BoatBanter.com

BoatBanter.com (https://www.boatbanter.com/)
-   Cruising (https://www.boatbanter.com/cruising/)
-   -   sailing & pirate movies (https://www.boatbanter.com/cruising/63283-sailing-pirate-movies.html)

noone cares November 25th 05 11:32 AM

sailing & pirate movies
 
I ran across a movie on TV (1983, Tommy Lee Jones) called Nate and
Hayes, really enjoyed it!

Are there any other old movies like this (probably), even B movies,
lets get a list started.

I bought and converted Nate and Hayes to DVD (since its no longer in
production, was never realeased on DVD, and is no longer sold, thats
legal), and I will be happy to trade with anyone who has another
similar type movie that we can't find.

List:

Master and Commander
Nate and Hayes


Keith November 25th 05 12:53 PM

sailing & pirate movies
 
Check out "The Island". Cool modern day pirate movie. Not the Sci-fi
one that's fairly recent... this was made in the 70's or 80's.


Glen \Wiley\ Wilson November 25th 05 04:35 PM

sailing & pirate movies
 
On Fri, 25 Nov 2005 07:32:16 -0400, noone cares
wrote:

I ran across a movie on TV (1983, Tommy Lee Jones) called Nate and
Hayes, really enjoyed it!


I remember that one. Good fun. I was trying to remember the title a
few weeks ago, so thanks.

Are there any other old movies like this (probably), even B movies,
lets get a list started.

I bought and converted Nate and Hayes to DVD (since its no longer in
production, was never realeased on DVD, and is no longer sold, thats
legal), and I will be happy to trade with anyone who has another
similar type movie that we can't find.


There is a lot of confusion on this point, so I can see where you'd
get that idea. But actually it's not legal. The current marketing
status of an author's work has no legal impact on whether it's legal
for you to sell or trade it. Right or wrong, the right to do that
rests entirely with the copyright holder for as long as the copyright
lasts.

I expect now that I will be harangued by people with arguments that
boil down to "I want it, he won't let me have it, so I'm gonna take
it. Nobody get's hurt. Information wants to be free!" This
evidently sounds reasonable to many, but it doesn't affect the way the
law is written. It's a pecadillo in my book, but I'm not an attorney
for a movie studio. I won't be trading, but I don't mind contributing
to yet another "best sailing movies" thread.

List:

Master and Commander
Nate and Hayes

Captain Horatio Hornblower (Gregory Peck version - the A&E Hornblower
is good too.)
Dead Calm
Captain Blood
Krakatoa: East of Java
Damn the Defiant!

__________________________________________________ __________
Glen "Wiley" Wilson usenet1 SPAMNIX at world wide wiley dot com
To reply, lose the capitals and do the obvious.

Take a look at cpRepeater, my NMEA data integrator, repeater, and
logger at http://www.worldwidewiley.com/

Richard November 25th 05 06:01 PM

sailing & pirate movies
 
White Squall

"Glen "Wiley" Wilson" wrote in
message ...
On Fri, 25 Nov 2005 07:32:16 -0400, noone cares
wrote:

I ran across a movie on TV (1983, Tommy Lee Jones) called Nate and
Hayes, really enjoyed it!


I remember that one. Good fun. I was trying to remember the title a
few weeks ago, so thanks.

Are there any other old movies like this (probably), even B movies,
lets get a list started.

I bought and converted Nate and Hayes to DVD (since its no longer in
production, was never realeased on DVD, and is no longer sold, thats
legal), and I will be happy to trade with anyone who has another
similar type movie that we can't find.


There is a lot of confusion on this point, so I can see where you'd
get that idea. But actually it's not legal. The current marketing
status of an author's work has no legal impact on whether it's legal
for you to sell or trade it. Right or wrong, the right to do that
rests entirely with the copyright holder for as long as the copyright
lasts.

I expect now that I will be harangued by people with arguments that
boil down to "I want it, he won't let me have it, so I'm gonna take
it. Nobody get's hurt. Information wants to be free!" This
evidently sounds reasonable to many, but it doesn't affect the way the
law is written. It's a pecadillo in my book, but I'm not an attorney
for a movie studio. I won't be trading, but I don't mind contributing
to yet another "best sailing movies" thread.

List:

Master and Commander
Nate and Hayes

Captain Horatio Hornblower (Gregory Peck version - the A&E Hornblower
is good too.)
Dead Calm
Captain Blood
Krakatoa: East of Java
Damn the Defiant!

__________________________________________________ __________
Glen "Wiley" Wilson usenet1 SPAMNIX at world wide wiley dot com
To reply, lose the capitals and do the obvious.

