BoatBanter.com

BoatBanter.com (https://www.boatbanter.com/)
-   ASA (https://www.boatbanter.com/asa/)
-   -   46 retirements (https://www.boatbanter.com/asa/26619-re-46-retirements.html)

Capt. Neal® December 28th 04 05:29 PM

46 retirements
 
I can see why! Somebody needs to teach those ******s how to bend
on a balanced sail plan and to get a boat with some staying power
in storm conditions.

CN


OzOne wrote in message ...
From a fleet of 116 in a savage Sydney Hobart race.

http://rolexsydneyhobart.com//default.asp?key=521


Oz1...of the 3 twins.

I welcome you to crackerbox palace,We've been expecting you.


Joe December 28th 04 05:44 PM

It's amazing. Almost half have thrown in the towel.

What a bunch of wussies. Here you dont quit until your de-masted, or
sunk, why take the risk to race far offshore if your not ready for the
worst. They must all be sailing flimsey junk or they just can not meet
the challenge, or both.

I suspect most are rich spoiled weekend warriors that bit off a might
bit to much than they can chew and a rolling in vomit on the main cabin
soles. But I bet the crews are wearing spiffy matching sailor suits.

Bwahahahahahah
Joe
MSV RedCloud- Never ever failed to finish a race.

Oh well


DSK December 28th 04 05:49 PM

Joe wrote:
It's amazing. Almost half have thrown in the towel.


The 'retired' list is 56 as of last report.


What a bunch of wussies.


Hardly.

... Here you dont quit until your de-masted, or
sunk,


Why don't you tell us about some of the offshore races you've sailed
personally, Joe.



I suspect most are rich spoiled weekend warriors


I suspect that you have no friggin' clue what you're talking about.


MSV RedCloud- Never ever failed to finish a race.


And how many is that, exactly?

More to the point, tell us how many races she's finished in 40+ knot
winds and 20+ foot breaking seas? For that matter, how often have you
sailed *any* boat in those conditions?

Fresh Breezes (to them wot kin use 'em)- Doug King


Joe December 28th 04 06:13 PM

Well Doug I've raced RedCloud in 3 Harvest Moon regetta around 250 mi
in the gulf and we had 12-15 footers... rails in the water , a few
boats other boats were de-masted and we kept racing I have no doubt
another 5 foot would have had much more affect. Our best was a third in
our class.

Many many week night bay races with winds higher than 40 knots, thats
why I have reefing points in my sails and several head sails.

Are you telling me that anyone who enters Hobart race should not
expect strong winds and large seas?

Joe


Capt. Neal® December 28th 04 08:58 PM

Face the facts, Oz! This years Hobart demonstrated how fragile racing boats
are and how dangerous it is to go to sea in them. It also shows a disregard for
life and limb and a disrespect for the sea.

It's not racing, it's stupidity and arrogance to think those flimsy boats even
have any business at sea. Keep them running round the buoys in a nice safe
harbor and they will be marginally acceptable. Allow them to go offshore
in one of the worlds roughest bodies of water and they will not be up to
the task.

Believe it!

CN


OzOne wrote in message ...
On Tue, 28 Dec 2004 12:29:09 -0500, Capt. Neal®
scribbled thusly:

I can see why! Somebody needs to teach those ******s how to bend
on a balanced sail plan and to get a boat with some staying power
in storm conditions.

CN


Yeah, and I can see that you've never raced a boat in your life, have
no idea what a challenge is,and have no experience sailing in anything
like what these guys are getting......hell, you wouldn't be here if
you had!


Oz1...of the 3 twins.

I welcome you to crackerbox palace,We've been expecting you.



John Cairns December 28th 04 09:11 PM


OzOne wrote in message ...
From a fleet of 116 in a savage Sydney Hobart race.

http://rolexsydneyhobart.com//default.asp?key=521


Oz1...of the 3 twins.

I welcome you to crackerbox palace,We've been expecting you.


http://www.toledoyachtclub.com/Mills...RE-REVISED.pdf

They had 53 either didn't start or withdrew. Out of 165. Horvath did this
one. Pretty nasty from what I've been told.

John Cairns



JG December 28th 04 09:17 PM

Neal's only challenge is to pretend well. Sadly, he can't even do that well.

--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com

OzOne wrote in message ...
On Tue, 28 Dec 2004 12:29:09 -0500, Capt. Neal®
scribbled thusly:

I can see why! Somebody needs to teach those ******s how to bend
on a balanced sail plan and to get a boat with some staying power
in storm conditions.

CN


Yeah, and I can see that you've never raced a boat in your life, have
no idea what a challenge is,and have no experience sailing in anything
like what these guys are getting......hell, you wouldn't be here if
you had!


Oz1...of the 3 twins.

I welcome you to crackerbox palace,We've been expecting you.




