|
My new stand-on/give way list.
Jeff pointed out that the regular pecking order list that Captain Neal gives in his lessons isn't right.
So is every other pecking order list not right. Pedantic fer sure! But he has a good point. I think I agree with him. So I made a new list like it should be. Here it is. It summarizes rule 18. The classification below the line must avoid the ones above the line. NUC RAM FISH SAIL __________________ POWER NUC RAM FISH ___________________ SAIL NUC RAM ___________________ FISH NUC RAM _____________________ CBD NUC RAM CBD FISH SAIL POWER ________________________________ SEAPLANE NUC RAM CBD FISH SAIL POWER SEAPLANE ___________________________________________ WIG Cheers, Ellen |
My new stand-on/give way list.
Ellen MacArthur wrote: What .......no new pictures? Joe Jeff pointed out that the regular pecking order list that Captain Neal gives in his lessons isn't right. So is every other pecking order list not right. Pedantic fer sure! But he has a good point. I think I agree with him. So I made a new list like it should be. Here it is. It summarizes rule 18. The classification below the line must avoid the ones above the line. NUC RAM FISH SAIL __________________ POWER NUC RAM FISH ___________________ SAIL NUC RAM ___________________ FISH NUC RAM _____________________ CBD NUC RAM CBD FISH SAIL POWER ________________________________ SEAPLANE NUC RAM CBD FISH SAIL POWER SEAPLANE ___________________________________________ WIG Cheers, Ellen |
My new stand-on/give way list.
"Joe" wrote | | What .......no new pictures? Just for you and Scotty..... http://www.badongo.com/pic/337352 Cheers, Ellen |
My new stand-on/give way list.
You fail to note the potential difference between NUC and RAM.....probably
because you don't understand the potential difference since you are just reading words.. otn "Ellen MacArthur" wrote in message reenews.net... Jeff pointed out that the regular pecking order list that Captain Neal gives in his lessons isn't right. So is every other pecking order list not right. Pedantic fer sure! But he has a good point. I think I agree with him. So I made a new list like it should be. Here it is. It summarizes rule 18. The classification below the line must avoid the ones above the line. NUC RAM FISH SAIL __________________ POWER NUC RAM FISH ___________________ SAIL NUC RAM ___________________ FISH NUC RAM _____________________ CBD NUC RAM CBD FISH SAIL POWER ________________________________ SEAPLANE NUC RAM CBD FISH SAIL POWER SEAPLANE ___________________________________________ WIG Cheers, Ellen |
My new stand-on/give way list.
So close, and yet ...
Maybe the reason my point here is so hard to see is because it's represented by a clause that isn't there! otnmbrd wrote: You fail to note the potential difference between NUC and RAM.....probably because you don't understand the potential difference since you are just reading words.. otn "Ellen MacArthur" wrote in message reenews.net... Jeff pointed out that the regular pecking order list that Captain Neal gives in his lessons isn't right. So is every other pecking order list not right. Pedantic fer sure! But he has a good point. I think I agree with him. So I made a new list like it should be. Here it is. It summarizes rule 18. The classification below the line must avoid the ones above the line. NUC RAM FISH SAIL __________________ POWER .... |
My new stand-on/give way list.
"otnmbrd" wrote in message k.net... | You fail to note the potential difference between NUC and RAM.....probably | because you don't understand the potential difference since you are just | reading words.. I understand the difference. The rule tells me the difference. Rule 3 tells me NUC is unable to maneuver to comply with the Rules and unable to keep out of the way of other vessels. The Rule tells me RAM has restricted ability to maneuver to comply with the other Rules and is also unable to keep out of the way of other vessels. Like I said before.... NUC = unable/unable RAM + restricted/unable So it makes it look like NUC is really more handicapped. But it's looks only. What matters is the unable part when it comes to keeping out of the way of other vessels. Both NUC and RAM are unable to keep out of the way of another vessel. So what if it's for different reasons! Your trying to say RAM has to be kept out of the way of NUC . But that's impossible because RAM is unable to keep out of the way. Rule 3 says so.... You can't have it both ways. You talk about *potential difference*. Funny but Rule 3 doesn't say a thing about it. You just can't go around saying *I've tons of experience. I can see a potential difference. I don't care what the Rule says. I know better than the Rule. I can use my judgment and I can use Rule 2 to ignore all the other Rules. Those dummies should have put something in there about potential differences. They didn't but I'll just act like they did because I have loads of experience. And because Rule 2 says I can.* They just put Rule 2 in there to cover their butts. In case they forget to put something in the other Rules they have an out. Instead of saying they wrote crummy rules they can say people didn't use good judgment in applying their crummy Rules. Why not just have one Rule to cover it all? Duh! So here it is. My new 06Colregs... Let's get all the countries to sign on. Rule (1) Use good judgment! Rule (2) the end Cheers, Ellen |
My new stand-on/give way list.
"Jeff" wrote | Maybe the reason my point here is so hard to see is because it's | represented by a clause that isn't there! Who's the one sounding like a blonde now? :-) *Maybe the reason nobody adored my new diamond necklace is because I'm wearing pearls....* Cheers, Ellen |
My new stand-on/give way list.
You keep looking at the definition of NUC and RAM. Why don't you tell
us what their responsibility is with respect to each other? |
My new stand-on/give way list.
Ellen MacArthur wrote:
"Jeff" wrote | Maybe the reason my point here is so hard to see is because it's | represented by a clause that isn't there! Who's the one sounding like a blonde now? :-) *Maybe the reason nobody adored my new diamond necklace is because I'm wearing pearls....* Do I have to spell this out for you? For Neal's pecking order to be correct, there would have to be a clause that isn't there. |
My new stand-on/give way list.
"Jeff" wrote | You keep looking at the definition of NUC and RAM. Why don't you tell | us what their responsibility is with respect to each other? I thought I did that. I said that Rule 18 says: ( -: nothing about it :- ) Did you see in any of my new diagrams it listed? No you didn't because it says nothing about it in the rule. It never says NUC keep clear of RAM or vice versa. Another reason I say they're equal. So, if you insist on having a complete list it should look like this: NUC RAM ________ CBD FISH SAIL POWER SEAPLANE WIG But rule 18 never says that. It says what I said in my new stand on/give way list. It doesn't give a complete list. Cheers, Ellen |
| All times are GMT +1. The time now is 12:52 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com