Take a look at cpRepeater, my NMEA data integrator, repeater, and
logger at http://www.worldwidewiley.com/




Terry Spragg November 25th 05 07:57 PM

sailing & pirate movies
 
Richard wrote:

White Squall

"Glen "Wiley" Wilson" wrote in
message ...

On Fri, 25 Nov 2005 07:32:16 -0400, noone cares
wrote:


I ran across a movie on TV (1983, Tommy Lee Jones) called Nate and
Hayes, really enjoyed it!


I remember that one. Good fun. I was trying to remember the title a
few weeks ago, so thanks.

Are there any other old movies like this (probably), even B movies,
lets get a list started.

I bought and converted Nate and Hayes to DVD (since its no longer in
production, was never realeased on DVD, and is no longer sold, thats
legal), and I will be happy to trade with anyone who has another
similar type movie that we can't find.


There is a lot of confusion on this point, so I can see where you'd
get that idea. But actually it's not legal. The current marketing
status of an author's work has no legal impact on whether it's legal
for you to sell or trade it. Right or wrong, the right to do that
rests entirely with the copyright holder for as long as the copyright
lasts.

I expect now that I will be harangued by people with arguments that
boil down to "I want it, he won't let me have it, so I'm gonna take
it. Nobody get's hurt. Information wants to be free!" This
evidently sounds reasonable to many, but it doesn't affect the way the
law is written. It's a pecadillo in my book, but I'm not an attorney
for a movie studio. I won't be trading, but I don't mind contributing
to yet another "best sailing movies" thread.

List:

Master and Commander
Nate and Hayes


Captain Horatio Hornblower (Gregory Peck version - the A&E Hornblower
is good too.)
Dead Calm
Captain Blood
Krakatoa: East of Java
Damn the Defiant!


Cool! Write a certified cheque for 1 dollar and send it to whomever
you think should get the royalties.

If they cash it, or not, you can produce it in court as a
demonstration of your good intentions. It's a lot more than a
legitimate owner might expect to get using a publishing company.

A co-op might pool the proffered funds, with the intention of
seeking an attourney to disburse the funds. CAPO might help. We'd
need an administrator. Copyclub.com should do.

That should assuage your concience, and Judge Judy.

Trade away! Publisher's agent's lawyers chase commercial printing
press bootleggers, not guys like you.

Terry K


Glen \Wiley\ Wilson November 25th 05 10:35 PM

Copyrights -- Was sailing & pirate movies -- LONG
 
On Fri, 25 Nov 2005 15:57:02 -0400, Terry Spragg
wrote:

Cool! Write a certified cheque for 1 dollar and send it to whomever
you think should get the royalties.

If they cash it, or not, you can produce it in court as a
demonstration of your good intentions. It's a lot more than a
legitimate owner might expect to get using a publishing company.

A co-op might pool the proffered funds, with the intention of
seeking an attourney to disburse the funds. CAPO might help. We'd
need an administrator. Copyclub.com should do.

That should assuage your concience, and Judge Judy.

Trade away! Publisher's agent's lawyers chase commercial printing
press bootleggers, not guys like you.


Your last point seems to be that it's alright as long as you don't get
caught? OK. I don't think I'll respond to that. It doesn't seem to
be a profitable avenue for discussion and I expect you didn't really
mean it that way.

This is mostly intellectual interest on my part -- I don't really care
what the OP does and I'm in no position to act holier than thou. I've
doubtless done worse things.

But I've at various times been a musician, a photographer, a writer,
and a programmer of commercial software. As such, I tend to identify
with the problems of the copyright owner more than the average guy
does. It's a little bit different when it's *your* copyright being
abused.

I will point out that there are hundreds of file traders being sued
here in the US as we speak by the studios. Sending a dollar to some
random individual affects your legal standing not one whit. When and
how a copyrighted work is released is at the sole discretion of the
copyright holder. "Good intent" and the state of one's conscience is
entirely irrelevant. In other words, Judge Judy would send you to the
guillotine. But you're probably right that the OP will get away with
it. I hope so, anyway. Right now, the punishment does not fit the
crime, IMHO.

Your co-op idea is interesting. It would only satisfy the legal
issues to the extent that studios, publishers, etc. decided to
participate. According to copyright law as laid down in the
constitution and reinforced by piles of legislation and international
treaties like the Berne convention, we don't get to dictate to artists
how their license agreements work. But it's hard to see how it would
be a bad thing for them.

