BoatBanter.com

BoatBanter.com (https://www.boatbanter.com/)
-   Cruising (https://www.boatbanter.com/cruising/)
-   -   Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow (https://www.boatbanter.com/cruising/66100-ocean-kayak-27footer-store-tow.html)

[email protected] February 3rd 06 10:02 PM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 

Does anyone have experience either storing an
ocean kayak (closed, sit on top variety) on a 27
foot sailboat, or towing it behind?

What are your experiences? Doable? Horrible?
Good idea?

Thanks!


Capt. JG February 3rd 06 10:34 PM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
wrote in message
oups.com...

Does anyone have experience either storing an
ocean kayak (closed, sit on top variety) on a 27
foot sailboat, or towing it behind?

What are your experiences? Doable? Horrible?
Good idea?

Thanks!


I believe there's another thread about towing... you should probably avoid
this except for short distances in protected waters.

--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com




[email protected] February 3rd 06 11:30 PM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
Thanks, but I was asking for EXPERIENCES.

There are plenty of threads about towing, the
most recent about towing a heavy motorboat.
Not my interest.

Pleeaaaaase, experiences from people who
have done it. I can speculate plenty myself.


[email protected] February 3rd 06 11:52 PM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
On 3 Feb 2006 15:30:43 -0800, "
wrote:

Pleeaaaaase, experiences from people who
have done it. I can speculate plenty myself.


That kind of smart-assed comment is a pretty sure way to cut off
further answers.

I think Jon was suggesting that the issues involved in towing a kayak
are similar to the issues of towing any dinghy. And he helpfully
pointed you toward a disscussion of those issues that included input
from people with experiences.

MMC February 3rd 06 11:53 PM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
I think Garhauer makes racks that mount to stanctions for hanging kayaks
outside the rail.
I agree with the below, heard too many "wasn't there a dinghy back there
when we left?" stories to do that myself.

"Capt. JG" wrote in message
...
wrote in message
oups.com...

Does anyone have experience either storing an
ocean kayak (closed, sit on top variety) on a 27
foot sailboat, or towing it behind?

What are your experiences? Doable? Horrible?
Good idea?

Thanks!


I believe there's another thread about towing... you should probably avoid
this except for short distances in protected waters.

--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com






Capt. JG February 4th 06 12:19 AM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
wrote in message
oups.com...
Thanks, but I was asking for EXPERIENCES.

There are plenty of threads about towing, the
most recent about towing a heavy motorboat.
Not my interest.

Pleeaaaaase, experiences from people who
have done it. I can speculate plenty myself.


I think many of us have towed dinghies for some distances. My *experience*
is that it's not a good idea, except in protected waters for short periods.

--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com




Capt. JG February 4th 06 12:20 AM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
wrote in message
...
On 3 Feb 2006 15:30:43 -0800, "
wrote:

Pleeaaaaase, experiences from people who
have done it. I can speculate plenty myself.


That kind of smart-assed comment is a pretty sure way to cut off
further answers.

I think Jon was suggesting that the issues involved in towing a kayak
are similar to the issues of towing any dinghy. And he helpfully
pointed you toward a disscussion of those issues that included input
from people with experiences.


You were thinking correctly.

--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com




Capt. JG February 4th 06 12:20 AM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
"MMC" wrote in message
.. .
I think Garhauer makes racks that mount to stanctions for hanging kayaks
outside the rail.
I agree with the below, heard too many "wasn't there a dinghy back there
when we left?" stories to do that myself.

"Capt. JG" wrote in message
...
wrote in message
oups.com...

Does anyone have experience either storing an
ocean kayak (closed, sit on top variety) on a 27
foot sailboat, or towing it behind?

What are your experiences? Doable? Horrible?
Good idea?

Thanks!


I believe there's another thread about towing... you should probably
avoid
this except for short distances in protected waters.

--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com


I have that tee shirt.

--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com




Jeff February 4th 06 12:26 AM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
wrote:
Thanks, but I was asking for EXPERIENCES.

There are plenty of threads about towing, the
most recent about towing a heavy motorboat.
Not my interest.

