![]() |
Fractional sailing?
Greetings all,
Pardon me if this has been discussed before but I am new to the group. Has anyone had experience with what seems essentially to be a boat time-share lease, i.e. sharing the use of a boat with several other people, but never owning it? I was perusing boat ads the other day and ran across one such outfit and it seemed like a good deal, which immediately made me suspicious. Anyone here ever tried this type of thing? Thanks, Steve |
Fractional sailing?
On Sep 28, 9:36 pm, "Steve" wrote:
Greetings all, Pardon me if this has been discussed before but I am new to the group. Has anyone had experience with what seems essentially to be a boat time-share lease, i.e. sharing the use of a boat with several other people, but never owning it? I was perusing boat ads the other day and ran across one such outfit and it seemed like a good deal, which immediately made me suspicious. Anyone here ever tried this type of thing? Thanks, Steve Hi Steve, I think it is rediculous. You have a yacht in Greece and someone else has a boat in Uk etc. So you can choose from a list where you wanto go every year. I wouldnt like someone using my yacht! It like timesharing. Stelios www.sig.gr |
Fractional sailing?
"Steve" wrote:
Greetings all, Pardon me if this has been discussed before but I am new to the group. Has anyone had experience with what seems essentially to be a boat time-share lease, i.e. sharing the use of a boat with several other people, but never owning it? I was perusing boat ads the other day and ran across one such outfit and it seemed like a good deal, which immediately made me suspicious. Anyone here ever tried this type of thing? Several, I think. I've owned boats in partenrship, and it is not suited to my personality. Part of it is the inevitable bickering over maintenance exenses, which made me want to just smack them over the head... we did not have any repair issues, thank goodness, that can be even thornier. Just let me say: Buy a small boat you can afford rather than ruining a friendship going in partners on a big one... or, if you must have a big boat, go in partners with somebody you hate already. Places like J-World or Club Nautique can also be a pretty good deal, but part of what you pay for is professional management of the boat(s) and expenses, and you have a limited range of options for use. Still, it's much cheaper per-hour than owning one of the boats yourself.... unless you really have good maintenance skills and use the boat a lot. Walking around almost any marina or sailing club, you'll see millions of dollars sitting idle 99.99% of the time. Fresh Breezes- Doug King |
Fractional sailing?
On Sep 28, 9:47 pm, wrote:
"Steve" wrote: Greetings all, Pardon me if this has been discussed before but I am new to the group. Has anyone had experience with what seems essentially to be a boat time-share lease, i.e. sharing the use of a boat with several other people, but never owning it? I was perusing boat ads the other day and ran across one such outfit and it seemed like a good deal, which immediately made me suspicious. Anyone here ever tried this type of thing? Several, I think. I've owned boats in partenrship, and it is not suited to my personality. Part of it is the inevitable bickering over maintenance exenses, which made me want to just smack them over the head... we did not have any repair issues, thank goodness, that can be even thornier. Just let me say: Buy a small boat you can afford rather than ruining a friendship going in partners on a big one... or, if you must have a big boat, go in partners with somebody you hate already. Places like J-World or Club Nautique can also be a pretty good deal, but part of what you pay for is professional management of the boat(s) and expenses, and you have a limited range of options for use. Still, it's much cheaper per-hour than owning one of the boats yourself.... unless you really have good maintenance skills and use the boat a lot. Walking around almost any marina or sailing club, you'll see millions of dollars sitting idle 99.99% of the time. Fresh Breezes- Doug King Doug: Your last sentence says a lot. Not being used seems to be worse for a boat than moderate use. So, how to address this problem? For a cruising boat, I cannot think of a way but for racing boats a racing club might be the way. |
Fractional sailing?
