Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#7
![]()
posted to rec.boats.cruising,rec.boats.building
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Following up my own post to integrate responses so far (thanks very
much, y'all!)... Skip Gundlach wrote: So, we're floating, again, and letting the hull settle into its water configuration, having been out for more that 2.5 years, before we start tweaking. DSK and KLC chimed in: Hmm, when you say "settle into the water," what do you mean? For the planks to swell & close up the seams? A fiberglass boat should have exactly zero "settling" to do. Not really true. Even the best cradle puts different pressures on the hull than does the water, and Essie always "settles in" to the water as Skip referenced. Mostly this isn't much, no more than a fraction of a fraction of an inch athwartships -- but the companionway door always loosens up after a few weeks in the water, where the cradle had "pinched" it tighter. The shrouds also tend to be marginally looser the first few weeks than after "settling." That's interesting - perhaps it'll tighten up as I wait... About interior fittings' alignment - the differences there have been immediately apparent (stuff which used to bind on land doesn't, and a couple of vice-versas). Several of our yard mates have had notable differences in their hull shapes from being on the hard. One boat, with two intermediate bearings, had the shaft alignment more than an inch out from what it was when he came in (corrected by judicious jacking of the [full] keel at various points in addition to the yard's insufficient number of supports). Of the several power folks I've spoken with, there was unanimity that I should wait (varying from a week to a month, with a couple of weeks being a consensus of adequacy) for the hull to stabilize before trying to realign the propshaft. (To the engine.) One particularly astute (to my mind, anyway) fellow suggested I needed to tune the rig before attempting alignment, as well. Either way, the engine and fuel issues aren't finished, so we couldn't fire it up yet, anyway. (I'm installing a fuel polishing system, plus going to dual Racor 500 - thanks for all the current discussion in the Island Packet Sailnet list about filters, saving me headaches on refills! - as well as replacing all the supply and return lines. That's after I get the oil filter remotely mounted, the water pump bracket installed and the new pulley on the pump to match the engine pulley, and a few other minor chores...) Thus, the hull will have attained its 'normal' shape before we get to that. (me again) I want to tune the rig before we start sailing, and currently all the shrouds and intermediates save one seem very loose by hand. Regardless, they're probably not set correctly. Once the hull's settled in, I expect that a Loos gauge is the way to go to see the right setup. I have two questions: First, is it worth the investment to buy one? I'm not a racer, nor will I ever be. But I expect that a properly tuned rig will be kinder to the boat, in any event. Is this something which I'd use frequently or something better done by paying a rigger (the largest tool is what our boat needs - it's 180 at list) on the occasions when I thought I needed it? Comments included: Personally, I don't think that matters. If you want to be able to set up your rig (or a friend's) properly *and* (here's the key part) be able to do it the same every time, then a Loos gauge is the best tool for it. There are other ways of judging tension, in fact you can home-brew a tension gage. But it will cost more in time and be less accurate. OTOH you can borrow one, or jury-rig a tension gauge that's good enough. and: You're going to be surprised how tight you want to get those stays (although there will be even more tension when you're sailing). To my mind, the cost of a good rigger is one of the best "deals" left in sailing. In a couple of hours they can check and "cruising" tune your rig - tuning a racing boat is more involved. You'll greatly decrease the odds of catastrophic rig failure on your first gusty day and probably have a substantially faster boat upwind. and: I second that advice. A good professional rigger will get the jobdone much more quickly and accurately.Dismastings are a *very* expensive repair. and: Ya think ![]() Once the hull's settled in, I expect that a Loos gauge is the way to go to see the right setup. and: Depends partly on your rig & partly on your goals. It'sprobably cheaper to pay a rigger, especially if you have multiple spreaders. and: "Proper tension" depends on who you ask. The minimum should be 10% of the wire's limit (termed "working load"). Setting up a cruiser's mast should be quite simple. The goal is to get the mast standing up & keep it there! It's surprising how few people pay any attention to this. http://www.sailingsource.com/neilpry...al/rigtune.htm http://hallspars.com/Resources/Articles/rigtune.htm Start off with all standing rigging slightly loose to the hand. Use either a plumb bob (which I don't like, since it can be misleading) or a protractor from 'way back on shore to measure the RAKE of the mast. This is how much it leans aft. You want enough to get a good helm balance when the boat is powered up under sail. Too much weather helm means too much rake (ie leaned too far aft). This is adjusted at the forestay (looser = more rake). Now get the mast straight up & down athwartship. You'd be amazed how many boats are sailing around with their mast leaning to one side or the other. The lower shrouds should be loose, uppers barely taut. Put a tape measure on the main halyard and make a measurement to a good marking point which can be definitely the same on both sides, say for example to the gun'l