Pleeaaaaase, experiences from people who
have done it. I can speculate plenty myself.

I can't help you either.

However, I do keep a large Ocean Kayak (Malibu II XL) on deck on our
36 foot catamaran. Our shrouds are inboard, and there's enough room
to wedge it between the shrouds and lifelines. At 61 pounds its light
enough for one person to drop it overboard, but its a lot easier to
use the main halyard and winch.

The kayak got a lot of use last summer: daily trips ashore with the
dog; poking around the anchorage. etc. The downside is that you
inevitably get a bit wet, and you have to accept the possibility of
getting a lot wet. So the hard dink is still better for fetching
groceries, etc.

I wouldn't want to tow it any distance. If you tow above its hull
speed it could be stressed; they strongly advise against towing with a
powerboat at speed.


http://www.oceankayak.com/malibutwoxl.html
http://www.sv-loki.com/Molly_Doodle/MollyBanana1.jpg

Gary February 4th 06 12:59 AM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
Capt. JG wrote:
wrote in message
oups.com...

Does anyone have experience either storing an
ocean kayak (closed, sit on top variety) on a 27
foot sailboat, or towing it behind?

What are your experiences? Doable? Horrible?
Good idea?

Thanks!



I believe there's another thread about towing... you should probably avoid
this except for short distances in protected waters.

The question is a little different than towing a dinghy. I too have
wondered about towing a sit-on-top kayak. The difference is they are
self bailing, unsinkable and fairly light. It is more akin to towing a
styrofoam log than a dinghy.

Good question. I am also interested in hearing if anyone has done it.

Gaz

Gary February 4th 06 01:05 AM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
wrote:
On 3 Feb 2006 15:30:43 -0800, "
wrote:


Pleeaaaaase, experiences from people who
have done it. I can speculate plenty myself.



That kind of smart-assed comment is a pretty sure way to cut off
further answers.

I think Jon was suggesting that the issues involved in towing a kayak
are similar to the issues of towing any dinghy. And he helpfully
pointed you toward a disscussion of those issues that included input
from people with experiences.


I think John is wrong. I like the focussing of the question. Does
anyone have any experience towing a sit-on-top kayak?

Gary February 4th 06 01:10 AM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
MMC wrote:
I think Garhauer makes racks that mount to stanctions for hanging kayaks
outside the rail.
I agree with the below, heard too many "wasn't there a dinghy back there
when we left?" stories to do that myself.


I've seen those hangers and it looks like it would rip the stanchions
off in any kind of a seaway. I think that is a very "near shore"
weekender design.

I like the idea of towing the kayak (sit-on-top) better.

Gaz

[email protected] February 4th 06 01:32 AM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
On Fri, 3 Feb 2006 16:20:06 -0800, "Capt. JG"
wrote:

You were thinking correctly.


See Jon, I back you up when you're right. It just happens so seldom
g.

Capt. JG February 4th 06 05:08 AM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
I know. I'm imperfect. Not too humble either.

--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com

wrote in message
...
On Fri, 3 Feb 2006 16:20:06 -0800, "Capt. JG"
wrote:

You were thinking correctly.


See Jon, I back you up when you're right. It just happens so seldom
g.




Capt. JG February 4th 06 05:10 AM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
Well, I've seen it done, and I've seen the result...

--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com

"Gary" wrote in message
news:p%SEf.424192$2k.384298@pd7tw1no...
Capt. JG wrote:
wrote in message
oups.com...

Does anyone have experience either storing an
ocean kayak (closed, sit on top variety) on a 27
foot sailboat, or towing it behind?

What are your experiences? Doable? Horrible?
Good idea?

Thanks!



I believe there's another thread about towing... you should probably
avoid this except for short distances in protected waters.

The question is a little different than towing a dinghy. I too have
wondered about towing a sit-on-top kayak. The difference is they are self
bailing, unsinkable and fairly light. It is more akin to towing a
styrofoam log than a dinghy.

Good question. I am also interested in hearing if anyone has done it.

Gaz




Gary February 4th 06 05:54 AM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
Capt. JG wrote:
Well, I've seen it done, and I've seen the result...

