet
cable anyhow, if you are not repeating (wds) from an Asus device.

Bob Crantz July 7th 06 01:06 AM

internet on board
 
Get an amateur radio license. Satellite service is free. Equipment is
inexpensive.

Glory!

"Capt.Mooron" wrote in message
news:iUgrg.99342$I61.73210@clgrps13...
Don't listen to the ignorance and nay saying regarding internet service
while at sea. Several providers have sail mail. Many marinas offer high
speed internet on a global basis.
Research what you need. Keep in mind the baud rate drop is substantial
when at sea. VHF sail mail will keep you in touch with a laptop. stick to
text messages and it will allow downloads of weather data.

CM

I don't usually condone x-posting... but this is a sailing related thread
"Edoardo" wrote in message
oups.com...
You wrote:
In article . com,
"Edoardo" wrote:

Hi,

I am searching for some good source of information about installing a
satellite internet connection on sailing boats.
What's the best solution?
Is there a website/forum/group that is specifically talking about
this?

Thanks a lot for your help
Eddy


All it takes is MONEY, and lots of it, for either expensive hardware, or
expensive SAT Time, or BOTH......


This was the same kind of answer one would get 10 years ago asking for
a flat panel 19" display or for a car navigation system.
things that you can buy now for less than 500euro (maybe because
somebody started talking about?)
I am sorry for being polemic but I can't get an answer other than the
"wow, what you want to do it's really expensive!" one.
The reason I am asking this is because I really like sailing and at the
same time I would like to help a friend of mine that asked this - maybe
just as curiosity - or maybe just to know how it works.
Internet satellite systems are getting widely used for cars, caravans
and TV vans for example; I guess the most complicated thing to make
them work on a boat would be for the boat movements (tilting, etc) but
I can't find any good source of information about.
thanks anyway..






dog July 7th 06 05:12 AM

internet on board
 
Unfortunately you tend to get a lot of Morons who can't spell.
Sailmail is via SSB not VHF. VHF doesn't have any appreciable range,
once you're at sea.

You can get full Internet access via a satellite phone system, but if
you're on a small sailboat, you will be using an awful lot of power to
get it. Full internet access at sea requires you to use a stabilized
satellite antenna. Not only is the equipment power hungry, but it is
also quite expensive, as is the air time. Unlike a terrrestrial
broadband connection, most of the satellite-based ones charge by the
bandwidth used, not a flat monthly fee.

If all you need is decent access when near shore, then it might be
worth looking into an EDGE or GSM-based solution. While not as fast as
satellite, it is considerably cheaper. However, you would probably have
to get a new sim card and account for each country you use it in. Some
countries have a flat-rate plan, some do not. Really it depends on the
particular country and what providers are there.

On 2006-07-06 19:19:42 -0400, "Capt.Mooron" said:

Don't listen to the ignorance and nay saying regarding internet
service while at sea. Several providers have sail mail. Many marinas
offer high speed internet on a global basis.
Research what you need. Keep in mind the baud rate drop is substantial
when at sea. VHF sail mail will keep you in touch with a laptop. stick
to text messages and it will allow downloads of weather data.

CM



Dave Doe July 7th 06 10:11 AM

internet on board
 
In article 2006070700125616807-dog@nomailcom, says...
Unfortunately you tend to get a lot of Morons who can't spell.
Sailmail is via SSB not VHF. VHF doesn't have any appreciable range,
once you're at sea.

You can get full Internet access via a satellite phone system, but if
you're on a small sailboat, you will be using an awful lot of power to
get it. Full internet access at sea requires you to use a stabilized
satellite antenna. Not only is the equipment power hungry, but it is
also quite expensive, as is the air time. Unlike a terrrestrial
broadband connection, most of the satellite-based ones charge by the
bandwidth used, not a flat monthly fee.


What sorta of speed is available?

--
Duncan

Wayne.B July 7th 06 11:48 AM

internet on board
 
On Fri, 7 Jul 2006 21:11:41 +1200, Dave Doe wrote:

What sorta of speed is available?


=========

http://www.kvh.com/KVHSatCom/


Edoardo July 7th 06 12:31 PM

internet on board
 
Anonyma wrote:
If you want to know how much it will cost you as a consumer, start as
cheap as you can and go price data capable Satellite phones. They start
at about $600 US and go up from there. Satellite service is about $.14 a
minute. On top of that your actual bandwidth will be sold to you in
upload/download packages ranging from around $60/Month for 250MEG up
and 1GIG down (total bytes, not per second), to around 5GIG/7GIG for
$1100 a month.