wrote in message ps.com... "Steve" wrote: Greetings all, Pardon me if this has been discussed before but I am new to the group. Has anyone had experience with what seems essentially to be a boat time-share lease, i.e. sharing the use of a boat with several other people, but never owning it? I was perusing boat ads the other day and ran across one such outfit and it seemed like a good deal, which immediately made me suspicious. Anyone here ever tried this type of thing? Several, I think. I've owned boats in partenrship, and it is not suited to my personality. Part of it is the inevitable bickering over maintenance exenses, which made me want to just smack them over the head... we did not have any repair issues, thank goodness, that can be even thornier. Just let me say: Buy a small boat you can afford rather than ruining a friendship going in partners on a big one... or, if you must have a big boat, go in partners with somebody you hate already. Places like J-World or Club Nautique can also be a pretty good deal, but part of what you pay for is professional management of the boat(s) and expenses, and you have a limited range of options for use. Still, it's much cheaper per-hour than owning one of the boats yourself.... unless you really have good maintenance skills and use the boat a lot. Walking around almost any marina or sailing club, you'll see millions of dollars sitting idle 99.99% of the time. Fresh Breezes- Doug King I agree with all that Doug has said, but you also have to consider that there is always the possibility that the another guy who shares the boat and had it out just before you will find himself unable to get back at the end of his time because either he went too far downwind or else the weather went against him on his way back. So you arrive to pick the boat up when it is your turn and you find it is not there waiting for you Big difference from a timeshare property! Also consider that it is likely to be very hard to sell your share when you are tired of the deal. Take Doug's advice and buy a boat you can afford and can sell when you want to trade up. |
Fractional sailing?
I've owned boats in partenrship, and it is not suited to my
personality. Part of it is the inevitable bickering over maintenance I owned my fist boat in partnership and had no problems. Of course Doug did since he's an asshole. Two or more affable sailors can certainly own a boat together and I know more than a few that do this. Owning a 40 foot boat with a partner or two MIGHT be more rewarding than owning a 28 foot boat on your own, but that depends on your requirements and expectations. Cheers, RB 35s5 NY |
Fractional sailing?
Walking around almost any marina or sailing club, you'll see millions
of dollars sitting idle 99.99% of the time. Frogwatch wrote: Your last sentence says a lot. Not being used seems to be worse for a boat than moderate use. That seems true from what I've seen. What's worse, the owners of boats that sit for years tend to think of the boat as being still spanking new, so when they do show up for that once-in-three-years sail (and I'm not kidding) they get into trouble with engine problems, dead batteries, sun-rotted gear, etc etc. .... So, how to address this problem? For a cruising boat, I cannot think of a way but for racing boats a racing club might be the way. For racing, one way is to have fleet-owned one design boats. Buy in at the crew level, a higher buy-in for skippers; mandatory maintenance hours or a fee that will more than cover needed work (most people would rather pay, so you have to make the fee at least slightly punitive). There are actually a number of clubs that do this around the Chesapeake; don't know about other areas. For cruising, the answer is to use the boat a lot. Mulitple benefits... you don't have a lot of capital lying idle, you learn the ins & outs of the boat, you have more fun. "Edgar" wrote: ..... you also have to consider that there is always the possibility that the another guy who shares the boat and had it out just before you will find himself unable to get back at the end of his time because either he went too far downwind or else the weather went against him on his way back. So you arrive to pick the boat up when it is your turn and you find it is not there waiting for you Big difference from a timeshare property! Or one of the partners has damaged the boat and not fixed it because he didn't notice, or didn't know how, or "didn't have time". Never happened to us but is common. Some friends of ours who owned a nice 37- footer in partnership had the partners' family leave the head valves open, so the boat flooded with a skim nice fresh potty-flush floating on top. That one ended up in court as they argued about not only who was supposed to pay for totally stripping & cleaning the inside of boat, replacing cushions, etc etc. That one *really* ruined a friendship and a family relationship as well. The boats I owned in partnership were all racers and the partners were quite good sailors. We had quite an extenensive & effective agreement, for example we agreed to flip a coin before every race to determine who would skipper. We also had to kick in a fixed amount monthly above expenses, so that money was always on hand in the "boat fund." It was actually a valuable experience because I got to campaign 2 boats I could not have afforded otherwise and learned first-hand that a hard-racing keelboat is like a cocaine habit, you simply spend as much money as you can lay hands on once it gets hold of you. Also consider that it is likely to be very hard to sell your share when you are tired of the deal. Take Doug's advice and buy a boat you can afford and can sell when you want to trade up. You also won't be caught in a financial trap like all the yuppies currently moaning over their McMansion ARMs. Fresh Breezes- Doug King |
Fractional sailing?