What did you see?
What was the result?

Capt. JG February 4th 06 07:50 AM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
A broken painter.

--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com

"Gary" wrote in message
news:hkXEf.544273$ki.301436@pd7tw2no...
Capt. JG wrote:
Well, I've seen it done, and I've seen the result...

What did you see?
What was the result?




Gary February 4th 06 02:38 PM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
Capt. JG wrote:
A broken painter.

That's it?

MMC February 4th 06 03:31 PM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
Damn expensive experience gathering! A good friend has lost 2 inflatables
while towing! He finally bought davits.....
"Capt. JG" wrote in message
...
"MMC" wrote in message
.. .
I think Garhauer makes racks that mount to stanctions for hanging kayaks
outside the rail.
I agree with the below, heard too many "wasn't there a dinghy back there
when we left?" stories to do that myself.

"Capt. JG" wrote in message
...
wrote in message
oups.com...

Does anyone have experience either storing an
ocean kayak (closed, sit on top variety) on a 27
foot sailboat, or towing it behind?

What are your experiences? Doable? Horrible?
Good idea?

Thanks!

I believe there's another thread about towing... you should probably
avoid
this except for short distances in protected waters.

--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com


I have that tee shirt.

--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com






MMC February 4th 06 03:34 PM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
How about if they rotated, inside for passage making and outside for in
port?
MMC
"Gary" wrote in message
news:Q9TEf.318255$tl.270005@pd7tw3no...
MMC wrote:
I think Garhauer makes racks that mount to stanctions for hanging kayaks
outside the rail.
I agree with the below, heard too many "wasn't there a dinghy back there
when we left?" stories to do that myself.


I've seen those hangers and it looks like it would rip the stanchions
off in any kind of a seaway. I think that is a very "near shore"
weekender design.

I like the idea of towing the kayak (sit-on-top) better.

Gaz




Gary February 4th 06 05:12 PM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
MMC wrote:
Damn expensive experience gathering! A good friend has lost 2 inflatables
while towing! He finally bought davits.....
"Capt. JG" wrote in message
...


The reason I am interested in hearing from someone who has actually
towed a sit on top is because of all the types of towed dinghies, it
seems like it would be the best. It can't fill with water. It won't
suddenly weigh 1000 pounds. It is unsinkable. The only thing that I
can think of that would be of concern is it flipping over in a seaway
and diving. Painter chafe is a solveable problem.

Carrying one onboard is easy and I do that regularily. I don't tie it
to the guardrails/lifelines though. They are not strong enough for that.

Gaz

Capt. JG February 4th 06 06:34 PM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
"Gary" wrote in message
news:bg5Ff.322948$tl.239395@pd7tw3no...
MMC wrote:
Damn expensive experience gathering! A good friend has lost 2 inflatables
while towing! He finally bought davits.....
"Capt. JG" wrote in message
...


The reason I am interested in hearing from someone who has actually towed
a sit on top is because of all the types of towed dinghies, it seems like
it would be the best. It can't fill with water. It won't suddenly weigh
1000 pounds. It is unsinkable. The only thing that I can think of that
would be of concern is it flipping over in a seaway and diving. Painter
chafe is a solveable problem.

Carrying one onboard is easy and I do that regularily. I don't tie it to
the guardrails/lifelines though. They are not strong enough for that.

Gaz


Yes, it would seem like it would be the best... but they get pretty
squirrelly I would think... whipping around because they have no substance.
I believe that the one I saw lost kept getting whipped from side to side and
this finally did in the painter.

--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com




Capt. JG February 4th 06 06:35 PM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
You asked me what I saw... that's what I saw... isn't that enough? It
probably chafed through? Just a guess.

--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com

"Gary" wrote in message
news:303Ff.547604$ki.339867@pd7tw2no...
Capt. JG wrote:
A broken painter.

That's it?




Don White February 4th 06 07:36 PM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
Gary wrote:
MMC wrote:

Damn expensive experience gathering! A good friend has lost 2 inflatables
while towing! He finally bought davits.....
"Capt. JG" wrote in message
...



