![]() |
Why cruise?
My annoyance with that silly Mark Twain quote prompts this post.
Although casting off everyday cares to go cruising sounds ideal to many people, I have to wonder about people aspire to it with intense zeal. I wonder if they have so little to offer to humanity that they would abandon society for such a narcissistic goal. If you spend all of your time cruising, you essentially give up making any difference to the rest of humanity. My personal belief ("belief" means I have no proof or even a good argument for it) is that each of us has some unique skill that could somehow be of use to humanity. Unfortunately, very few people ever discover this skill (a topic that I spend hours discussing with my unhappy state worker neighbor)but I think you ought to give it many real tries before giving up and going off cruising. I have no problem with people who retire and then go cruising, they have already made their contribution. My argument is with people who aspire to cruising as their life goal. The most interesting and to my mind the most successful cruising person I have ever seen was when I had my old 23' boat docked waaaaaay up the Carabelle River at a place for $20/month. The boat next to mine was a trashed out 21' Venture. One day, its hatch was open and a voice invited me aboard and when I stepped into the cabin, I stepped into water 1" deep. In the gloom I saw huge cans of green beans labelled Department of Agriculture that i recognized as early 60s cast-offs from fallout shelters in Tallahassee (this was 1988). The Master and Commander of this odd vessel was named Jack who told me that until 6 months ago he had been a homeless drunk but he had somehow been given a check for $500 that he used to buy this floating (sort-of) home of his on a whim. I never learned the rest of his story but clearly he had an interesting life as he had only one ear, half of his left hand, something wrong with one eye and other physical markings of a less than normal suburban existence. Jack had a black mongrel dog named "Crow" that perfectly matched him as it was missing a front paw and its lower jaw was bent at a strange angle to the rest of its head from being run over. Jack sailed this amazing little boat with duct tape repaired sails all over the northern gulf from Cedar Key all the way over to (this is almost unbelievable) New Orleans. I'd run into him at odd places and he could describe the channels of all the cool places I wanted to visit that also did not have marked channels. One day, I ran into Jack on a brand new top-of-the-line boat ( I cannot remember the brand) so I asked him if he had won the lottery. He said no and volunteered to show me what he was doing so we went below where I found myself wading through wood shavings. Wood carving tools were scattered round as were what looked like wooden masks with intricate gold inlays; they looked sort of Japanese with black lacquer and gold. He told me that he had carved one and sold it in New Orleans (something to do with Mardi Gras and Voodoo etc.)and since then had so many orders he couldnt fill them all and that he didnt even begin working on one till he was paid several thousand dollars for it. I never saw him again after that but I always think of him as what a successful cruiser should be. |
|
|
wrote:
Although casting off everyday cares to go cruising sounds ideal to many people, I have to wonder about people aspire to it with intense zeal. I wonder if they have so little to offer to humanity that they would abandon society for such a narcissistic goal. If you spend all of your time cruising, you essentially give up making any difference to the rest of humanity ... I think you are going to have more luck wrestling with this issue if you base your research on the experiences people who _are_ (or who have, for a considerable period of time, been) cruising, rather than people who merely aspire to it. Further, by "cruising" I don't necessarily mean wandering from mud flat to mud flat in the Panhandle. ... I have no problem with people who retire and then go cruising, they have already made their contribution ... Frankly there are so many untested assumptions in this statement that it's difficult to formulate a cogent response. I personally know quite a few who retired "contribution-free," as it were. Or were you referring primarily to Social Security contributions? -- Good luck and good sailing. s/v Kerry Deare of Barnegat http://kerrydeare.home.comcast.net/ |
If money was a major concern, I'd work for somebody else instead of
being self (un)employed. As far as wandering from mud flat to mud flat, I find the mud flats to be the most interesting places on the water. Actually, the salt marshes are the most interesting. The open water is essentially a desert while the salt marshes are the most food productive parts of the ocean. I bet I can find more cool stuff in a salt marsh than you can in the open water (Look honey, Another wave). I have no problem with people eventually retiring whether or not they make what they consider to be a "contribution". Giving it a good try is what is important. As far as using people who really do cruise for answers, isnt that why I asked here? |