John Cairns December 28th 04 09:40 PM


"Capt. Neal®" wrote in message
...

It's not racing, it's stupidity and arrogance to think those flimsy boats
even
have any business at sea. Keep them running round the buoys in a nice safe
harbor and they will be marginally acceptable. Allow them to go offshore
in one of the worlds roughest bodies of water and they will not be up to
the task.

Believe it!

CN


This is hilarious, unintentionally, of course
..
http://community.webshots.com/photo/...29756597HYYFzU

Now, 25-30 kts. isn't a whole lot of wind, but we had a schedule to keep,
guess who we left in the harbor at san sal?

http://community.webshots.com/photo/...29752889EEUQzM

A Bristol 45.5

http://community.webshots.com/photo/...29752930zQMnIr

A Shannon 38

These folks allowed that they were going to wait for the weather to settle
down. They were/are cruisers, they sail cruising boats. If the Sydney-Hobart
event had been a cruising rally like the Carribbean 1500, for example, NO
ONE WOULD HAVE LEFT PORT. Btw, a fair % of the boat that do the
Sydney-Hobart RACE are cruising boats.

John Cairns



OzOne wrote in message
...
On Tue, 28 Dec 2004 12:29:09 -0500, Capt. Neal®
scribbled thusly:

I can see why! Somebody needs to teach those ******s how to bend
on a balanced sail plan and to get a boat with some staying power
in storm conditions.

CN


Yeah, and I can see that you've never raced a boat in your life, have
no idea what a challenge is,and have no experience sailing in anything
like what these guys are getting......hell, you wouldn't be here if
you had!


Oz1...of the 3 twins.

I welcome you to crackerbox palace,We've been expecting you.





Horvath December 28th 04 10:21 PM

On Tue, 28 Dec 2004 21:11:11 GMT, "John Cairns"
wrote this crap:


http://www.toledoyachtclub.com/Mills...RE-REVISED.pdf

They had 53 either didn't start or withdrew. Out of 165. Horvath did this
one. Pretty nasty from what I've been told.

John Cairns



I've seen worse.






Pathetic Earthlings! No one can save you now!

Joe December 28th 04 10:29 PM


wrote:
On 28 Dec 2004 10:13:13 -0800, "Joe" wrote:

... rails in the water


Both rails? Turn on your bilge pump, dummy!

BB


Not at the same time brainiac.

Joe


Joe December 28th 04 10:40 PM


wrote:
On 28 Dec 2004 14:29:40 -0800, "Joe" wrote:


wrote:
On 28 Dec 2004 10:13:13 -0800, "Joe"

wrote:

... rails in the water

Both rails? Turn on your bilge pump, dummy!

BB


Not at the same time brainiac.

Joe


Well, now that you have established clearly that you are the dummy

and I'm the
brainiac, what else can I help you with, you defenseless mooron?

BB


Yeah your a real brainiac Bob.


Capt. Neal® December 29th 04 12:22 AM


OzOne wrote in message ...

Yep, they get like that.
We're now up to 54 retired and a number who took shelter during the
worst of the storms have now resumed racing.
It looks like the 93' super maxi Skandia Wild Thing will be a total
loss after being abandoned.
She had a failure in the keel canting mechanism which locked it off to
one side, she was abandoned when it was feared she would capsize in
the wild seas and this was later proven a prudent move, as she did
capsize after her keel broke off.



Canting keels are just another bad idea. A real sailor would engineer
a system to kant the mast, not the keel.

CN

Joe December 29th 04 12:39 AM


wrote:
On 28 Dec 2004 14:40:30 -0800, "Joe" wrote:


wrote:
On 28 Dec 2004 14:29:40 -0800, "Joe"

wrote:


wrote:
On 28 Dec 2004 10:13:13 -0800, "Joe"

wrote:

... rails in the water

Both rails? Turn on your bilge pump, dummy!

BB

Not at the same time brainiac.

Joe

Well, now that you have established clearly that you are the dummy

and I'm the
brainiac, what else can I help you with, you defenseless mooron?

BB


Yeah your a real brainiac Bob.


That would be "you're", ****wad.

BB



OK You're a ****wad Bob


DSK December 29th 04 02:36 PM

Joe wrote:
Well Doug I've raced RedCloud in 3 Harvest Moon regetta around 250 mi
in the gulf and we had 12-15 footers... rails in the water , a few
boats other boats were de-masted and we kept racing I have no doubt
another 5 foot would have had much more affect. Our best was a third in
our class.


OK, now think... the Sydney-Hobart has sailors coming from all over the
world to compete. It is one of the toughest races. Does the Harvest Moon
regatta even bring a lot of regional interest? How many boats race in
it? How many different clubs represented?

Not trying to diss the Harvest Moon race, but it is not at all even
close to the same scale event.


Many many week night bay races with winds higher than 40 knots, thats
why I have reefing points in my sails and several head sails.