right at the chainplates. It almost certainly won't be the same on both sides unless you are very lucky. Adjust only the upper shrouds until it is the same on both sides, then tighten the upper shrouds to the minimum, counting the turns on each turnbuckle & keeping them the same, then lock them. Now, sight up the mast track. It should be perfectly straight all the way up. If not, tighten the lower on the side that it bends away from. When the mast is raked properly, centered, and straight (termed "in column"); and all the shrouds are set up to their minimum tension, you can go sailing. You will want to tighten the uppers enough to keep the lee shrouds from going slack (assuming your hull is strong & rigid enough), and the lowers enough to keep it in column. You will also want to adjust the lowers such that when you tighten the backstay, you get a little curve aft in the mast. This does two things, it controls sail shape and it prevents the mast from pumping (alternately bowing one way then the other as the boat goes over waves). Remember to always adjust the shrouds in pairs, keeping the same number of turns on each side. And don't overdo it, remember the mast & rig is like an enormous bow & arrow that you do *not* want to shoot! And that's it. Many fairly successful racers do less. and: A Loos gauge may be useful as a final check, but you will probably need the large one. For a cruising boat with masthead rig, you need to first of all decide how much rake you need. This is usually not known, but if boat has weather helm, mast should be close to vertical and forward in base, if it can be adjusted. If it has lee helm, mast base should be further aft and mast should be raked more. For a start, I would put mast base in centre position and rake top of mast about 1 mast diameter by adjusting forestay/backstay accordingly - use rigging links if forestay has non-adjustable furling. Uppers, backstay & forestay should be made about hand tight - Not so tight so as to bend mast (use main halyard or topping lift pulled tight to gooseneck and sight up mast track to check for straightness) Uppers should then be adjusted so that top of mast is centred athwartships. Use the main halyard and distance from top of mast to toerail is equal on each side. Then take up on lowers and adjust them so mast is kept straight - Keep double checking by sighting up mast track. Once everything looks good, take up a few turns starting with uppers, then backstay/forestay then lowers and check and adjust again for straightness. Exact tension is not important, but stays should be tight enough to go sailing. Loos have a guide to the tension needed by wire size in this link: http://www.saltyjohn.co.uk/resources...the%20Loos.pdf Go sailing in about 10-12 knots and watch rig. Leeward uppers and lowers should not be loose. As wind increases, some "loos"ness should develop at say 15-20 knots. A backstay adjuster that can relieve forestay/backstay tension at dock is a good idea - otherwise boat needs to be stiff and not deform under the constant load. ----- Lots of great info there, and likewise very helpful links. Thanks so much to all for those. Given the purely cruising nature of our boat, we don't have adjusters nor running backs - though, given the added inner forestay, it might have been a good idea. So, the rig will remain tensioned and static, other than the occasional times we might pull the inner off to the side (removable fitting), which I presume would change the shape of the mast slightly. One minor question, which seems counter-intuitive to me: Pulling the lowers to as to bow the mast AFT. Why is that? If any curve, I would think it should be forward... Coincidentally, I was talking yesterday with one of the yard guys who previously was the head rigger at Catalina. He essentially echoed the above comments about alignment, but said that once snug and firm, a couple of full turns on each of the turnbuckles would be about right. He also commented that a Loos gauge was mostly a racer's tool, as it allowed a crew to quickly duplicate a setting they previously found to work to their satisfaction. He also suggested that if one were to truly do it right, those weren't nearly accurate enough. He went on to say that for our purposes, however, all the above suggestions were ample. As to hiring a rigger, vs the cost of the tool, at the largest (what we'd need), it's only (everything's relative - it would be one of the smaller costs in this refit) $180 at list, less in a variety of available sources, so by comparison to a rigger, should we do this with any frequency, probably a bargain. OTOH, as pointed out, a dismasting is an expensive luxury from a poorly received bargain! However... As we sailed it over, in mostly very heavy weather, it balanced very nicely, so I presume the rake is about right. Until we played with it in nearly 30k, pinching tighter and tighter, making it heel substantially, we had no weather helm nor lee helm we could discern. So, I'm pretty comfortable about the angle of the mast. Ours is a single-spreader rig, so it's a little less challenging than some might be. As we get close to the time of sea trials, we'll loosen the shrouds and do the adjustments recommended. Once we get to sailing, we'll check out the lee cables. If they are slack under any but very substantial loads, we'll take up some more on the tension, duplicating the turns on each side, but still checking for straight line in column. Thanks again for the knowledgeable input, and the links. I'll spend some quality time with all the info points before we start at it. And, I think, from all here and my local contact, that a Loos isn't something we need aboard... L8R Skip and Lydia, deeper in the water than we thought possible! (Heavy, Dude!) |