|
|
|
I admit that some people who cruise can benefit others by their
example, this is part of the reason why I consider my friend Jack to be a successful cruiser. I also agree that most people do not have the luxury of considering if their lives have been a "contribution". However, many people do consider their kids to be a legacy (a contribution of sorts) and this may be the best they can do. Believing that you can make a "contribution" may be self indulgent but it seems to be a positive form. I still think a person should try to make a positive impact before they simply drop out. Do you think the work you did before you retired was worthless? If so, maybe you should consider repaying those who paid you. Didn't there used to be a saying during WW2 (well before my time) "They also serve who stand and wait". Reasons why I consider my friend Jack to be successful. 1. He got himself out of his previous dependent lifestyle. 2. This in itself is an inspiration. 3. All the travel he did with limited resources shows the rest of us what can be done (an inspiration). 4. His carvings were not fakes but were recognized as being made by him. These were serious works of art that stopped me in my tracks in admiration. I do admire home craft people just as I admire most small business people. |
Capt. Neal® wrote:
snip... To shed some light on why I, Capt. Neal, retired early and went cruising, let me say it was simply because I figured that which I knew and that which I aspired to was well-beyond the capability of all but a few like me who actually enjoyed being highly educated and loved using a superior brain to ruminate on the sad condition of the remainder of humanity. Peggy...this is very hard to resist..... ;-) |
wrote in message
oups.com... My annoyance with that silly Mark Twain quote prompts this post. (and) Now, I have seen enough of this silly Twain quote. In twenty years, you will regret the things you did not do even if you do go cruising. If you go cruising, it keeps you from doing other things. More below, but... Herewith, for the next while at least, is my old sig, before I was busy contemplating casting off the bowlines. Longtimers here will recall it :{)) Hope you get your offspring straightened out and actually get to leave sometime... -- Morgan 461 #2 SV Flying Pig http://tinyurl.com/384p2 The Society for the Preservation of Tithesis commends your ebriated and scrutible use of delible and defatigable, which are gainly, sipid and couth. We are gruntled and consolate that you have the ertia and eptitude to choose such putably pensible tithesis, which we parage. Stamp out Sesquipedalianism Although casting off everyday cares to go cruising sounds ideal to many people, I have to wonder about people aspire to it with intense zeal. I wonder if they have so little to offer to humanity that they would abandon society for such a narcissistic goal. If you spend all of your time cruising, you essentially give up making any difference to the rest of humanity. My personal belief ("belief" means I have no proof or even a good argument for it) is that each of us has some unique skill that could somehow be of use to humanity. Your apparent intelligence from other posts (as compared to Neal's constant nose tweaking disguising, rather than enhancing his various values) suggest you know very well what the quote's about. It's not about cruising (yes, I know you were looking for information about why people cruise). It's about not sticking in a rut. The sailing analogy was appropriate to his interests, but didn't require everyone of the time - then or now - to go off and cruise. And, unless I'm totally unusual, and the folks I read about or talk to in the SSCA (the real cruisers, as to be a Commodore you've had to lived aboard for quite a while) and other active cruisers in my various travels and internet contacts are (unusual) as well, casting off everyday cares has little or nothing to do with it. Instead, it's how they choose to spend their lives, or a portion of them, at least. Why does someone hike, let alone climb Killamanjaro? Why does someone wilderness camp? Why does *anyone* go to Disneyland? Because that's what they want to do with their time and money at the time. Last I heard, you wanted to cruise, too. Why did you want to do that? Especially with a punk? (Sorry - I've had 4, and so has Lydia. That makes 8 exposures to punk or saint potentials. Her eldest has been busted for running Ecstacy from France, and her youngest has spent time in slam for underage drinking, so I'm not taking pot (excuse the expression) shots. I know