The reason I am interested in hearing from someone who has actually
towed a sit on top is because of all the types of towed dinghies, it
seems like it would be the best. It can't fill with water. It won't
suddenly weigh 1000 pounds. It is unsinkable. The only thing that I
can think of that would be of concern is it flipping over in a seaway
and diving. Painter chafe is a solveable problem.

Carrying one onboard is easy and I do that regularily. I don't tie it
to the guardrails/lifelines though. They are not strong enough for that.

Gaz



Usually, at this time, someone recommends the PortaBote.
It folds up smaller than your kayak for attaching to lifelines, yet
would keep you dry rowing back & forth to mooring field.
Like a normal dinghy, I would only tow it in calm seas.

Gary February 5th 06 02:47 AM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
Capt. JG wrote:
You asked me what I saw... that's what I saw... isn't that enough? It
probably chafed through? Just a guess.

I was expecting something more dramatic/catastrophic. IE: The kayak
surged forward and landed in the cockpit knocking the helmsman
overboard; The kayak inverted and dove straight down ripping the cleat
right off the back of the boat; The kayak accelerated past the boat
while surfing on a wave and when the painter came tight it yanked the
kayak bow right through a portlight.

Something more........you know.

Gaz

Gary February 5th 06 02:50 AM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
Don White wrote:
Gary wrote:

MMC wrote:

Damn expensive experience gathering! A good friend has lost 2
inflatables
while towing! He finally bought davits.....
"Capt. JG" wrote in message
...




The reason I am interested in hearing from someone who has actually
towed a sit on top is because of all the types of towed dinghies, it
seems like it would be the best. It can't fill with water. It won't
suddenly weigh 1000 pounds. It is unsinkable. The only thing that I
can think of that would be of concern is it flipping over in a seaway
and diving. Painter chafe is a solveable problem.

Carrying one onboard is easy and I do that regularily. I don't tie it
to the guardrails/lifelines though. They are not strong enough for that.

Gaz




Usually, at this time, someone recommends the PortaBote.
It folds up smaller than your kayak for attaching to lifelines, yet
would keep you dry rowing back & forth to mooring field.
Like a normal dinghy, I would only tow it in calm seas.


Doesn't it also present a lot of area to a boarding sea? There is also
the looks thing. PortaBote's are really ugly. They make a MacGregor
look nice.

Gaz

Capt. JG February 5th 06 06:19 PM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
I didn't see that part. I saw the part where the skipper and crew were
yelling "sh*t, sh*t, sh*t" over and over and trying to recover it.

--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com

"Gary" wrote in message
news:PGdFf.434495$2k.336015@pd7tw1no...
Capt. JG wrote:
You asked me what I saw... that's what I saw... isn't that enough? It
probably chafed through? Just a guess.

I was expecting something more dramatic/catastrophic. IE: The kayak
surged forward and landed in the cockpit knocking the helmsman overboard;
The kayak inverted and dove straight down ripping the cleat right off the
back of the boat; The kayak accelerated past the boat while surfing on a
wave and when the painter came tight it yanked the kayak bow right through
a portlight.

Something more........you know.

Gaz




Wayne.B February 6th 06 04:43 AM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
On Sat, 04 Feb 2006 17:12:39 GMT, Gary wrote:

The only thing that I
can think of that would be of concern is it flipping over in a seaway
and diving.


Flipping over is a matter of "when", not "if". It would be good no
know in advance how it will react after it flips.

I've had 2 towed inflatables flip over, once with a 65 lb outboard
motor on the back, and 1 fiberglass dinghy capsize while being towed.
It happens with amazing speed under the right conditions, and it
doesn't have to be especially rough. I see no reason to think that a
kayak is immune.


Gary February 6th 06 05:06 AM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
Wayne.B wrote:
On Sat, 04 Feb 2006 17:12:39 GMT, Gary wrote:


The only thing that I
can think of that would be of concern is it flipping over in a seaway
and diving.



Flipping over is a matter of "when", not "if". It would be good no
know in advance how it will react after it flips.

