BoatBanter.com

BoatBanter.com (https://www.boatbanter.com/)
-   Cruising (https://www.boatbanter.com/cruising/)
-   -   Grim MO in Maine (https://www.boatbanter.com/cruising/61767-grim-mo-maine.html)

Roger Long October 21st 05 12:21 PM

Grim MO in Maine
 
An experienced sailor went overboard from his 41 foot ketch on a trip
from Rockland ME to Rye NH for haul out. His 20 year old son was the
only crew member and spent from last Saturday till yesterday
(Thursday) drifting from off Boothbay Harbor to near Cape Cod.

A Coast Guard jet spotted the boat with sails down and apparently
abandoned after an extensive search and had a nearby fishing boat go
over for a look. The son jumped overboard immediately when he saw the
fishing boat and swam to it. He was then airlifted by chopper from the
fishing boat to Cape Cod.

By all accounts and what can be determined from a newspaper photo, the
boat was capable and well equipped. No hint yet why the son was not
able to start the engines or use the radios.

You can bet I'll be giving my family another round of more intensive
training next spring.

--

Roger Long





Don White October 21st 05 02:15 PM

Grim MO in Maine
 
Roger Long wrote:
An experienced sailor went overboard from his 41 foot ketch on a trip
from Rockland ME to Rye NH for haul out. His 20 year old son was the
only crew member and spent from last Saturday till yesterday
(Thursday) drifting from off Boothbay Harbor to near Cape Cod.

A Coast Guard jet spotted the boat with sails down and apparently
abandoned after an extensive search and had a nearby fishing boat go
over for a look. The son jumped overboard immediately when he saw the
fishing boat and swam to it. He was then airlifted by chopper from the
fishing boat to Cape Cod.

By all accounts and what can be determined from a newspaper photo, the
boat was capable and well equipped. No hint yet why the son was not
able to start the engines or use the radios.

You can bet I'll be giving my family another round of more intensive
training next spring.

You bet. As a minimum, they should be able to use the VHF.

Rosalie B. October 21st 05 02:33 PM

Grim MO in Maine
 
Don White wrote:

Roger Long wrote:
An experienced sailor went overboard from his 41 foot ketch on a trip
from Rockland ME to Rye NH for haul out. His 20 year old son was the
only crew member and spent from last Saturday till yesterday
(Thursday) drifting from off Boothbay Harbor to near Cape Cod.

A Coast Guard jet spotted the boat with sails down and apparently
abandoned after an extensive search and had a nearby fishing boat go
over for a look. The son jumped overboard immediately when he saw the
fishing boat and swam to it. He was then airlifted by chopper from the
fishing boat to Cape Cod.

By all accounts and what can be determined from a newspaper photo, the
boat was capable and well equipped. No hint yet why the son was not
able to start the engines or use the radios.

You can bet I'll be giving my family another round of more intensive
training next spring.

You bet. As a minimum, they should be able to use the VHF.


Something like this happened to a man in the Bahamas and his wife
couldn't turn off the autopilot or use the VHF either. She called for
help on the SSB which happened to be tuned to a weather forecaster in
the Virgin Islands, and he relayed the message to BASRA. It turned
out that she had once been able to do those things, but she had
Alzheimer's.


grandma Rosalie

Roger Long October 21st 05 02:36 PM

Grim MO in Maine
 
I also leave the GPS running on the display with the Lat Long and make
sure they know the button that pages to it. I told them to read those
numbers in their Mayday either on the radio or the cell phone which
reaches most areas where we sail.

--

Roger Long





Roger Long October 21st 05 04:38 PM

Grim MO in Maine
 
Someone once suggested to me pretending like the freeboard was 1000
feet and then thinking how your would approach deckwork.

I'll admit to being rather casual on this point but I'm really
thinking about this.