Dedicated "dialup speed" 32K/sec both ways will run you somewhere around
$400 a month, and dedicated satellite "broadband" around a 1M/sec can
be upwards of $11,000 a month.

And don't forget that every minute of fraction thereof you're connected
it costs you another $.14 or so on top of that. :(


ok, it is expensive :)

and TV vans for example; I guess the most complicated thing to make


TV is one-way. The signal is spewed everywhere and those who want
it, receive it. There's absolutely no need to send the TV station any
information at all. All you need is the receiver, not the transmitter.
You could do this on a boat also, if the Internet weren't by design a
system where information is sent to a specific destination, and then
confirmed packet by packet. ;)


I wasn't thinking about tv, sometime you can find in big cities those
tv vans with terrestrial satellite antennas (that don't need to be
stabilized), they have a receiver and a transmitter and they put you
online.
Of course with cnn budgets you can do everything but the point here is
that terrestrial systems like this are being sold around 250euro /month
flat fee with connections 256Kbit/512Kbit upstream/downstream


There is another option though, and it's something that's been around
forever. Packet switching via amateur radio bandwidth. There's
literally thousands of amateur repeaters along the US coastline alone
that will allow you to grab essentially free Internet as long as you
have an account somewhere to get your email and stuff. Of course this
takes an even larger initial cash outlay, and a considerable amount of
study and expertise.


nothing you can use in open sea though... and speed is low, very very
low


Bruce in Alaska July 7th 06 07:44 PM

internet on board
 
In article .com,
"Edoardo" wrote:

You wrote:
In article . com,
"Edoardo" wrote:

Hi,

I am searching for some good source of information about installing a
satellite internet connection on sailing boats.
What's the best solution?
Is there a website/forum/group that is specifically talking about this?

Thanks a lot for your help
Eddy


All it takes is MONEY, and lots of it, for either expensive hardware, or
expensive SAT Time, or BOTH......


This was the same kind of answer one would get 10 years ago asking for
a flat panel 19" display or for a car navigation system.
things that you can buy now for less than 500euro (maybe because
somebody started talking about?)
I am sorry for being polemic but I can't get an answer other than the
"wow, what you want to do it's really expensive!" one.
The reason I am asking this is because I really like sailing and at the
same time I would like to help a friend of mine that asked this - maybe
just as curiosity - or maybe just to know how it works.
Internet satellite systems are getting widely used for cars, caravans
and TV vans for example; I guess the most complicated thing to make
them work on a boat would be for the boat movements (tilting, etc) but
I can't find any good source of information about.
thanks anyway..


There are piles of SAT systems for cars, caravans, and TV Vans, but the
first two are not passing IP Traffic in the bidirectional mode at any
speed of consequence. SAT Tv Vans have all the hardware to pass just
about any type of traffic, BUT they don't do it while moving, only at
fixed locations, and all that gear is expensive, HEAVY, and Power-hungry.
You can't find the information you require, because you are looking at
trying to do it on the cheap, and Gyro-Stabilized Ka or Ku Band Antennas
are anything but cheap. They also require Directional Heading Inputs
from an external Gyro System, or Enertial Nav system, which is another
expense, which is why these are usually only fitted on Military, or
Large Ships that already have a platform, and required auxillary Input
Systems, fitted.
DBS TvSAT Receive/Only Systems are in the 3-5Kbuck range when fitted with
Gyro-Stabilized Antennas, and getting an Uplink going means that your
antenna tracking accuracy has to be increased by at least an order of
magnitude. Otherwise you would be interfering with numerous other users,
on multiple SAT's because your antenna can't track a point in the sky
at less than 300 ArcSeconds.

Bruce in alaska an old SAT/Comm's guy from way back......
--
add a 2 before @

[email protected] July 7th 06 09:10 PM

internet on board
 
http://www.kvh.com/kvhsatcom/


Edoardo wrote:
Hi,

I am searching for some good source of information about installing a
satellite internet connection on sailing boats.
What's the best solution?
Is there a website/forum/group that is specifically talking about this?

Thanks a lot for your help
Eddy



dog July 10th 06 12:30 PM

internet on board
 
On 2006-07-07 16:10:22 -0400, said:

http://www.kvh.com/kvhsatcom/


Edoardo wrote:
Hi,

I am searching for some good source of information about installing a
satellite internet connection on sailing boats.
What's the best solution?
Is there a website/forum/group that is specifically talking about this?