wrote:
The idea that the overwhelming majority of boats never sail is a bunch of baloney. Maybe in the marinas & sailing clubs that you have been to. .... People have different schedules. I'll bet there are people who think my boat never leaves the dock, simply because we have different schedules. And the dockmaster(s) who are there all day, every day? The retired guys who hang out there? You may have a "different schedule" but if there's never anybody else there to see you, then that would tend to prove my point that other boats aren't getting sailed much. Doug is flat out wrong. Occasionally happens, but not this time. Ask any dockmaster or club manager what percent of boats get taken out twice a year or less. DSK |
Fractional sailing?
Doug is flat out wrong.
Occasionally happens, but not this time. Most of the boats, power and sail, at our club see a lot of use. A very few don't. I used to think Doug's comment had some truth to it, but not any more. Once I spent more time at my club I realized that only a few boats sat without use. Of course Doug walks around asking dockmasters about the sailboats that don't sail!!! Anyone believe THAT??? BWAHAHAHHAHAAHA! We sailed today. Doug did not. Doug does not have a sailboat. RB 35s5 NY |
Fractional sailing?
Capt. Rob wrote:
Doug is flat out wrong. Occasionally happens, but not this time. Most of the boats, power and sail, at our club see a lot of use. A very few don't. I used to think Doug's comment had some truth to it, but not any more. Once I spent more time at my club I realized that only a few boats sat without use. Of course Doug walks around asking dockmasters about the sailboats that don't sail!!! Anyone believe THAT??? BWAHAHAHHAHAAHA! We sailed today. Doug did not. Doug does not have a sailboat. RB 35s5 NY Seeing that I sail out of the same marina as Doug, I can verify that. Our dickmaster makes active note of who sails what when where and why and can tell you exactly how many times each boat leaves the dock. He also keeps track of time that each boat leaves, looks out for when you return and is waiting on the dock for you...he is probably one of the most "in the know" guys I have ever seen..he makes it his business to know everything going on in our marina...and there are a lot of boats that never go out...their owners are living way far away and only make it there for long vacations... |
Fractional sailing?
katy wrote:
Capt. Rob wrote: Doug is flat out wrong. Occasionally happens, but not this time. Most of the boats, power and sail, at our club see a lot of use. A very few don't. I used to think Doug's comment had some truth to it, but not any more. Once I spent more time at my club I realized that only a few boats sat without use. Of course Doug walks around asking dockmasters about the sailboats that don't sail!!! Anyone believe THAT??? BWAHAHAHHAHAAHA! We sailed today. Doug did not. Doug does not have a sailboat. RB 35s5 NY Seeing that I sail out of the same marina as Doug, I can verify that. Our dickmaster makes active note of who sails what when where and why and can tell you exactly how many times each boat leaves the dock. He also keeps track of time that each boat leaves, looks out for when you return and is waiting on the dock for you...he is probably one of the most "in the know" guys I have ever seen..he makes it his business to know everything going on in our marina...and there are a lot of boats that never go out...their owners are living way far away and only make it there for long vacations... Lordy...typo...it's is of course, dockmaster...NC has laws against practicing the other... |
Fractional sailing?
Seeing that I sail out of the same marina as Doug, I can verify that.
Our dickmaster Ahhh, I see they finally hired Doug. RB 35s5 NY |
Fractional sailing?
wrote in message ups.com... wrote: The idea that the overwhelming majority of boats never sail is a bunch of baloney. Maybe in the marinas & sailing clubs that you have been to. snip What happened to your Great Loop trip? Can't afford fuel? Engine break? Blisters pop and leak? Wilbur Hubbard |
Fractional sailing?