a punk when I see one. Fortunately, they don't have to stay punks all their lives, and hers haven't, either. I didn't belittle that (your desire, much frustrated, to cruise). Unfortunately, very few people ever discover this skill (a topic that I spend hours discussing with my unhappy state worker neighbor)but I think you ought to give it many real tries before giving up and going off cruising. Giving *what* many real tries? Doing something you hate, earning just enough to survive to get up and do it again the next day? Not everyone (yes, there are many, but they are in the miniscule minority) has an income-production activity which so captivates them that they hate to quit doing it - even to the point, sometimes of eating, let alone departing the "rat race". Your situation isn't unique, but pretty close. Good on you for having something you hate to leave. But don't **** on those who chose to do something else. I have no problem with people who retire and then go cruising, they have already made their contribution. My argument is with people who aspire to cruising as their life goal. I've not seen why, yet. WTFC what someone wants to do with their life goal? I know a few masters and doctoral earners who basically subsistence survive (in a variety of circumstances, none cruisers). Did they aspire to that when they spent all that time and money getting all those letters after their names? Doubtful, but, as the saying goes, whatever floats your boat (with apologies to the premise that somehow cruising is "bad" as it's not about boats, but what gives one comfort or joy). The most interesting and to my mind the most successful cruising person I have ever seen was when I had my old 23' boat docked waaaaaay up the Carabelle River at a place for $20/month. The boat next to mine was a trashed out 21' Venture. One day, its hatch was open and a voice invited me aboard and when I stepped into the cabin, I stepped into water 1" deep. In the gloom I saw huge cans of green beans labelled Department of Agriculture that i recognized as early 60s cast-offs from fallout shelters in Tallahassee (this was 1988). The Master and Commander of this odd vessel was named Jack who told me that until 6 months ago he had been a homeless drunk but he had somehow been given a check for $500 that he used to buy this floating (sort-of) home of his on a whim. I never learned the rest of his story but clearly he had an interesting life as he had only one ear, half of his left hand, something wrong with one eye and other physical markings of a less than normal suburban existence. Jack had a black mongrel dog named "Crow" that perfectly matched him as it was missing a front paw and its lower jaw was bent at a strange angle to the rest of its head from being run over. And your point about Jack and Crow is? Jack sailed this amazing little boat with duct tape repaired sails all over the northern gulf from Cedar Key all the way over to (this is almost unbelievable) New Orleans. I'd run into him at odd places and he could describe the channels of all the cool places I wanted to visit that also did not have marked channels. One day, I ran into Jack on a brand new top-of-the-line boat ( I cannot remember the brand) so I asked him if he had won the lottery. He said no and volunteered to show me what he was doing so we went below where I found myself wading through wood shavings. Wood carving tools were scattered round as were what looked like wooden masks with intricate gold inlays; they looked sort of Japanese with black lacquer and gold. He told me that he had carved one and sold it in New Orleans (something to do with Mardi Gras and Voodoo etc.)and since then had so many orders he couldnt fill them all and that he didnt even begin working on one till he was paid several thousand dollars for it. I never saw him again after that but I always think of him as what a successful cruiser should be. And, this has what to do with "Why cruise?"? And why does someone who happened to fall into something that they loved doing (which happens to be profitable) *while living on a boat* make him better than his doing the same thing ashore but wanting to hit the high seas, but not having a boat on which to do it? Sorry, I'm a bit grumpy today, having dealt with an automotive repair person I had to tell how to do their work, an ear with a hole in it (again), stopped up Eustachians so all I hear is tinnitius, trying to arrange flights from UK for Lydia's mother who'll help on the boat for 5 weeks before I go get cut again (so I can raise my arm), all before noon. And, we're going, not because we're retiring, though it looks like that. It's because that's what we want to do. We'll be working during the high season and cruising the rest, because our savings and investments (Social Security is a long way off) won't allow us the luxury to just cruise. Even if it were, likely we'd be involved