Thanks a lot for your help
Eddy


Now, there is also a vast difference between getting high-speed
internet access at a marina or near shore via cell or wifi and getting
semi-high speed internet access from the open seas. Most of the work
I've done with satellite systems has been media related, from the
reporting side, and the newer systems can give you about 128k full
duplex, but are designed to be on a fixed ground location. To do this
from a small sailboat in the open ocean requires gyro-stabilized
antenna as noted by others. This type of equipment is not only
expensive, but ungodly power-hungry.

This isn't to say it isn't possible to do from a sailboat at sea...but
it is very, very expensive to do so. The boat would have to be
capable of generating enough power to keep the equipment powered up for
however long you want to use it. The equipment ain't cheap. The cost
of service is not cheap either, generally being billed on a time or
data rate basis. None of the purely internationally available
satellite providers that I know of give a flat-rate fee. There is no
incentive for them to do so. DirectPC does, but they're only available
in the United States for the most part and their uplink speed is
generally below 30kbps.


glenn P July 13th 06 02:53 AM

internet on board
 
Not enough information. If you expect people to spend time helping you, it's
worthwhile explaining exactly what you want, and what for.

"Edoardo" wrote in message
ups.com...
Hi,

I am searching for some good source of information about installing a
satellite internet connection on sailing boats.
What's the best solution?
Is there a website/forum/group that is specifically talking about this?

Thanks a lot for your help
Eddy




[email protected] July 31st 06 11:41 AM

internet on board
 

Edoardo wrote:
Hi,

I am searching for some good source of information about installing a
satellite internet connection on sailing boats.
What's the best solution?
Is there a website/forum/group that is specifically talking about this?

Thanks a lot for your help
Eddy


Eddy...
You may find the Podcast at the following link helpful:
http://www.distantshores.ca/pb/wp_9d..._9d5ec457.html

Download Podcast #3 - March 30, 2006 - "Communications and email
aboard. Interview with David Anderson of Stand Sure Marine about using
an HF marine or HAM radio to connect to the Internet at sea."

It is 38 min long and is an interview conducted by Paul and Sheryl
Shard discussing everything from e-mail to Internet at sea with an
expert. Most of the figures they use are in Canadian Dollars...

Hope this gets you started...


jim.isbell August 1st 06 05:00 PM

internet on board
 
If you want it at sea, I cant help but if you want it near shore I can.

I just completed a 1400 mile trip from Tampa Florida to Corpus Christi
Texas in my Gulfstar 36. I had internet connection for the whole thrip
except for about 120 miles along the "Big Bend" of Florida. I had fast
connections so that I was able to download charts from the internet
every evening (about 5 minutes per chart). And the cost was $10 a
month and no cell minutes used.

The service is called PCS Vision and its with Sprint. You have to have
a regular Cell Phone account with Sprint, a PCS Vision enabled cell
phone, and a cable from a third party vendor (you can find them on the
internet, and NO they are NOT illegal) Sprint used to sell the cables
but got out of the bussiness......maybe to discourage use of the
system.

The speed is about 56 K Baud....depending on the tower you get....you
must have a digital tower, wont work on an analog tower....and you need
a laptop to connect the cable from the cell phone to. The software is
free, download from the Sprint website.

I can only talk about the Sanyo SCP 4900 cell phone as that is the one
I have (two years old) . It works great, but it is an oldie and they
may not be available anymore. The current phones may work even better
but I cannot attest to that.

You have to be careful in selecting your plan as there are several and
two of them will eat you alive on minutes charges. The cheap one at $5
a month charges for minutes. The next step is $10 a month and does NOT
charge for minutes. Technically you could stay on 24/7 at no extra
cost. The third one is for commercial users and will cost you more
than you have to spend.

During our trip I used a Sony Vaio laptop to which I connected my $99
Delorme GPS, a 1gig ram stick ($49 at Wall Mart), and the telephone
(free at the time for promotional purposes). I could download the
charts in the evening for the next day and then using (also free
software) SeaClear software I could watch my progress on the charts
using the GPS connection. Its a great system and the monthly cost was
only $10


wrote:
Edoardo wrote:
Hi,

I am searching for some good source of information about installing a
satellite internet connection on sailing boats.
What's the best solution?
Is there a website/forum/group that is specifically talking about this?

Thanks a lot for your help
Eddy


Eddy...
You may find the Podcast at the following link helpful:
http://www.distantshores.ca/pb/wp_9d..._9d5ec457.html

Download Podcast #3 - March 30, 2006 - "Communications and email
aboard. Interview with David Anderson of Stand Sure Marine about using
an HF marine or HAM radio to connect to the Internet at sea."