"Capt. Rob" wrote in message ps.com... Seeing that I sail out of the same marina as Doug, I can verify that. Our dickmaster Dickmaster? Why do you have to gay up every post? Ahhh, I see they finally hired Doug. At least somebody thinks Doug's labor is worth the money. Unlike you, who got fired from that lame sail loft for gross incompetence and for giving their product a bad name so they booted your worthless arse out onto the street . . . Wilbur Hubbard |
Fractional sailing?
wrote:
Doug said 99.9% never get used. I see the problem. You didn't read what I wrote. What I wrote: "Walking around almost any marina or sailing club, you'll see millions of dollars sitting idle 99.99% of the time." DSK |
Fractional sailing?
At least somebody thinks Doug's labor is worth the money. Unlike you,
who got fired from that lame sail loft for gross incompetence and for giving their product a bad name so they booted your worthless arse out onto the street . . . Golly! You mean the two lofts where I sold sails for Hunter 43, Pearson 33, C&C 29, Beneteau 35cc and Cape Dory 26? That's some booting! Ahh...making the sockpuppets dance....good times. RB 35s5 NY |
Fractional sailing?
Doug said 99.9% never get used.
That's Dickmaster math. They're teaching it in all of the new Dickmaster schools these days, but using my slide rule made from whale bone I worked out that sailboats in my club sit idle 37.8% of the time. BTW, Doug sails 0.0 % of the time. He's a powerboater and that's a fact. RB 35s5 NY |
Fractional sailing?
wrote in message ups.com... wrote: The idea that the overwhelming majority of boats never sail is a bunch of baloney. Maybe in the marinas & sailing clubs that you have been to. .... People have different schedules. I'll bet there are people who think my boat never leaves the dock, simply because we have different schedules. And the dockmaster(s) who are there all day, every day? The retired guys who hang out there? You may have a "different schedule" but if there's never anybody else there to see you, then that would tend to prove my point that other boats aren't getting sailed much. Doug is flat out wrong. Occasionally happens, but not this time. Ask any dockmaster or club manager what percent of boats get taken out twice a year or less. talk to the yard apes, they really know the skinny. What Doug said is true. Scotty |
Fractional sailing?
wrote in message ... People have different schedules. I'll bet there are people who think my boat never leaves the dock, simply because we have different schedules. I returned to the slip one Saturday, after a 4 day sail and my 'neighbor' was there and asked, '' you finally going for a sail?''. I answered no, I just got back. Then he said how he's noticed my boat tied up most weekends. I don't like weekends during ''the season'' when all the weekend warrior stink potters are out. Scotty |
Fractional sailing?
"Scotty" wrote:
I returned to the slip one Saturday, after a 4 day sail and my 'neighbor' was there and asked, '' you finally going for a sail?''. I answered no, I just got back. Then he said how he's noticed my boat tied up most weekends. I don't like weekends during ''the season'' when all the weekend warrior stink potters are out. It's true that some have different schedules; but the fact remains that a large number of boats sit unused. If you walk the docks and look around, you can tell a boat that is taken out often and taken care of, albeit in times when there many not be anybody to see, from one that just sits unloved. The New Bern marina dockmaster once said that about 20% of the boats in his marina have never been taken out once during the years they've been parked there. The man in the slip next to us has taken his boat out twice in 4 years, spent more time prepping for hurricanes than he has sailing. It's also true that there are many owners who live far away, one boat is owned from Colorado and the owner goes on a 2 week trip every year and doesn't see the boat otherwise. One reason why there are so many different kinds of boats is that there are so many different kinds of sailors! DSK |
Fractional sailing?
Thanks for all the responses! I think I just need to start calling places
up and get the details on the various plans. I'd love to have my own boat, but it seems like dockage is at a premium. There are plenty of sailing clubs that offer slips to members (Lake Erie) but some of these have long waiting lists and I don't know if it makes sense to buy a boat so I can join a club and then store it while I wait for a slip to open up. Need to do some more digging! Steve |
Fractional sailing?
