pjb, this is a no-brainer for me. I've owned both and the only really good
thing I can say for an inflatable is that they fit much better into a small
airplane for remote trips. Otherwise, here is the list of advantages the
Appy has over the duck:

1) it's dryer
2) it carries more bulk
3) it keeps your gear dryer
4) it's MUCH faster
5) it's MUCH more maneuverable, esp. w/ a load
6) it can hold three or four extra kids for short trips
7) It's much faster
8) it's much more rewarding to paddle
9) with float bags and thigh straps it is a great ww tandem boat
10) it's considerably cheaper
11) a hole in it won't put you on the beach
11) it's much faster
12) you don't have to drag aroun a pump
13) it won't explode on a hot day
14) it's much faster
15) nobody will quack at you on the river

If you'd rather bounce off rocks than glide safely by, get a duck.
Padeen



d" wrote in message
news:hqede.8510$fI.7464@fed1read05...
I'm trying to make a decision on a canoe purchase and I hope someone in
this
group can offer some advice and perhaps opinions.



I live and canoe rivers in the southwest United States and northwest
Mexico.
Places like the Green, San Juan, and Yaqui Rivers. I'm usually out for a
week, give or take a day, and with one or two other two person boats in
our
parties. As you can imagine, rivers here vary considerably depending upon
the water year and other factors. We generally run up to class three
rapids
and often have to drag boats over rocks in some shallow reaches. We also
occasionally T-bone a boulder or two while on the water. The conditions
can
be hard on canoes.



In the past I've used Old Town Appalachians
(http://www.otccanoe.com/canoes_appalachian.php) and Mad River
Revelations,
which I think has been replaced by the Explorer 16rx
(http://www.madrivercanoe.com/zoom_bo...orer_16_rx.jpg), both
16
ft Royalex boats. We are carrying a lot of gear, but also need
maneuverability in swift water.



On a trip last year, some friends brought a SOAR 16 ft inflatable boat
(http://www.soar1.com/soar_16.htm). I was extremely impressed with how
forgiving it was on rocks and its handling in some rapids that we in the
Royalex boats needed to line. It's also self bailing which of course
helps
when we take on some water in the middle of a run. The downside is, it's
more expensive, and although SOAR claims it has a cargo capacity of 17 +
cubic feet, it certainly carried less gear than the thin hulled Old Towns
and Mad Rivers. I've also been told that being an inflatable, they are
slugs in a headwind, something we invariably get a day or two of on any
trips.



My choice is coming down to the Appalachian and the SOAR 16. I'd like to
hear any recommendations on the boats, as well as necessary accessories
for
either one. I also sea kayak so I have the usual stuff, PFDs, dry bags,
etc. For accessories I'm thinking more along the lines of seat upgrades,
expedition repair kits, etc.



Thanks in advance.



pjb


--
Too many spams have forced me to alter my email. If you wish to email me
directly please send messages to pjbphd at cox dot net