I'm aware of at least one co-op run by authors to license electronic
versions of their out-of-print works at very reasonable rates. Seems
like a good idea. Studios should look into that. They'd get to make
a little bit of cash off their catalog without having to press dvds
and distribute them.

Right now the system is broken and being propped up by bad laws like
the DMCA and bad technology like MacroVision or the Sony root kits
that have been installed on some unknown number of PCs without the
owners informed consent. Oh yeah, and lawsuits.

Copyrights and patents are the basis of free enterprise innovation.
There needs to be incentive (read:profit) to create and publish
original works, but it makes no sense that the OP should be in
violation of federal and international law (enforced or not,
enforceable or not).

Wow, that turned into a rant. I've been thinking about this lately
and it all just spewed out. Sorry about that.

Obligatory cruising content: this discussion also applies to
copyrighted charts.

More Obligatory cruising content: under the DMCA, the shape of a
boats hull is now considered copyrighted material.


__________________________________________________ __________
Glen "Wiley" Wilson usenet1 SPAMNIX at world wide wiley dot com
To reply, lose the capitals and do the obvious.

Take a look at cpRepeater, my NMEA data integrator, repeater, and
logger at http://www.worldwidewiley.com/

FMac November 26th 05 01:31 AM

Copyrights -- Was sailing & pirate movies -- LONG
 

"Glen "Wiley" Wilson" wrote in part:
Sorry about that.
Likewise!



MMC November 26th 05 11:38 PM

sailing & pirate movies
 
Captain Ron.
"Richard" wrote in message
...
White Squall

"Glen "Wiley" Wilson" wrote in
message ...
On Fri, 25 Nov 2005 07:32:16 -0400, noone cares
wrote:

I ran across a movie on TV (1983, Tommy Lee Jones) called Nate and
Hayes, really enjoyed it!


I remember that one. Good fun. I was trying to remember the title a
few weeks ago, so thanks.

Are there any other old movies like this (probably), even B movies,
lets get a list started.

I bought and converted Nate and Hayes to DVD (since its no longer in
production, was never realeased on DVD, and is no longer sold, thats
legal), and I will be happy to trade with anyone who has another
similar type movie that we can't find.


There is a lot of confusion on this point, so I can see where you'd
get that idea. But actually it's not legal. The current marketing
status of an author's work has no legal impact on whether it's legal
for you to sell or trade it. Right or wrong, the right to do that
rests entirely with the copyright holder for as long as the copyright
lasts.

I expect now that I will be harangued by people with arguments that
boil down to "I want it, he won't let me have it, so I'm gonna take
it. Nobody get's hurt. Information wants to be free!" This
evidently sounds reasonable to many, but it doesn't affect the way the
law is written. It's a pecadillo in my book, but I'm not an attorney
for a movie studio. I won't be trading, but I don't mind contributing
to yet another "best sailing movies" thread.

List:

Master and Commander
Nate and Hayes

Captain Horatio Hornblower (Gregory Peck version - the A&E Hornblower
is good too.)
Dead Calm
Captain Blood
Krakatoa: East of Java
Damn the Defiant!

__________________________________________________ __________
Glen "Wiley" Wilson usenet1 SPAMNIX at world wide wiley dot com
To reply, lose the capitals and do the obvious.

Take a look at cpRepeater, my NMEA data integrator, repeater, and
logger at http://www.worldwidewiley.com/






Bryan November 27th 05 02:28 AM

sailing & pirate movies
 

"noone cares" wrote in message
...
I ran across a movie on TV (1983, Tommy Lee Jones) called Nate and
Hayes, really enjoyed it!

Are there any other old movies like this (probably), even B movies,
lets get a list started.

I bought and converted Nate and Hayes to DVD (since its no longer in
production, was never realeased on DVD, and is no longer sold, thats
legal), and I will be happy to trade with anyone who has another
similar type movie that we can't find.

List:

Master and Commander
Nate and Hayes

The latest Pirates of The Carribean
Captain Ron is my all time favorite



Glenn A. Heslop November 27th 05 04:02 PM

sailing & pirate movies
 
Gotta include Capt' Ron & White Squall.

Glenn.

"noone cares" wrote in message
...
I ran across a movie on TV (1983, Tommy Lee Jones) called Nate and
Hayes, really enjoyed it!

Are there any other old movies like this (probably), even B movies,
lets get a list started.

I bought and converted Nate and Hayes to DVD (since its no longer in
production, was never realeased on DVD, and is no longer sold, thats
legal), and I will be happy to trade with anyone who has another
similar type movie that we can't find.

List:

Master and Commander
Nate and Hayes





All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:01 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com