It is 38 min long and is an interview conducted by Paul and Sheryl
Shard discussing everything from e-mail to Internet at sea with an
expert. Most of the figures they use are in Canadian Dollars...

Hope this gets you started...



Dick Locke August 1st 06 07:00 PM

internet on board
 
On 31 Jul 2006 03:41:17 -0700, wrote:


Edoardo wrote:
Hi,

I am searching for some good source of information about installing a
satellite internet connection on sailing boats.
What's the best solution?
Is there a website/forum/group that is specifically talking about this?

Thanks a lot for your help
Eddy


THe original post has dropped off my computer, so I'm not sure if the
question was originally aimed at US coastal cruisiers or global
cruisers. For global cruisers who want something closer to "always on"
than SSB/Pactor rigs...

Has anyone looked into R-BGAN or BGAN from Inmarsat? . I've seen
R-BGAN prices around $500 for the antenna/terminal and $12 per
megabyte for satellite usage. Speed is "up to" 144K BITS per second,
but there is some new acceleration software. Looks adequate for email
but not much good for graphic downloading. It could give Skymate a
run for its money.

http://broadband.inmarsat.com/about/...extonly=False#

My main concern is directional sensitivity of the flat antenna and
whether it would work under way in a sailboat....or even in a
relatively calm anchorage.



Glenn Ashmore August 2nd 06 12:05 AM

internet on board
 
Looks like it goes to a geosynchronus satellite. Use d a satphone for
several years over a geosync. Very picky. Useless on a boat. Had to sit
on the dock and let the people walking by be bewildered by the nut case
sitting on the dock talking on the phone.

--
Glenn Ashmore

I'm building a 45' cutter in strip/composite. Watch my progress (or lack
there of) at: http://www.rutuonline.com
Shameless Commercial Division: http://www.spade-anchor-us.com

"Dick Locke" wrote in message
...
On 31 Jul 2006 03:41:17 -0700, wrote:


Edoardo wrote:
Hi,

I am searching for some good source of information about installing a
satellite internet connection on sailing boats.
What's the best solution?
Is there a website/forum/group that is specifically talking about this?

Thanks a lot for your help
Eddy


THe original post has dropped off my computer, so I'm not sure if the
question was originally aimed at US coastal cruisiers or global
cruisers. For global cruisers who want something closer to "always on"
than SSB/Pactor rigs...

Has anyone looked into R-BGAN or BGAN from Inmarsat? . I've seen
R-BGAN prices around $500 for the antenna/terminal and $12 per
megabyte for satellite usage. Speed is "up to" 144K BITS per second,
but there is some new acceleration software. Looks adequate for email
but not much good for graphic downloading. It could give Skymate a
run for its money.

http://broadband.inmarsat.com/about/...extonly=False#

My main concern is directional sensitivity of the flat antenna and
whether it would work under way in a sailboat....or even in a
relatively calm anchorage.





krj August 2nd 06 12:21 AM

internet on board
 
Glenn Ashmore wrote:
Looks like it goes to a geosynchronus satellite. Use d a satphone for
several years over a geosync. Very picky. Useless on a boat. Had to sit
on the dock and let the people walking by be bewildered by the nut case
sitting on the dock talking on the phone.

What satphone system uses geosync satellites? Both Iridium and
Globalstar use LEO satellites.
krj

Glenn Ashmore August 2nd 06 01:51 AM

internet on board
 
This was long ago in ancient times. Like almost 7 or 8 years. :-) Before
Iridium and Globestar everything was geosync. Inmarsat (B, M and Mini-M)
were all there was. The unit was about the size of a lap top with a
telephone hand set attached. You aim the lid at the satellite. Had a
9600bps dataport too. This device looks like a stylized version of those
old sat phones but with ADSL. .

--
Glenn Ashmore

I'm building a 45' cutter in strip/composite. Watch my progress (or lack
there of) at: http://www.rutuonline.com
Shameless Commercial Division: http://www.spade-anchor-us.com

"krj" wrote in message
. ..
Glenn Ashmore wrote:
Looks like it goes to a geosynchronus satellite. Use d a satphone for
several years over a geosync. Very picky. Useless on a boat. Had to
sit on the dock and let the people walking by be bewildered by the nut
case sitting on the dock talking on the phone.

What satphone system uses geosync satellites? Both Iridium and Globalstar
use LEO satellites.
krj





All times are GMT +1. The time now is 03:05 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com