I've had 2 towed inflatables flip over, once with a 65 lb outboard
motor on the back, and 1 fiberglass dinghy capsize while being towed.
It happens with amazing speed under the right conditions, and it
doesn't have to be especially rough. I see no reason to think that a
kayak is immune.

I don't think the kayak would be immune to flipping. I am interested in
what it does after flipping. Unlike a hardshell dinghy, it won't fill
with water or behave like a drogue. Unlike a zodiac it shouldn't start
to come apart. The kayak can't fill with water and will either dive or
just flip back again. Remember, it is more like a log than a boat.

Gary

Spammy Spamson February 6th 06 09:20 AM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
OK, from experience - don't tow a kayak. Except for river or squirt
boats the majority of Kayaks are designed to track in a straight line.
All goes well until you tack. The painter slakens a bit, then
rightens and your Kayak continues on it's merry way on your LAST
course, until it is dragged sideways, flips over and fills with
water. That does not address your particular question about sit on
tops however as it would not fill with water - but I still wouldn't
tow it.

As to carrying on deck... a major pain in the ass unless you have a 60
ft boat.

Any other questions?

I've sold about a million dollars worth of Kayaks and have owned up to
five at one time and still have a couple of folders (which are what I
recomend and use on my sailboat). If you want an economical folder
check out pac boat.


regards,


Capt Spammy



On 3 Feb 2006 14:02:52 -0800, "
wrote:


Does anyone have experience either storing an
ocean kayak (closed, sit on top variety) on a 27
foot sailboat, or towing it behind?

What are your experiences? Doable? Horrible?
Good idea?

Thanks!



Ken Heaton February 6th 06 11:42 AM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
Tried this last year for a weekend. Bigger sailboat, perhaps smaller
kayaks. Good results.

We were out for the weekend on a C&C 35 Mk. I and took two friends and their
two rotomold kayaks, about 16 or 17 feet long. They fit on deck on edge
between the shrouds and the cabin top. They made it a bit more difficult to
go forward to tend to bow lines, sails, etc. but not too big a deal. You
had to pay more attention to the jib sheets when tacking as once a sheet
hooked under a kayak, forcing us to tack back to clear it. This was all in
protected waters, the Bras d'Or Lakes, and in generally good weather with
wind in the 10 to 20 knot range. We did try towing briefly but they track
too well, going off in one straight line until jerked onto another straight
line, rather annoying wandering around behind like that. I think the
painters wouldn't have lasted very long.

We were really glad we had brought the kayaks along as they were great for
exploring once we were tucked into an anchorage for the evening and in the
morning so our guests could have a little privacy and "sleep in."

As Steve says, my experience for what it's worth...
--
Ken Heaton & Anne Tobin
Cape Breton Island, Canada
kenheaton at eastlink dot ca

wrote in message
oups.com...

Does anyone have experience either storing an
ocean kayak (closed, sit on top variety) on a 27
foot sailboat, or towing it behind?

What are your experiences? Doable? Horrible?
Good idea?

Thanks!




Gary February 6th 06 02:56 PM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
Spammy Spamson wrote:
OK, from experience - don't tow a kayak. Except for river or squirt
boats the majority of Kayaks are designed to track in a straight line.
All goes well until you tack. The painter slakens a bit, then
rightens and your Kayak continues on it's merry way on your LAST
course, until it is dragged sideways, flips over and fills with
water.

That should be the same for boats shouldn't it?
That does not address your particular question about sit on
tops however as it would not fill with water - but I still wouldn't
tow it.

I am still looking for experience, not opinion.

As to carrying on deck... a major pain in the ass unless you have a 60
ft boat.


Concur

Any other questions?

I've sold about a million dollars worth of Kayaks and have owned up to
five at one time and still have a couple of folders (which are what I
recomend and use on my sailboat).

Me too.

If you want an economical folder
check out pac boat.

My pac boat google's first hit was a pac boat being launched on a lake
that was a little choppy and it was taking on water. Didn't look like
much boat for a dinghy replacement.