--

Roger Long



Dennis Pogson October 21st 05 05:51 PM

Grim MO in Maine
 
Roger Long wrote:
An experienced sailor went overboard from his 41 foot ketch on a trip
from Rockland ME to Rye NH for haul out. His 20 year old son was the
only crew member and spent from last Saturday till yesterday
(Thursday) drifting from off Boothbay Harbor to near Cape Cod.

A Coast Guard jet spotted the boat with sails down and apparently
abandoned after an extensive search and had a nearby fishing boat go
over for a look. The son jumped overboard immediately when he saw the
fishing boat and swam to it. He was then airlifted by chopper from the
fishing boat to Cape Cod.

By all accounts and what can be determined from a newspaper photo, the
boat was capable and well equipped. No hint yet why the son was not
able to start the engines or use the radios.

You can bet I'll be giving my family another round of more intensive
training next spring.


I misread the post as "2-year-old son". Surely a 20-year-old would have
taken more notice of the boat's systems and how they operate? Granted he may
not have been on the boat before, but all the more reason for the father to
give him a thorough work-thru before leaving?


Dennis.



Capt. JG October 21st 05 07:30 PM

Grim MO in Maine
 
That's an interesting way to look at it. I usually have a somewhat similar
discussion when I'm teaching people on our 30 footer... asking what would it
feel like to fall off the boat head first onto the dock. If you don't like
that idea, don't jump!

--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com

"Roger Long" wrote in message
...
Someone once suggested to me pretending like the freeboard was 1000 feet
and then thinking how your would approach deckwork.

I'll admit to being rather casual on this point but I'm really thinking
about this.

--

Roger Long





Me October 21st 05 08:25 PM

Grim MO in Maine
 
In article ,
"Roger Long" wrote:

I also leave the GPS running on the display with the Lat Long and make
sure they know the button that pages to it. I told them to read those
numbers in their Mayday either on the radio or the cell phone which
reaches most areas where we sail.


Crew Training is the responcability of the Skipper, and I, for one,
go over the MayDay Card that is Posted by the radio with each, and
every, person who boards my vessel, BEFORE we untie the lines.....
Every time......


Me

[email protected] October 22nd 05 07:01 AM

Grim MO in Maine
 
The new VHF radios have a nice red 16 button, and if you are out of
range for the VHF, IMHO: EPRBs are expensive, but should be high on
the list if necessary equipment.
It is a very sad and heart wrenching story.

John
S/V Pangea


Evan Gatehouse October 22nd 05 07:21 AM

Grim MO in Maine
 
Roger Long wrote:
Someone once suggested to me pretending like the freeboard was 1000
feet and then thinking how your would approach deckwork.

I'll admit to being rather casual on this point but I'm really
thinking about this.


My wife and I discussed this when offshore cruising. Our
thought was that either of us fell overboard at night with
the other sleeping, you're dead. Simple as that. Always
wore our harnesses and clipped on to the jackline when
leaving the cockpit. Never slipped or had an incident but
you should take it seriously.

We look upon lost hats overboard as improptu man overboard
drills and usually recover them in about 2-4 minutes. But
they are easy to miss and hard to see. A floating hat is
similar to a head in the water. Makes you appreciate the
usefulness of a Dan Buoy.

Evan Gatehouse


Lauri Tarkkonen October 22nd 05 07:54 AM

Grim MO in Maine
 
In Evan Gatehouse writes:

Roger Long wrote:
Someone once suggested to me pretending like the freeboard was 1000
feet and then thinking how your would approach deckwork.

I'll admit to being rather casual on this point but I'm really
thinking about this.


My wife and I discussed this when offshore cruising. Our
thought was that either of us fell overboard at night with
the other sleeping, you're dead. Simple as that. Always
wore our harnesses and clipped on to the jackline when
leaving the cockpit. Never slipped or had an incident but
you should take it seriously.


We look upon lost hats overboard as improptu man overboard
drills and usually recover them in about 2-4 minutes. But
they are easy to miss and hard to see. A floating hat is
similar to a head in the water. Makes you appreciate the
usefulness of a Dan Buoy.


