BoatBanter.com

BoatBanter.com (https://www.boatbanter.com/)
-   Cruising (https://www.boatbanter.com/cruising/)
-   -   Project for Larry (https://www.boatbanter.com/cruising/102142-project-larry.html)

Capt.Bill January 31st 09 04:39 PM

Project for Larry
 
Hey Larry, how up are you on 3 phase motors and controls?

A captain acquaintance of mine is having a bit of trouble with the bow
thruster system on a boat he has taken over in the Bahamas. Perhaps
you could be of help if you so choose.

http://www.yachtforums.com/forums/te...ase-motor.html

Marty[_2_] February 1st 09 03:29 AM

Project for Larry
 
Capt.Bill wrote:
Hey Larry, how up are you on 3 phase motors and controls?

A captain acquaintance of mine is having a bit of trouble with the bow
thruster system on a boat he has taken over in the Bahamas. Perhaps
you could be of help if you so choose.

http://www.yachtforums.com/forums/te...ase-motor.html


Holy crap! Looking at the images, all I can say is "What a cluster ****".


Good Luck, best advice in that forum, "rip it all out, start again and
KISS"

Cheers
Martin

Brian Whatcott February 1st 09 03:54 AM

Project for Larry
 
Capt.Bill wrote:
Hey Larry, how up are you on 3 phase motors and controls?

A captain acquaintance of mine is having a bit of trouble with the bow
thruster system on a boat he has taken over in the Bahamas. Perhaps
you could be of help if you so choose.

http://www.yachtforums.com/forums/te...ase-motor.html


Marmoz seems to have provided as good support as could be expected by
remote control from someone who does not have access to the wiring
diagram for his installation. If the components were all identified,
or even a circuit diagram found, then there are people who could help,
I feel sure. This is one step beyond what a small boat electrician
would feel comfortable with.

Brian W

Larry February 1st 09 06:03 AM

Project for Larry
 

Capt.Bill wrote:
Hey Larry, how up are you on 3 phase motors and controls?

A captain acquaintance of mine is having a bit of trouble with the
bow thruster system on a boat he has taken over in the Bahamas.
Perhaps you could be of help if you so choose.

http://www.yachtforums.com/forums/te...on/10616-roto-

phas
e-motor.html



This boat needs an AMERICAN shipyard with skilled technicians on that,
obviously, old system that looks kluged up to some new conversion.

My guess from what little is showing is it had a mechanical phase
converter to give the 3-phase motors on the thrusters old-fashioned 3-
phase motor speed control. Someone has changed that old system to a
newer solid state (see the new control box?) phase rotator to drive the
motors.

Of course, no documentation was ever done to DIAGRAM what was done to
it, as is just normal on 95% of the yachts at any dock. So, noone
knows, for sure, what was done and must start from scratch, read that
many BILLABLE man-hours that could have been saved by paying the
installer some manhours to document what was done long ago.

From the look of its older parts, it's replacement time, anyways, and
denial will simply extend the inevitable replacement time. New systems
with switching motor speed controllers and motors made to run from them
solve the problem.......er, ah....until that breaks, when the cycle
repeats.

Sorry, I can't help you from the pictures. Looks like a great
challenge, though. I fixed a motor-alternator set on an old yacht that
didn't work. It converted the 32VDC battery beasts to 115/230 2-phase
60 Hz long before today's highly efficient, powerful digital switching
AC inverters were invented. Besides the bad bearing a motor rewind shop
replaced for us, I had the original drawings and simply replaced the
rotten wiring and corrected 25 years of misconnections with the original
installation. It was actually quite quiet, considering it was running
at 1800 RPM to get 60 Hz all the time. By today's standards, the idle
32V at 2.8A wasn't very efficient, but this was a dual engine motoryacht
with FOUR 32v alternators running off two big v-belts, not a sailboat on
boat batteries, so it wasn't an issue. Keeping the beer cold in the big
GE refridgerator-side-by-side-freezer was. The look on his face when
those AC lights came on by pressing the red button at the helm was quite
PRICELESS....

The alternator could put out 6.5 KVA very smoothly.

He needs a good yard to replace it with a modern system......if he must
have it.


Capt.Bill February 1st 09 05:01 PM

Project for Larry
 
On Feb 1, 1:03*am, Larry wrote:
Capt.Bill wrote:
Hey Larry, how up are you on 3 phase motors and controls?


A captain acquaintance of mine is having a bit of trouble with the
bow thruster system on a boat he has taken over in the Bahamas.
Perhaps you could be of help if you so choose.


http://www.yachtforums.com/forums/te...on/10616-roto-

phas
e-motor.html


This boat needs an AMERICAN shipyard with skilled technicians on that,
obviously, old system that looks kluged up to some new conversion.

My guess from what little is showing is it had a mechanical phase
converter to give the 3-phase motors on the thrusters old-fashioned 3-
phase motor speed control. *Someone has changed that old system to a
newer solid state (see the new control box?) phase rotator to drive the
motors.

Of course, no documentation was ever done to DIAGRAM what was done to
it, as is just normal on 95% of the yachts at any dock. *So, noone
knows, for sure, what was done and must start from scratch, read that
many BILLABLE man-hours that could have been saved by paying the
installer some manhours to document what was done long ago.

From the look of its older parts, it's replacement time, anyways, and
denial will simply extend the inevitable replacement time. *New systems
with switching motor speed controllers and motors made to run from them
solve the problem.......er, ah....until that breaks, when the cycle
repeats.

Sorry, I can't help you from the pictures. *Looks like a great
challenge, though. *I fixed a motor-alternator set on an old yacht that
didn't work. *It converted the 32VDC battery beasts to 115/230 2-phase
60 Hz long before today's highly efficient, powerful digital switching
AC inverters were invented. *Besides the bad bearing a motor rewind shop
replaced for us, I had the original drawings and simply replaced the
rotten wiring and corrected 25 years of misconnections with the original
installation. *It was actually quite quiet, considering it was running
at 1800 RPM to get 60 Hz all the time. *By today's standards, the idle
32V at 2.8A wasn't very efficient, but this was a dual engine motoryacht
with FOUR 32v alternators running off two big v-belts, not a sailboat on
boat batteries, so it wasn't an issue. *Keeping the beer cold in the big
GE refridgerator-side-by-side-freezer was. *The look on his face when
those AC lights came on by pressing the red button at the helm was quite
PRICELESS....

The alternator could put out 6.5 KVA very smoothly.

He needs a good yard to replace it with a modern system......if he must
have it.


Thanks. He does have some diagrams and is trying to get them scanned
in. If he does I'll post a link so you can see them.

But I agree with you and have told him I think it's better to **** can
that mess and replace it than waste time and his owners money trying
to fix it.



Capt. Bill


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:37 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com