Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
posted to rec.boats.building
|
|||
|
|||
Hydraulic drive experiences
Hi, Steve
Thanks for your reply. Yes, the energy loss is certainly a factor - weight is not as much a factor, since I have to add 1« ton of ballast anyway(closed up pond). Cooling... I have access to stainless heat exchangers at a very good price. As for the electrical drive - I know that it has a lower energy loss, but the idea of so much stuff that can short out in my engine room is not appealing until I have mre knowledge of the equipment's degree of protection. The hydraulics OTOH can operate if partly submerged - as long as the diesel can draw breath :-) So I speculate on - trying to calculate heat loss right now. I'd rather be sailing.... Ole Ole, I have considered this before and rejected it because of excessive weight, very high cost and very poor efficiency. Consider the size and weight of the hydraulics rated for 130 HP. Consider the amount of heat generated in the hydraulic oil in comparison to a conventional gear. (lost energy) Now, do a cost comparison. I think you will end up making the same decision. All other concerns like speed and torque are simply hydraulic configuration issues and are easily resolved. Now, electric, propulsion. There you have serious possibilities. Steve |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Hydraulic pump/motor Question | Electronics | |||
Hydraulic pump/motor Question | General | |||
Hydraulic pump/motor Question | Boat Building |