There is a minor difference in recovering a lost hat than recovering a
adult human being. Your recovery time of 2-4 minutes are for sure close
to unofficial world records, and I am afraid that even you might not
match the times if either of you were in the water and the other one in
the boat. Anyway this is not the issue, but there are several cases
where the crew aboard had had trouble of getting the ones swimming back
aboard. After a few minutes in the water, that is quite a cold in the
northern and southern seas, the ability to catch and hold on to the rope
is limited and to hoist a person even if you get hold of him/her is not
as easy as some armchairsailors might think.

There was a case some ten years ago here in Baltic, where the captain
fell into the sea, and even though his vife and daughter and son in law
got a rope to him and under his arms, they could not hoist him to the
boat soon enough, to prevent him from dying in hypothermia. It was mid
Jyly and the weather was reasonabl gentle.

- Lauri Tarkkonen


Maynard G. Krebbs October 22nd 05 09:52 AM

Grim MO in Maine
 
On Fri, 21 Oct 2005 11:21:25 GMT, "Roger Long"
wrote:
Snippage


You can bet I'll be giving my family another round of more intensive
training next spring.


You could try the "Captain for a day" rotation amoung your family. You
would retain oversight powers and of coarse be there for advise. :o)

They'll learn a lot and have fun being in charge for a day once in a
while. As they get older/more profecient you could expand their
duties into voyage planning for their day as Captain.
Mark E. Williams

Don White October 22nd 05 01:51 PM

Grim MO in Maine
 
Lauri Tarkkonen wrote:
In Evan Gatehouse writes:


Roger Long wrote:

Someone once suggested to me pretending like the freeboard was 1000
feet and then thinking how your would approach deckwork.

I'll admit to being rather casual on this point but I'm really
thinking about this.



My wife and I discussed this when offshore cruising. Our
thought was that either of us fell overboard at night with
the other sleeping, you're dead. Simple as that. Always
wore our harnesses and clipped on to the jackline when
leaving the cockpit. Never slipped or had an incident but
you should take it seriously.



We look upon lost hats overboard as improptu man overboard
drills and usually recover them in about 2-4 minutes. But
they are easy to miss and hard to see. A floating hat is
similar to a head in the water. Makes you appreciate the
usefulness of a Dan Buoy.



There is a minor difference in recovering a lost hat than recovering a
adult human being. Your recovery time of 2-4 minutes are for sure close
to unofficial world records, and I am afraid that even you might not
match the times if either of you were in the water and the other one in
the boat. Anyway this is not the issue, but there are several cases
where the crew aboard had had trouble of getting the ones swimming back
aboard. After a few minutes in the water, that is quite a cold in the
northern and southern seas, the ability to catch and hold on to the rope
is limited and to hoist a person even if you get hold of him/her is not
as easy as some armchairsailors might think.

There was a case some ten years ago here in Baltic, where the captain
fell into the sea, and even though his vife and daughter and son in law
got a rope to him and under his arms, they could not hoist him to the
boat soon enough, to prevent him from dying in hypothermia. It was mid
Jyly and the weather was reasonabl gentle.

- Lauri Tarkkonen

What's that little saying....
50% of the people will last 50 minutes in 50 deg (F)water.
They taught us to make a 'bowline on a bight' knot to help in this
case....and if the boat is big enough, attach the main halyard to the
boom end...the bight from aft end of boom to victim. Use winches to
raise boom end (with victim secured) and swing over rail into boat.
Could be tough to do in heavy seas.

Rosalie B. October 22nd 05 03:45 PM

Grim MO in Maine
 
(Lauri Tarkkonen) wrote:

In Evan Gatehouse writes:

Roger Long wrote:
Someone once suggested to me pretending like the freeboard was 1000
feet and then thinking how your would approach deckwork.

I'll admit to being rather casual on this point but I'm really
thinking about this.


My wife and I discussed this when offshore cruising. Our
thought was that either of us fell overboard at night with
the other sleeping, you're dead. Simple as that. Always
wore our harnesses and clipped on to the jackline when
leaving the cockpit. Never slipped or had an incident but
you should take it seriously.