Gaz

Gary February 6th 06 02:59 PM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
Ken Heaton wrote:
Tried this last year for a weekend. Bigger sailboat, perhaps smaller
kayaks. Good results.

We were out for the weekend on a C&C 35 Mk. I and took two friends and their
two rotomold kayaks, about 16 or 17 feet long. They fit on deck on edge
between the shrouds and the cabin top. They made it a bit more difficult to
go forward to tend to bow lines, sails, etc. but not too big a deal. You
had to pay more attention to the jib sheets when tacking as once a sheet
hooked under a kayak, forcing us to tack back to clear it. This was all in
protected waters, the Bras d'Or Lakes, and in generally good weather with
wind in the 10 to 20 knot range. We did try towing briefly but they track
too well, going off in one straight line until jerked onto another straight
line, rather annoying wandering around behind like that. I think the
painters wouldn't have lasted very long.

We were really glad we had brought the kayaks along as they were great for
exploring once we were tucked into an anchorage for the evening and in the
morning so our guests could have a little privacy and "sleep in."

As Steve says, my experience for what it's worth...

That is interesting. Thanks.

Don White February 6th 06 03:38 PM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
Ken Heaton wrote:
Tried this last year for a weekend. Bigger sailboat, perhaps smaller
kayaks. Good results.

We were out for the weekend on a C&C 35 Mk. I and took two friends and their
two rotomold kayaks, about 16 or 17 feet long. They fit on deck on edge
between the shrouds and the cabin top. They made it a bit more difficult to
go forward to tend to bow lines, sails, etc. but not too big a deal. You
had to pay more attention to the jib sheets when tacking as once a sheet
hooked under a kayak, forcing us to tack back to clear it. This was all in
protected waters, the Bras d'Or Lakes, and in generally good weather with
wind in the 10 to 20 knot range. We did try towing briefly but they track
too well, going off in one straight line until jerked onto another straight
line, rather annoying wandering around behind like that. I think the
painters wouldn't have lasted very long.

We were really glad we had brought the kayaks along as they were great for
exploring once we were tucked into an anchorage for the evening and in the
morning so our guests could have a little privacy and "sleep in."

As Steve says, my experience for what it's worth...



Found a review of 9 different 'bag boats' that might be useful as a
portable way to go ashore ffrom a moored sailboat.
http://tinyurl.com/ar3t2

Capt. JG February 6th 06 06:53 PM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
Logs dive. Actually, I think it would dive, depending on the speed it was
towed. It would surface immediately, but that would put a lot of strain on
the line.... hmmm...

--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com

"Gary" wrote in message
news:ePAFf.342302$tl.292301@pd7tw3no...
Wayne.B wrote:
On Sat, 04 Feb 2006 17:12:39 GMT, Gary wrote:


The only thing that I can think of that would be of concern is it
flipping over in a seaway and diving.



Flipping over is a matter of "when", not "if". It would be good no
know in advance how it will react after it flips. I've had 2 towed
inflatables flip over, once with a 65 lb outboard
motor on the back, and 1 fiberglass dinghy capsize while being towed.
It happens with amazing speed under the right conditions, and it
doesn't have to be especially rough. I see no reason to think that a
kayak is immune.

I don't think the kayak would be immune to flipping. I am interested in
what it does after flipping. Unlike a hardshell dinghy, it won't fill
with water or behave like a drogue. Unlike a zodiac it shouldn't start to
come apart. The kayak can't fill with water and will either dive or just
flip back again. Remember, it is more like a log than a boat.

Gary




Jeff February 6th 06 07:35 PM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
Capt. JG wrote:
Logs dive. Actually, I think it would dive, depending on the speed it was
towed. It would surface immediately, but that would put a lot of strain on
the line.... hmmm...


From this site:
http://www.wavelengthmagazine.com/2005/fm05primer.php

"Kayaks do not tow well. They tend to surf a boat’s wake, go broadside
and flip. Two kayaks will tow better than one if they are lashed
together at the bow and stern, creating a catamaran shape. The best
plan for towing is to put them inside your dinghy if you don’t have
enough room on the deck."