Do week night races take you over open sea, with current, and take you
on a course beating into 40+ knot winds for hours at a time?


Are you telling me that anyone who enters Hobart race should not
expect strong winds and large seas?


No, I'm saying a piddey local racer who thinks he's tough because he's
sailed in piddley local races should not bad-mouth world class talent in
the toughest sailboat race on the planet.

For one thing, all it does is make you look dumb.

DSK


DSK December 29th 04 03:25 PM

Crap'n Neal® wrote:
Canting keels are just another bad idea.


You're speaking from the standpoint of your vast knowledge of naval
architecture & engineering?


... A real sailor would engineer
a system to kant the mast, not the keel.


First of all it's been done... so much for your knowledge and experience.

Secondly, why would canting the mast be better? Heeling the hull would
degrade steering & leeway resistance, and add lots of hydrodynamic drag.

Think! It's difficult & painful but it's better than the alternative.

Fresh Breezes
Doug King


Joe December 29th 04 03:51 PM

Most Harvest moon races have around 200-300 boats. I'm not a Yacht Club
member and could care less how many Yacht clubs enter the race, There
are several, I can tell by the little flags and cute colorful matching
sailor suits the crews wear, I've seen many cross the finish line
usually several hours and drinks after we crossed it. The race is
sponsered by Baccardi.

OK now think.....If you travel half way across the world to RACE would
you not finish what you started? I would.

Now if you want to hold high esteem for quiters and losers feel free, I
just think many of the people in the race are weekend warriors with
more money than skills and fortatude.

If you want to have respect for sailors who do not understand the
abilitys of the vessels they sail, then go ahead.

Every year I raced the harvest moon we raced against another Ketch
called the Lone Star Love, the owners were quite proud that they had
raced the Hobart. Ever year we finished just ahead of them. They had a
300K boat, fancy sailor suits, and 5+ more years than I racing the
Harvest moon.

Ill respect the people who finish what they started, the others are
just wussies and wannabes.

Joe


DSK December 30th 04 01:58 AM

"Joe" scribbled thusly:
Most Harvest moon races have around 200-300 boats.


How many are sober?

How long is the Harvest Moon race? How many rocky capes does it pass,
and what kind of currents over that area?

OzOne wrote:
Ummm, here, and in all races that have any worth, you must be a member
of a yacht club to enter.


I dunnoe about "of any worth" but it does show a more serious attitude
about sailing that so many people who are serious enough to do a lot of
racing in their clubs.

I bet the Harvest Moon draws a large crowd of people for whom it's their
only race of the year.


I'm surprised that there are "many" boats slower than your floating
caravan...guess it's because it's a picnic race.


It's a PHRF race. Says it all IMHO.


OK now think.....If you travel half way across the world to RACE would
you not finish what you started? I would.



Sure you would, without a mast, broken rudders, cracked hull and
bulkheads.....sure you would.


I think at some point, the wise man says to himself and his crew, "It's
more important to get home in one piece than to finish."


Thing is, these guys are racers, they seek safety when they know that
their boat is or has reached her limit..or passed it!


And they know when that is. A dumbo-macho attitude is a sure way to end
up in big trouble.


Now if you want to hold high esteem for quiters and losers feel free


Joe, this is one of the toughest races over one of the toughest parts of
ocean in the world. I'd give a nod of respect to anybody who had made
the passage, much less completed the race. Yet you feel compelled to
insult & belittle others.

... I
just think many of the people in the race are weekend warriors with
more money than skills and fortatude.


No doubt because that's what you see in your local races?



Some are people who do the race every year just for the hell of it.
They are smart enough to know that when Bass Strait gets wild, you
don't go out there in any boat for fun.


Maybe a submarine...


If you want to have respect for sailors who do not understand the
abilitys of the vessels they sail


Hey Joe, what's you're boat's Ballast/Disp ratio again? You seem to not
be able to answer questions about how you sail your boat hard to
windward in 40+ knot winds and 20+ foot breaking seas.


Ill respect the people who finish what they started, the others are
just wussies and wannabes.


Maybe you should suggest to President Bush that he find Osama Bin Laden.



I respect people who know that when the boom, gooseneck,mast or hull
is broken that they can't continue.
I also have great respect for those who recognise their and their
boats abilities and chose not to continue into Bass Strait out of
bravado...or fear of being called a wussie or wannabee by some
uninformed, totally ignorant clown.


Part of the problem here is that Joe (and others of the same stripe) do
not understand their own boats true capabilities, much less others. They
want to play the game both ways- darn candy-ass racers are just a bunch
of quitters... and the ones that break something are sailing flimsy
cockleshells... they hate racing and racers, probably out of a
well-deserved sense of inferiority.

Fresh Breezes- Doug King



All times are GMT +1. The time now is 07:13 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com