Steve wrote:
Thanks for all the responses! I think I just need to start calling places up and get the details on the various plans. I'd love to have my own boat, but it seems like dockage is at a premium. There are plenty of sailing clubs that offer slips to members (Lake Erie) but some of these have long waiting lists and I don't know if it makes sense to buy a boat so I can join a club and then store it while I wait for a slip to open up. Need to do some more digging! Steve Get a trailer sailor or find a mooring can... |
Fractional sailing?
"katy" wrote in message ... Get a trailer sailor or find a mooring can... A trailerable boat is out for me as I do a lot of single-hand. I'm not sure I'd feel comfortable storing my boat to a mooring all season! Thanks! |
Fractional sailing?
Steve wrote:
"katy" wrote in message ... Get a trailer sailor or find a mooring can... A trailerable boat is out for me as I do a lot of single-hand. I'm not sure I'd feel comfortable storing my boat to a mooring all season! Thanks! huh? Why wouldn't you be able to singlehand a trailer sailerable boat? We had an O'Day 22 and it was singlehanded all the time by either one of us...and we've had our boat on a mooring...what's the problem with that??? If you're worried about stepping the boat alone, it's really not that difficult when you use a come-along...It's a way to get around the waiting for a slip thing...you put the boat on the mooring and sail off it while waiting for your name to come up on the list...in fact, you will become a better sailor learning to sail on and off a can than you would coming and going from a dock.... |
Fractional sailing?
"katy" wrote in message ... huh? Why wouldn't you be able to singlehand a trailer sailerable boat? We had an O'Day 22 and it was singlehanded all the time by either one of us...and we've had our boat on a mooring...what's the problem with that??? If you're worried about stepping the boat alone, it's really not that difficult when you use a come-along...It's a way to get around the waiting for a slip thing...you put the boat on the mooring and sail off it while waiting for your name to come up on the list...in fact, you will become a better sailor learning to sail on and off a can than you would coming and going from a dock.... My only experience with trailerable boats are the powered variety and that is definitely a two-person operation: one to sit in the boat and pilot it and one to back the trailer down the boat ramp into the water. For the mooring, I guess I didn't realize you could just drop a mooring somewhere offshore and use it indefinitely. Don't you need someone's permission? I've used moorings before but only those off Long Wharf in Boston Harbor and they were maintained by the sailing club. |
Fractional sailing?
"Steve" wrote in message . net... " My only experience with trailerable boats are the powered variety and that is definitely a two-person operation: one to sit in the boat and pilot it and one to back the trailer down the boat ramp into the water. I, along with thousands of other's have launched boats single handed for years. For the mooring, I guess I didn't realize you could just drop a mooring somewhere offshore and use it indefinitely. Don't you need someone's permission? yes, King Neptune's. Scotty |
Fractional sailing?
"Steve" wrote in message t... "katy" wrote in message ... Get a trailer sailor or find a mooring can... A trailerable boat is out for me as I do a lot of single-hand. WTF? |
Fractional sailing?
"Steve" wrote in message
. net... "katy" wrote in message ... huh? Why wouldn't you be able to singlehand a trailer sailerable boat? We had an O'Day 22 and it was singlehanded all the time by either one of us...and we've had our boat on a mooring...what's the problem with that??? If you're worried about stepping the boat alone, it's really not that difficult when you use a come-along...It's a way to get around the waiting for a slip thing...you put the boat on the mooring and sail off it while waiting for your name to come up on the list...in fact, you will become a better sailor learning to sail on and off a can than you would coming and going from a dock.... My only experience with trailerable boats are the powered variety and that is definitely a two-person operation: one to sit in the boat and pilot it and one to back the trailer down the boat ramp into the water. For the mooring, I guess I didn't realize you could just drop a mooring somewhere offshore and use it indefinitely. Don't you need someone's permission? I've used moorings before but only those off Long Wharf in Boston Harbor and they were maintained by the sailing club. Sailing vessels are different from power vessels. I've owned trailer-sailers, and I've sailed with others who own them. They're not particularly difficult to launch/retrieve. -- "j" ganz @@ www.sailnow.com |
Fractional sailing?