Capt. JG February 6th 06 09:18 PM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
"Jeff" wrote in message
...
Capt. JG wrote:
Logs dive. Actually, I think it would dive, depending on the speed it was
towed. It would surface immediately, but that would put a lot of strain
on the line.... hmmm...


From this site:
http://www.wavelengthmagazine.com/2005/fm05primer.php

"Kayaks do not tow well. They tend to surf a boat’s wake, go broadside and
flip. Two kayaks will tow better than one if they are lashed together at
the bow and stern, creating a catamaran shape. The best plan for towing is
to put them inside your dinghy if you don’t have enough room on the deck."


Jeff, this is invalid...Gary only wants to hear about your own experiences.
:-)

--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com




Jeff February 6th 06 09:58 PM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
Capt. JG wrote:
"Jeff" wrote in message
...

Capt. JG wrote:

Logs dive. Actually, I think it would dive, depending on the speed it was
towed. It would surface immediately, but that would put a lot of strain
on the line.... hmmm...


From this site:
http://www.wavelengthmagazine.com/2005/fm05primer.php

"Kayaks do not tow well. They tend to surf a boat’s wake, go broadside and
flip. Two kayaks will tow better than one if they are lashed together at
the bow and stern, creating a catamaran shape. The best plan for towing is
to put them inside your dinghy if you don’t have enough room on the deck."



Jeff, this is invalid...Gary only wants to hear about your own experiences.
:-)


Actually, he and the OP do ask an interesting question - since a
sit-on-top can't fill, will it really be a problem to tow? Although I
have such a beast, I haven't tried towing, since most of my trips
start or end in crowded harbors or involve nasty sections, like Wood's
Hole, where you don't want to experiment.

However, I've been put off of any thoughts of trying by descriptions
such as the link I posted, and a book that said it was stressful on
the hull to tow above its hull speed. Also, it only takes a few
minutes to lift it on deck; its so easy that we do that in preference
to launching the dinghy if conditions allow.

If I did have to tow it, I think I'd pull it tight and lift the bow
some, so that it drags butt - it might stay well behaved in that mode.

Gary February 6th 06 11:33 PM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
Capt. JG wrote:
"Jeff" wrote in message
...

Capt. JG wrote:

Logs dive. Actually, I think it would dive, depending on the speed it was
towed. It would surface immediately, but that would put a lot of strain
on the line.... hmmm...


From this site:
http://www.wavelengthmagazine.com/2005/fm05primer.php

"Kayaks do not tow well. They tend to surf a boat’s wake, go broadside and
flip. Two kayaks will tow better than one if they are lashed together at
the bow and stern, creating a catamaran shape. The best plan for towing is
to put them inside your dinghy if you don’t have enough room on the deck."



Jeff, this is invalid...Gary only wants to hear about your own experiences.
:-)

I think I am just gonna tow my kayak for a while and see. I'll let you
guys know how it turns out. If it gets squirrily or breaks loose I'll
just bring it aboard. I don't think anything awful will happen.

Capt. JG February 6th 06 11:58 PM

Ocean Kayak and 27footer: store / tow
 
"Gary" wrote in message
news:a1RFf.351870$tl.349701@pd7tw3no...
Capt. JG wrote:
"Jeff" wrote in message
...

Capt. JG wrote:

Logs dive. Actually, I think it would dive, depending on the speed it
was towed. It would surface immediately, but that would put a lot of
strain on the line.... hmmm...


From this site:
http://www.wavelengthmagazine.com/2005/fm05primer.php

"Kayaks do not tow well. They tend to surf a boat’s wake, go broadside
and flip. Two kayaks will tow better than one if they are lashed together
at the bow and stern, creating a catamaran shape. The best plan for
towing is to put them inside your dinghy if you don’t have enough room on
the deck."



Jeff, this is invalid...Gary only wants to hear about your own
experiences. :-)

I think I am just gonna tow my kayak for a while and see. I'll let you
guys know how it turns out. If it gets squirrily or breaks loose I'll
just bring it aboard. I don't think anything awful will happen.


There you go... the scientific method. Good idea!

--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com





All times are GMT +1. The time now is 06:50 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com