BoatBanter.com

BoatBanter.com (https://www.boatbanter.com/)
-   ASA (https://www.boatbanter.com/asa/)
-   -   Big Cause of Radar Clutter (https://www.boatbanter.com/asa/18052-big-cause-radar-clutter.html)

JaxAshby October 24th 03 01:30 AM

Big Cause of Radar Clutter
 
Guess what the biggest cause of close in radar clutter is.

It's your radar reflector.

It also clutters the radars of other close by boats.

Causes many accidents. Take it down and see for yourself.

Takes a Mensa guy to figure that one out.

Yeppers sure does.

Jax



JaxAshby October 24th 03 03:32 AM

Big Cause of Radar Clutter
 
That radar beam only has a beam of angle beginning at a good distance from
the antenna, typically tens of feet.

Also, there's multiple beams and power outside the specified beam angle.

Your advice is good, are you in Mensa?

Jax

"Schoonertrash" wrote in message ...
Radar beams have a horizontal dimension and a vertical dimension measured

in
degrees of beam angle. Place the radar reflector above or below the
vertical angle to reduce or do away with clutter caused by the reflector.
Also, nine out of ten reflectors are useless anyway as they are improperly
mounted. The common ones should be placed in the rain catcher position

with
one of the eight tri corners up and one down leaving the remaining six to
reflect with maximum efficiency. The second problem is low placement. Even
at 120 feet or so above sea level it's difficult for our 3cm (12 miles and
less for close in work) and 10 cm (out to 24 miles working range) systems

to
reflect off objects buried in the trough or to discern objects lost in the
surface clutter of the ocean. Back to placement. High is better than
low. Radars, CARD Radar detection systems, and reflectors all work better
when placed as high as is possible on your boat. For radars a gimbaled
mount is the best choice but spendy. To close to the bridge deck or hull
and cabin top and clutter will always result. Higher mountings increase
range and improve the value of the display. For reflectors: if you have

a
hollow wooden mast consider stuffing the interior with crumpled aluminum
foil (standard kitchen variety) you probably won't need the exterior
versions. For metal masts try using double reflectors mounted port and
starboard just under the cross trees and inside the shrouds. Seems to work
just fine.

Little practical common sense is a fine compliment to skull sweat.



"JaxAshby" wrote in message
ink.net...
Guess what the biggest cause of close in radar clutter is.

It's your radar reflector.

It also clutters the radars of other close by boats.

Causes many accidents. Take it down and see for yourself.

Takes a Mensa guy to figure that one out.

Yeppers sure does.

Jax







Jeff Morris October 24th 03 03:49 AM

Big Cause of Radar Clutter
 
Jeeze Gilly, doesn't it get crowded in there?

Not that I'm complaining ... its always entertaining ... but I do get concerned


"JaxAshby" wrote in message
ink.net...
Guess what the biggest cause of close in radar clutter is.

It's your radar reflector.

It also clutters the radars of other close by boats.

Causes many accidents. Take it down and see for yourself.

Takes a Mensa guy to figure that one out.

Yeppers sure does.

Jax





Vito October 24th 03 05:10 PM

Big Cause of Radar Clutter
 
Schoonertrash wrote:

No, I work on commercial ships and live on sailboats. I'm sure someone will explain it shortly.

"JaxAshby" wrote
That radar beam only has a beam of angle beginning at a good distance from
the antenna, typically tens of feet.
Also, there's multiple beams and power outside the specified beam angle.


"Schoonertrash" wrote in message ...
Radar beams have a horizontal dimension and a vertical dimension measured in
degrees of beam angle.


The dimensions mentioned are usually the loci of the half power points;
ie, points where the power is half that at beam center equdistant from
the antenna. A short distance outside these "dimensions" there is still
0.04 then 0.03, etc as much power as at the center and even 0.1 may be
much more than found at beam center 20 miles out.

Schoonertrash October 25th 03 02:31 AM

Big Cause of Radar Clutter
 
Radar beams have a horizontal dimension and a vertical dimension measured in
degrees of beam angle. Place the radar reflector above or below the
vertical angle to reduce or do away with clutter caused by the reflector.
Also, nine out of ten reflectors are useless anyway as they are improperly
mounted. The common ones should be placed in the rain catcher position with
one of the eight tri corners up and one down leaving the remaining six to
reflect with maximum efficiency. The second problem is low placement. Even
at 120 feet or so above sea level it's difficult for our 3cm (12 miles and
less for close in work) and 10 cm (out to 24 miles working range) systems to
reflect off objects buried in the trough or to discern objects lost in the
surface clutter of the ocean. Back to placement. High is better than
low. Radars, CARD Radar detection systems, and reflectors all work better
when placed as high as is possible on your boat. For radars a gimbaled
mount is the best choice but spendy. To close to the bridge deck or hull
and cabin top and clutter will always result. Higher mountings increase
range and improve the value of the display. For reflectors: if you have a
hollow wooden mast consider stuffing the interior with crumpled aluminum
foil (standard kitchen variety) you probably won't need the exterior
versions. For metal masts try using double reflectors mounted port and
starboard just under the cross trees and inside the shrouds. Seems to work
just fine.

Little practical common sense is a fine compliment to skull sweat.



"JaxAshby" wrote in message
ink.net...
Guess what the biggest cause of close in radar clutter is.

It's your radar reflector.

It also clutters the radars of other close by boats.

Causes many accidents. Take it down and see for yourself.

Takes a Mensa guy to figure that one out.

Yeppers sure does.

Jax





Schoonertrash October 25th 03 03:55 AM

Big Cause of Radar Clutter
 
No, I work on commercial ships and live on sailboats. I'm sure someone will
explain it shortly.


"JaxAshby" wrote in message
ink.net...
That radar beam only has a beam of angle beginning at a good distance from
the antenna, typically tens of feet.

Also, there's multiple beams and power outside the specified beam angle.

Your advice is good, are you in Mensa?

Jax

"Schoonertrash" wrote in message ...
Radar beams have a horizontal dimension and a vertical dimension

measured
in
degrees of beam angle. Place the radar reflector above or below the
vertical angle to reduce or do away with clutter caused by the

reflector.
Also, nine out of ten reflectors are useless anyway as they are

improperly
mounted. The common ones should be placed in the rain catcher position

with
one of the eight tri corners up and one down leaving the remaining six

to
reflect with maximum efficiency. The second problem is low placement.

Even
at 120 feet or so above sea level it's difficult for our 3cm (12 miles

and
less for close in work) and 10 cm (out to 24 miles working range)

systems
to
reflect off objects buried in the trough or to discern objects lost in

the
surface clutter of the ocean. Back to placement. High is better than
low. Radars, CARD Radar detection systems, and reflectors all work

better
when placed as high as is possible on your boat. For radars a gimbaled
mount is the best choice but spendy. To close to the bridge deck or

hull
and cabin top and clutter will always result. Higher mountings increase
range and improve the value of the display. For reflectors: if you

have
a
hollow wooden mast consider stuffing the interior with crumpled aluminum
foil (standard kitchen variety) you probably won't need the exterior
versions. For metal masts try using double reflectors mounted port and
starboard just under the cross trees and inside the shrouds. Seems to

work
just fine.

Little practical common sense is a fine compliment to skull sweat.



"JaxAshby" wrote in message
ink.net...
Guess what the biggest cause of close in radar clutter is.

It's your radar reflector.

It also clutters the radars of other close by boats.

Causes many accidents. Take it down and see for yourself.

Takes a Mensa guy to figure that one out.

Yeppers sure does.

Jax










All times are GMT +1. The time now is 10:03 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com