Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Gaff sails?
Hi Tim,
I just looked at the main panel layout on Lady K. and it struck me that the main seams were not running as I expected. What's the story? Cheers MC |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Gaff sails?
Either:
can you be more specific? Which photo, what were you expecting? Or: If referring to "vertical" seams: Vertical of course was traditional, until cross-cut demonstrated its superiority in the old fabrics. With dacron, I am told that unless one is seeking the absolutely last iota of aerodynamic efficiency, the direction of the seaming makes almost no difference at all with modern materials, modern seaming and heavy cloth (which Lady Kates main certainly is!). As it's a gaff sail, and one is giving up a degree of aerodynamic and pointing perfection for a larger area lower down (lower heeling moment/area) and ease of rigging and handling, and to boot it as a tree-trunk at the leading edge, the sail was vertical seamed. (the authority for "I am told" was Ken O'Brien). There are also supposed to be advantages in the event of a tear, but I don't believe that. Flying Tadpole's gaff sails and flying jib mit club were also vertically cut, but her main staysail cross-cut. Flying Tadpole The navigator© wrote: Hi Tim, I just looked at the main panel layout on Lady K. and it struck me that the main seams were not running as I expected. What's the story? Cheers MC |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Gaff sails?
Yes, I was expecting cross cut as you are using Dacron. BUT seaming is
still very important... e.g. http://woodsdesignssailingcatamarans.com/rigs.htm " In the old days of cotton gaff sails the cloth was weak and thus seams ran vertically so, if they tore, the sail would not break in half. With the advent of Dacron/Terylene, cross cut sails came into vogue partly because these were (and still are) cheap to produce. More recently computer sail design packages and laser cutters have made it easy for sail lofts to make sails with more exotic panel layouts. " Nevertheless i would have thought that with an inefficient rig, sail shape would be even more critical and twist/draft control very important. Even though Lady Kate would go very well downwind with any (or even no) sail don't you want a bit more going to wind -or are all your ports downwind... Cheers MC Flying Tadpole wrote: Either: can you be more specific? Which photo, what were you expecting? Or: If referring to "vertical" seams: Vertical of course was traditional, until cross-cut demonstrated its superiority in the old fabrics. With dacron, I am told that unless one is seeking the absolutely last iota of aerodynamic efficiency, the direction of the seaming makes almost no difference at all with modern materials, modern seaming and heavy cloth (which Lady Kates main certainly is!). As it's a gaff sail, and one is giving up a degree of aerodynamic and pointing perfection for a larger area lower down (lower heeling moment/area) and ease of rigging and handling, and to boot it as a tree-trunk at the leading edge, the sail was vertical seamed. (the authority for "I am told" was Ken O'Brien). There are also supposed to be advantages in the event of a tear, but I don't believe that. Flying Tadpole's gaff sails and flying jib mit club were also vertically cut, but her main staysail cross-cut. Flying Tadpole The navigator© wrote: Hi Tim, I just looked at the main panel layout on Lady K. and it struck me that the main seams were not running as I expected. What's the story? Cheers MC |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Gaff sails?
Well, MC, I agree with all you say, as it was also what I
thought. However, in the case of Flying Tadpole II (Lady Kate already had her suit) I took the advice of the sailmaker instead, possibly because, as the sailmaker responsible for breaking the hearts of the NYYC I felt he might know more than I, or possibly because he learnt a few things from his uncle Conor that I mightn't know in relation to cruising sails. Mind you, I normally refuse to bow to authority unless it's approaching celestial, but in this case I did not feel my own experience and thoughts were defensible... BTW, you appear to be still defining "efficiency" purely in terms of extracting the maximum degree of weatherliness (70 degrees?). Being naturally indolent, I tend to regard an efficient rig as one which limits the demands on crew, machinery, rigging and hull, while still providing a good degree of weatherliness (90 degrees). Flying Tadpole The navigator© wrote: Yes, I was expecting cross cut as you are using Dacron. BUT seaming is still very important... e.g. http://woodsdesignssailingcatamarans.com/rigs.htm " In the old days of cotton gaff sails the cloth was weak and thus seams ran vertically so, if they tore, the sail would not break in half. With the advent of Dacron/Terylene, cross cut sails came into vogue partly because these were (and still are) cheap to produce. More recently computer sail design packages and laser cutters have made it easy for sail lofts to make sails with more exotic panel layouts. " Nevertheless i would have thought that with an inefficient rig, sail shape would be even more critical and twist/draft control very important. Even though Lady Kate would go very well downwind with any (or even no) sail don't you want a bit more going to wind -or are all your ports downwind... Cheers MC Flying Tadpole wrote: Either: can you be more specific? Which photo, what were you expecting? Or: If referring to "vertical" seams: Vertical of course was traditional, until cross-cut demonstrated its superiority in the old fabrics. With dacron, I am told that unless one is seeking the absolutely last iota of aerodynamic efficiency, the direction of the seaming makes almost no difference at all with modern materials, modern seaming and heavy cloth (which Lady Kates main certainly is!). As it's a gaff sail, and one is giving up a degree of aerodynamic and pointing perfection for a larger area lower down (lower heeling moment/area) and ease of rigging and handling, and to boot it as a tree-trunk at the leading edge, the sail was vertical seamed. (the authority for "I am told" was Ken O'Brien). There are also supposed to be advantages in the event of a tear, but I don't believe that. Flying Tadpole's gaff sails and flying jib mit club were also vertically cut, but her main staysail cross-cut. Flying Tadpole The navigator© wrote: Hi Tim, I just looked at the main panel layout on Lady K. and it struck me that the main seams were not running as I expected. What's the story? Cheers MC |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
tyvek sails? | Boat Building | |||
HELP! Need suggestions on making mast & sails | Boat Building | |||
EARTHSHIP SAILS IN VALENCIA, SPAIN APRIL 2004 EARTHSHIP SAILS IN VALENCIA, SPAIN APRIL 2004 | Cruising |