"Capt. JG" wrote in message ... Sailing vessels are different from power vessels. I've owned trailer-sailers, and I've sailed with others who own them. They're not particularly difficult to launch/retrieve. I've never had to deal with transporting/launching a boat so I guess I'm pretty ignorant about what is involved. I'm glad to hear it isn't difficult as it adds another option for me. Thanks! |
Fractional sailing?
"Capt. JG" wrote
.... I've owned trailer-sailers, and I've sailed with others who own them. They're not particularly difficult to launch/retrieve. Some are, some aren't. A lot depends on size & type. "Steve" wrote: I've never had to deal with transporting/launching a boat so I guess I'm pretty ignorant about what is involved. I'm glad to hear it isn't difficult as it adds another option for me. Thanks! It's a good option to consider if dock space is at a premium in your area. I had several different trailerable boats for years.... decades, actually, looking back on it.... mostly on the smallish side because I prefer smaller economical tow vehicles. My wife and I sailed & cruised many 2 week vacations in a 19 footer, all over the East Coast. Your sailing area expands when you can go port-to-port at 65mph. OTOH the additional time involved in trailering & rigging & launching, plus the maintenance of the trailer which can cause catastrophic failure if overlooked or done poorly, convince many people that they want an "in-water" boat. It's a matter of setting your priorities. Fresh Breezes- Doug King |
Fractional sailing?
wrote in message
ps.com... "Capt. JG" wrote .... I've owned trailer-sailers, and I've sailed with others who own them. They're not particularly difficult to launch/retrieve. Some are, some aren't. A lot depends on size & type. Certainly, but I think it's more about time/patience rather than size/type. "Steve" wrote: I've never had to deal with transporting/launching a boat so I guess I'm pretty ignorant about what is involved. I'm glad to hear it isn't difficult as it adds another option for me. Thanks! It's a good option to consider if dock space is at a premium in your area. I had several different trailerable boats for years.... decades, actually, looking back on it.... mostly on the smallish side because I prefer smaller economical tow vehicles. My wife and I sailed & cruised many 2 week vacations in a 19 footer, all over the East Coast. Your sailing area expands when you can go port-to-port at 65mph. OTOH the additional time involved in trailering & rigging & launching, plus the maintenance of the trailer which can cause catastrophic failure if overlooked or done poorly, convince many people that they want an "in-water" boat. It's a matter of setting your priorities. Yeah, I stepped off the dock one time, mast in hand. -- "j" ganz @@ www.sailnow.com |
Fractional sailing?
Steve wrote:
"katy" wrote in message ... huh? Why wouldn't you be able to singlehand a trailer sailerable boat? We had an O'Day 22 and it was singlehanded all the time by either one of us...and we've had our boat on a mooring...what's the problem with that??? If you're worried about stepping the boat alone, it's really not that difficult when you use a come-along...It's a way to get around the waiting for a slip thing...you put the boat on the mooring and sail off it while waiting for your name to come up on the list...in fact, you will become a better sailor learning to sail on and off a can than you would coming and going from a dock.... My only experience with trailerable boats are the powered variety and that is definitely a two-person operation: one to sit in the boat and pilot it and one to back the trailer down the boat ramp into the water. For the mooring, I guess I didn't realize you could just drop a mooring somewhere offshore and use it indefinitely. Don't you need someone's permission? I've used moorings before but only those off Long Wharf in Boston Harbor and they were maintained by the sailing club. You don't need someone on the boat when you launch...wouldn't do any good anyway...you just use long docklines so it doesn't float away..and no, you cannot sink a mooring anywhere...I was speaking of dedicated morring fields...many municipal marinas have them in Michigan and some yacht clubs...sometimes you can lease one from a private property owner that has sunk one in front of their ;property if their lake association allows it... |
All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:57 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com