in something productive, helping out in the areas we visited, just cuz we're like that. So, for us, "Why Cruise?" is "Why Not?" - and because that's what we want to do. We want to see and learn new cultures, test ourselves against nature, find our own food where and when we can, and leave a clean wake (SSCA motto) wherever we go. HTH... L8R Skip - home briefly before a 4-week liveaboard-on-the-hard/workaboard trip and Lydia - still home, trying to build the kitty, refitting as fast as we can -- Morgan 461 #2 SV Flying Pig http://tinyurl.com/384p2 "Twenty years from now you will be more disappointed by the things you didn't do than by the ones you did do. So throw off the bowlines. Sail away from the safe harbor. Catch the trade winds in your sails. Explore. Dream. Discover." - Mark Twain (sorry, couldn't resist :{)) - you can always stop reading at "Morgan 461 #2, to save yourself!) |
Don White wrote:
Capt. Neal® wrote: snip... To shed some light on why I, Capt. Neal, retired early and went cruising, let me say it was simply because I figured that which I knew and that which I aspired to was well-beyond the capability of all but a few like me who actually enjoyed being highly educated and loved using a superior brain to ruminate on the sad condition of the remainder of humanity. Peggy...this is very hard to resist..... ;-) There are but two possibilities: 1) In "real life" Neal is an absolute coward, terrified of others and therefore keeps his foul mouth shut. 2) In "real life" Neal gets punched in his foul mouth on a regular (perhaps daily) basis. |
"Skip Gundlach" wrote in message ... snipped a priori pabulum Morgan 461 #2 SV Flying Pig http://tinyurl.com/384p2 Way too much clutter on that foredeck. . . CN |
In article .com,
wrote: My annoyance with that silly Mark Twain quote prompts this post. Although casting off everyday cares to go cruising sounds ideal to many people, I have to wonder about people aspire to it with intense zeal. I wonder if they have so little to offer to humanity that they would abandon society for such a narcissistic goal. They aren't abandoning humanity or society. The cruising community is its own society: different, but not nothing. I could easily argue that it's a more humane society than what we see on shore. From what I've seen, cruisers tend to contribute more to the communities they find themselves in than most people could comprehend. As a minor item: When I'm travelling back and forth to work each workday, I'm usually too "busy" to help stranded motorists on the side of the road. When we're cruising, we go investigate boats that might be broken down and help one or two a season. Stories of cruisers helping the disadvantaged that they contact are legion. And I find most people in the workaday world have narcissistic goals, though they're expressed in socially acceptable terms. Most are basically drifting on autopilot, and very *BUSY* doing it. If you spend all of your time cruising, you essentially give up making any difference to the rest of humanity. Not true. My personal belief is that each of us has some unique skill that could somehow be of use to humanity. Unfortunately, very few people ever discover this skill, but I think you ought to give it many real tries before giving up and going off cruising. Most people don't have unique skills. They're essentially cogs in the wheel throughout their lives. That said, I know I have a few unique skills that I've utilized successfully over the years, whether I've been paid for them or not. I can point to a few people who changed careers to match their real abilities due to my input. But that was "luck". I get paid to utilize other of my skills to allow people to do their jobs more easily, but when push comes to shove, I wonder whether their jobs are really worth doing in the first place. I understand your viewpoint, but you're assuming others have your ability level, and that's not true from what I've seen you post. I have no problem with people who retire and then go cruising, they have already made their contribution. My argument is with people who aspire to cruising as their life goal. That's assuming that retirement, or cruising, is the end of contribution to society. I find that's not true. ----- One part of our considerations is that we tread quite a bit more softly upon the Earth in our boat than we do in our relatively modest house. Treading more softly would be a considerable accomplishment in my mind. ----- BUT what's wrong with our deciding that we've contributed enough to society if we can maintain our desired lifestyle with our available resources? -- Jere Lull Xan-a-Deux ('73 Tanzer 28 #4 out of Tolchester, MD) Xan's Pages: http://members.dca.net/jerelull/X-Main.html Our BVI FAQs (290+ pics) http://homepage.mac.com/jerelull/BVI/ |
All times are GMT +1. The time now is 06:32 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com