The same with us. No matter how calm or protected the waters, we
always wear life jackets when underway - not just offshore, but even
in the ICW. We wear the auto-inflate kind, and we tested them to see
how well they worked when we first got them.

We look upon lost hats overboard as improptu man overboard
drills and usually recover them in about 2-4 minutes. But
they are easy to miss and hard to see. A floating hat is
similar to a head in the water. Makes you appreciate the
usefulness of a Dan Buoy.


There is a minor difference in recovering a lost hat than recovering a
adult human being. Your recovery time of 2-4 minutes are for sure close
to unofficial world records, and I am afraid that even you might not
match the times if either of you were in the water and the other one in
the boat. Anyway this is not the issue, but there are several cases
where the crew aboard had had trouble of getting the ones swimming back
aboard. After a few minutes in the water, that is quite a cold in the
northern and southern seas, the ability to catch and hold on to the rope
is limited and to hoist a person even if you get hold of him/her is not
as easy as some armchairsailors might think.

There was a case some ten years ago here in Baltic, where the captain
fell into the sea, and even though his vife and daughter and son in law
got a rope to him and under his arms, they could not hoist him to the
boat soon enough, to prevent him from dying in hypothermia. It was mid
Jyly and the weather was reasonabl gentle.

We also have a way that we worked out so that either of us can winch
aboard (using the jib winch) the other one as long as the person is
conscious and can seat him/herself on the sling. We've practiced and
the gear is in the locker next to the jib winch.

However, if we have to go on deck in anything except a very calm sea,
we also clip onto the jacklines.


grandma Rosalie

Capt. JG October 22nd 05 05:57 PM

Grim MO in Maine
 
The possibility of finding the person in the dark will be greatly enhanced
if you have a strobe that is water activated. For an offshore, short-handed
journey, it's a small investment.

--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com

"Evan Gatehouse" wrote in message
...
Roger Long wrote:
Someone once suggested to me pretending like the freeboard was 1000 feet
and then thinking how your would approach deckwork.

I'll admit to being rather casual on this point but I'm really thinking
about this.


My wife and I discussed this when offshore cruising. Our thought was that
either of us fell overboard at night with the other sleeping, you're dead.
Simple as that. Always wore our harnesses and clipped on to the jackline
when leaving the cockpit. Never slipped or had an incident but you should
take it seriously.

We look upon lost hats overboard as improptu man overboard drills and
usually recover them in about 2-4 minutes. But they are easy to miss and
hard to see. A floating hat is similar to a head in the water. Makes you
appreciate the usefulness of a Dan Buoy.

Evan Gatehouse




Andy October 23rd 05 05:02 AM

Grim MO in Maine
 
Evan Gatehouse wrote:

My wife and I discussed this when offshore cruising. Our
thought was that either of us fell overboard at night with
the other sleeping, you're dead. Simple as that.


MOB at night is not necessarily the end if are lucky enough to do it in
the tropics in a major shipping lane.

When my wife and I were off the coast of Panama in the shipping lanes
we heard a call around 7am from a Ukrainian crewed freighter about a
MOB. A crewman had gone overboard at around 1am, and the freighter
was, for some reason, leaving the area. We were very close to the MOB
position the freighter gave, and so we started moving towards it,
though we didn't think the guy would be near there anymore since there
was a 1-2 kt current. A Panamax container ship also heard the call and
came charging to the scene (its interesting to have container ship pass
50 yards away going full speed) and, incredibly, spotted the guy within
about 20 minutes about 5 miles down current from where he went
overboard. By the time the Panamax managed to turn around and come to
a stop 100 yards from the MOB we had caught up. The Panamax had to talk
us to his position because we couldn't see him until we got within less
than 100 feet, even though conditions were not particularly rough. We
recovered him in using our dinghy (much easier than trying to pull him
directly on board, which may have been impossible). The Ukrainian
freighter came back for him, and we handed him over an hour later.

What I learned from this is that its almost impossible to see someone's
head from the deck of a sailboat if there is any chop at all, but that
if you can get a large vessel involved in the search, even hours later,
your odds improve immensely.

Andy


rhys October 23rd 05 07:41 AM

Grim MO in Maine
 
On Fri, 21 Oct 2005 15:38:28 GMT, "Roger Long"
wrote:

Someone once suggested to me pretending like the freeboard was 1000
feet and then thinking how your would approach deckwork.

I'll admit to being rather casual on this point but I'm really
thinking about this.


My four-year-old is getting a regular indoctrination on the concept of
"one hand for the boat". We don't generally sail in rough enough
weather to demand jacklines, but I can rig them if necessary.

I installed preventers (as in big beefy one fixed on both sides with
lines back to the cockpit) on the boom this year, as one of the prime
ways sailors get knocked overboard around here is getting slapped in
an unexpected gybe.

The preventers act like "super vangs" and I use them instead of the
mainsheet to do main gybes in heavy air. There's a lot less noise and
fuss and possiblity of getting bonked.

R.


Don White October 23rd 05 05:13 PM

Grim MO in Maine
 
rhys wrote:
On Fri, 21 Oct 2005 15:38:28 GMT, "Roger Long"
wrote:


Someone once suggested to me pretending like the freeboard was 1000
feet and then thinking how your would approach deckwork.

I'll admit to being rather casual on this point but I'm really
thinking about this.



My four-year-old is getting a regular indoctrination on the concept of
"one hand for the boat". We don't generally sail in rough enough
weather to demand jacklines, but I can rig them if necessary.

I installed preventers (as in big beefy one fixed on both sides with
lines back to the cockpit) on the boom this year, as one of the prime
ways sailors get knocked overboard around here is getting slapped in
an unexpected gybe.

The preventers act like "super vangs" and I use them instead of the
mainsheet to do main gybes in heavy air. There's a lot less noise and
fuss and possiblity of getting bonked.

R.

Good idea..As one sailer who has been smacked in the head by the boom, I
can tell you it's no fun.

rhys October 24th 05 01:30 AM

Grim MO in Maine
 
On 22 Oct 2005 21:02:36 -0700, "Andy"
wrote:


What I learned from this is that its almost impossible to see someone's
head from the deck of a sailboat if there is any chop at all, but that
if you can get a large vessel involved in the search, even hours later,
your odds improve immensely.

This was an educational story. Thanks for sharing it.

R.

Ryk October 26th 05 09:08 PM

Grim MO in Maine
 
On 22 Oct 2005 06:54:28 GMT, (Lauri Tarkkonen)
wrote:

There was a case some ten years ago here in Baltic, where the captain
fell into the sea, and even though his vife and daughter and son in law
got a rope to him and under his arms, they could not hoist him to the
boat soon enough, to prevent him from dying in hypothermia. It was mid
Jyly and the weather was reasonabl gentle.


How did they screw it up if they had him on a rope? I've swum in the
Baltic in mid July for fun. Hypothermia would take a while.

oops, I'm presuming sailboat, clip a halyard to the line and grind
even an unconscious MOB aboard. I am much more frightened about the
possibility of being an unnoticed MOB.

Ryk

Ryk October 26th 05 09:22 PM

Grim MO in Maine
 
On Sun, 23 Oct 2005 02:41:44 -0400, rhys wrote:

My four-year-old is getting a regular indoctrination on the concept of
"one hand for the boat". We don't generally sail in rough enough
weather to demand jacklines, but I can rig them if necessary.


Install the jacklines as another learning experience. I was amazed to
see how many grownups didn't clip in on our offshore adventures on
another boat. I put it up to lack of imagination...

My jacklines were in place from July 1 to haulout. I used them.
Waiting to rig may be the same sort of thing as not reefing soon
enough. It's really good to have jacklines already rigged when dousing
sail and reefing.

Ryk


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 05:33 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com